9 ms·
I think politicians must win prizes or something for showing who is the stupidest: > The bill also allows the attorney general to create a competition with a p
by hn_throwaway_99 6y ago
I think politicians must win prizes or something for showing who is the stupidest:
> The bill also allows the attorney general to create a competition with a prize for anyone who can come up with a way to access encrypted data while protecting privacy and security. Security experts have long noted that this is an impossible request.
Why they're at in, why don't they push a bill for permanent rainbows.
Also, the article states "The proposed legislation stops short of requiring tech companies to create a backdoor", so if end-to-end encryption is still available, this legislation does nothing. And if lawmakers try to ban end-to-end encryption, well then "banning math" should be the name of this legislation (yes, I realize politicians have tried to do that before). Sure, large companies may comply and average joes may get less E2E encryption, but anyone who knows anything about tech will be able to get access to E2E encrypted messengers.
- tux1968 6y agoDon't attribute to stupidity that which can be explained by malice. It's only stupid if you accept their ostensible rationale, but it makes perfect sense if they're trying to pry open the data of the average citizen, not some mythical terrorist.
- srmatto 6y ago>"a prize for anyone who can come up with a way to access encrypted data while protecting privacy and security." A prize for a cake that can be eaten but will never be consumed.
- solotronics 6y agoI think nanobots could accomplish this. The end result might be unexpected though...
- kevin_thibedeau 6y agoIt should be a square pie.
- fnord123 6y agoEach time you want an encrypted session you need to make a request to the government third party key signing service that, with your public key, the public counterparty's key and a government generated key for your session, a new key for the session is produced. It's possible but potentially expensive and has issues with who gets keys on international communication. And it's also dumb.
- chrisshroba 6y agoSerious question (about practicality, not ethics): people always say that it's impossible to provide government access to encrypted data without opening a huge security hole for hackers to exploit. Why couldn't an encryption scheme be used that, for decryption, requires either a) the user's private key (a usual), or b) some sort of combination of private keys of all the relevant government entities required to authorize accessing the user's data? So that something like the combination of a judicial private key and an fbi private key were required to access the data? Of course the data would still be hackable if a bad actor were to get their hands on both of those keys, but security could be increased by, for example, increasing the number of parties needed to authorize the access. (Please don't critique the ethical premise here - I make no claim that this is the "right" thing to do, just that it could be plausible)
- free_rms 6y agoThat's exactly it, it's very possible, but all the eggs would be in one basket. Scheme: multiple copies of symmetric key followed by symmetrically encrypted body (pgp-style). One copy of the symmetric key is secured by user's private key, another is wrapped in an onion of all required "side" keys. The issue is that the government-held keys only need to be exposed once, and then someone has a key to all of everything, everywhere.
- slg 6y agoThey mentioned having multiple keys with different government organizations. What if there are 12 keys and you need 6 keys to decrypt the data. The user has 6 keys. The company that created the device or service has 2 keys, the judicial branch has 2 keys, and the executive branch has 2 keys. All of the non-user keys are required to be in different systems. The compromise of any one system still requires cooperation from the non-user groups to decrypt. You couple that with some system that allows the data to be decrypted and reencrypted with new keys in the case of a breech of keys. You can add as many keys to this scenario as you want until you feel like a breech of the necessary number of keys is not going to happen. Are we sure a system along these lines is impossible?
- clarkmoody 6y ago> Security experts have long noted that this is an impossible request. You know, this could be a total political cover move. Pass some bill that makes it seem like tech companies will open comms to law enforcement, but make sure it doesn't actually work. Then, you can campaign on being tough on crime in November, and if somebody ever brings up the topic later, you can blame the biased big-tech firms for not wanting to work with Republicans. So encryption tech can't deliver permanent rainbows, but the politicians get them anyway.
- suizi 6y agoThrow lots of dirt at a wall and see what sticks.
