3 ms·
What are the effects of this, if passed, on the rest of the world using Office 365, Facebook or AWS? It might be impossible to reconcile with some regulation in
by fulafel 6y ago
What are the effects of this, if passed, on the rest of the world using Office 365, Facebook or AWS? It might be impossible to reconcile with some regulation in eg the EU.
- Cthulhu_ 6y agoI hope (fingers crossed) that the encryption laws will simply not apply to the EU. I mean most US companies operate via an intermediate company hosted in e.g. Ireland or the Netherlands already, so I reckon legally they can disregard these bills. Of course, if the US government starts to offer money for data, they may budge anyways. I'm fairly sure MOST data can freely be shared with the US, it's just government data and higher level company data that isn't allowed to cross the borders.
- hedora 6y agohttps://www.linklaters.com/en/insights/blogs/digilinks/2019/september/us-cloud-act-and-gdpr-is-the-cloud-still-safe https://www.linklaters.com/en/insights/blogs/digilinks/2019/... Tl;dr: For most data, the cloud vendor is basically forced to violate either the cloud act or the gpdr. The gpdr has a bunch of fuzzy carve outs for requests involving people in danger or the “public interest”. My guess is that those will be expanded over time to force the data to be handed over, regardless. If the data isn’t “personal information” (financial records aren’t, for example), GPDR doesn’t apply and the warrant must be served. I think this means that, because they could hypothetically receive a warrant they have to serve, the Ireland/EU intermediary (or the US company that provides them with the software/hardware) will have to backdoor the encryption. I am not a lawyer, and I haven’t even read any of these bills. I’m just piecing together summaries. I don’t think anyone really knows how the three bills will interact in practice.
- michaelmrose 6y agoLogically it means that most of planet earth abandons our technologies and our companies. Locking out their best and brightest simultaneously give them an even better chance to exploit this opportunity.