3 ms·
Dammit just give me the numbers. This should be an entirely mathematical exercise. I shouldn’t have to scroll through weird Star Wars text and a story about stu
by rayiner 6y ago
Dammit just give me the numbers. This should be an entirely mathematical exercise. I shouldn’t have to scroll through weird Star Wars text and a story about student protesters in 1970 to see what the basis for your number is. What on earth is wrong with journalists?
This is a very complicated subject. Here is an analysis that shows the contrary result: https://www.econlib.org/the-real-wage-myth https://www.econlib.org/the-real-wage-myth. One important observation: looking at wages alone, like the article does, excludes the value of benefits such as healthcare:
> BTW, these time series understate the growth in total labor compensation, as the cost of fringe benefits such as health care has risen faster than nominal wage growth. Alternatively, if you believe that health benefits are nearly worthless (my view), then the nominal wage series should be deflated by a price index that excludes health care. That would show even more rapid growth in real wages.
Basically, at the very least you’re not comparing like with like. Either include the value of health benefits in compensation, or exclude the contribution of healthcare in overall economic growth. There are also numerous other mathematical complexities. You need to adjust wages for inflation (using some index) and convert GDP to current dollars (using some index) but generally different indexes are used for the two. You also need to pick a baseline. 1970 is often used, but that was a recessionary period. Counter-intuitively, the ratio of wages to the overall economy is highest during recessions. Also, it’s not just workers and owners in the pirate ship analogy. Landowners also get a cut and their cut is growing. Accounting for both effects, the share of income going to non-housing capital owners is up a bit, but was about the same in 2005 as in 1960: http://voxeu.org/sites/default/files/image/FromMay2014/lacavafig1.png http://voxeu.org/sites/default/files/image/FromMay2014/lacav...
I’m not sure what the right answer is. What I’m sure about is that cobbled together vignettes sprinkled with uncited, unexplained numbers that are more garnish than substance does not help anyone understand the issue at all. It’s empty calories.
- TedDoesntTalk 6y agoI agree, but they need that emotional appeal... otherwise the numbers might not be convincing enough?
- scoopdewoop 6y agoThe numbers already exist and have existed. It is their job to be journalists, convey a comprehensible narrative from facts. Also keep in mind that is the opinion section. I doubt the author would object to changes in tax structure, etc. to grow more home ownership. Why not putting people in houses and unions? Do you think that unions are not effective?
- rayiner 6y ago> It is their job to be journalists, convey a comprehensible narrative from facts. This is not a comprehensible narrative. What the heck is a random aside about student protesters in the 1970s doing in the middle of—what? An advocacy piece about tax structure? Can you imagine if your boss asked you to put together a white paper on some issue to present to management, and you presented her something like this, with a few facts facts thrown in randomly between irrelevant filler anecdotes? If you want to tell stories, then fine. If you want to write advocacy white papers making a factual argument, fine. But this is neither thing. It’s a hybrid form that uses narrative and anecdote to fill in for the extremely thin facts and analysis. What is the social value of this type of writing? As to unions: what do they have to do with anything? Many countries with strong unions have see a similar or even greater decline in labor share of income. The US is not really much different than any other advanced economy on that front: https://www.mckinsey.com/~/media/mckinsey/featured%20insights/employment%20and%20growth/a%20new%20look%20at%20the%20declining%20labor%20share%20of%20income%20in%20the%20united%20states/mgi-a-new-look-at-the-declining-labor-share-of-income-in-the-united-states.ashx https://www.mckinsey.com/~/media/mckinsey/featured%20insight.... In the US, labor’s share of income is less than France, about the same as Germany, and more than Spain. It’s significantly higher than Sweden, which has robust unions. Moreover, nearly all the decline in labor’s share of income happened between 2000 and today. The decrease was very slight from 1947 to 2000. But unions stopped being a significant force in the US long before 2000.