- thephyber 6y agoLegislators don't have to show up to court to defend their dumb laws, so there's no requirement that their statute have any semblance of coherence. Government attorneys show up to court after some poor citizen spends a ton of money on legal fees to challenge a bad faith law. Worse yet, some bad faith laws are crafted in such a way that no (living) person has standing to bring it to court to challenge the statute.
- chrismorgan 6y agoOn “banning math” and that “politicians have tried to do that before”: I suspect you are referring at least in part to what the Australian Prime Minister said in 2017: > The laws of Australia prevail in Australia, I can assure you of that. The laws of mathematics are very commendable, but the only law that applies in Australia is the law of Australia. This particular statement was widely lampooned in tech circles at the time as obvious nonsense. Yet it’s actually perfectly sound: legislation is all about restricting you from doing things that are possible. (Now some of the other stuff Mr. Turnbull said at that time was drivel; he seemed to be under the impression that it was possible to allow law enforcement to access end-to-end encrypted content without it comprising a backdoor, which the industry as a whole considers axiomatically false.) It’s the government’s prerogative to ban mathematics. And indeed they already have in various areas due to copyright and possibly patent laws (c.f. illegal numbers). Now I personally think they would be unwise to ban any form of encryption, but realise that they’re quite at liberty to not just try to ban it.
- boringg 6y agoThe only laws that can't be broken are the laws of physics.
- ithkuil 6y agoBut can punish a person for doing an act that is perfectly legit under the laws of physics
- justinclift 6y agoOf course. If you drop a large weight on someone from a great height, that's generally seen as a problem. ;)
- awinder 6y agoIt’s a stupid statement because he’s using imprecision of the English language to try to make some sly commentary on his institutions relative power while also exposing the _exact_ point tech/science makes. While he has the power to make the _practice_ of mathematics law illegal, the law of mathematics that defines encryption will still exist, in the same places his man-made law touches.
- jeffdavis 6y ago"Sure, large companies may comply and average joes may get less E2E encryption, but anyone who knows anything about tech will be able to get access to E2E encrypted messengers." We are all lazy. I can use gpg, but how often am I going to do that? The NSA won't have access to the recipes that my brother sends to me, but aside from that, they'll get everything. To bad for them, though. They'd be better off with the recipes than the rest of it.
- suizi 6y agoAnyone committing a serious enough crime to "justify" breaking encryption would be very motivated to not get caught.
- causality0 6y agoYes, though the intelligence of criminals varies wildly. One person might organize drug deals over speakerphone in a Starbucks while another might torrent movies only over a clean laptop connected to a public access point with a long-range wifi antenna.
- suizi 6y agoIf a criminal is that unsophisticated, there should be other ways to catch them? Mind you, there are better ways to tackle drugs than a Law & Order approach.
- jeffdavis 6y agoHow many of these sophisticated and non-lazy criminals are there? If you have a lot of sophisticated and non-lazy criminals, my guess is that there is something very wrong. I'd like to know more about these characters and what kinds of crimes they are committing.
- tathougies 6y ago> The bill also allows the attorney general to create a competition with a prize for anyone who can come up with a way to access encrypted data while protecting privacy and security. Security experts have long noted that this is an impossible request. Well, with current encryption techniques this is impossible, but depending on what is meant by 'access', there are certainly ways of encrypting data in such a way that it maintains privacy while still being able to question if the data contains knowledge of certain things. For example, you can have a child pornography machine learning detector that operates over completely encrypted data via homomorphic machine learning. You can also use zero-knowledge proofs to ask a properly stored piece of data whether or not it contains a particular fact, without actually having to read the data. Depending on what is meant by 'access', this is a reasonable request. Requiring homomorphic encryption of encrypted data channels while government overreach perhaps, seems like something that can satisfy both a desire to have encrypted, unencryptable data, while still being able to examine the data in flight.
- suizi 6y agoHave you been circulating subversive documents which embarrass our wise and honourable government?