Re-reading this, I realise I've got the bit about carbon reducing oxide ions wrong. The oxide ions are being oxidised here, not reduced. But ending up at CO2 ra

Re-reading this, I realise I've got the bit about carbon reducing oxide ions wrong. The oxide ions are being oxidised here, not reduced. But ending up at CO2 rather than O2 means they don't need to be oxidised as hard - oxygen in CO2 is a bit more reduced than in O2. I think. I probably wouldn't pass A level chemistry if I sat the exams today. When neutral carbon and oxygen react, the carbon reduces the oxygen because it gives it a fractional share of its electrons when they form a bond. But when oxygen is charged, it already has lots of electrons. In this reaction the carbon is helping oxidise the oxide ions.