4 ms·
Mobile devices are typically underpowered compared to desktop systems. They've caught up to PCs in terms of power (as evidenced by the iPad Pro hardware being u
by Jtsummers 6y ago
Mobile devices are typically underpowered compared to desktop systems. They've caught up to PCs in terms of power (as evidenced by the iPad Pro hardware being used as the basis for the new dev kit by Apple). But the early years, in particular, saw massive annual increases in performance, Moore's Law had stalled on PCs but was alive and well for mobile platforms at that time.
You have to track the actual hardware changes in that time and compare it more to the PC market.
PCs pre-2006 had almost universally 32-bit processors, fixed pipeline GPUs, and maybe 4GB of RAM, probably 2GB. Post 2006, more GPUs got hardware shaders, 4GB of RAM became the baseline, as did 64-bit CPUs (usually with 2 or more cores). Those have all aged reasonably well and can still run most modern software outside of the graphics intensive ones (and even those sometimes if you turn most of the settings down).
The iPhone 3GS (2009) was the first one to have hardware shaders. That right there knocks out the two prior generations from being able to keep up.
The iPhone 5S (2013) was the first 64-bit processor, creating another boundary line for long-term support.
The iPhone 6S (2015) was the first to have > 1GB of RAM (upped it to 2GB), which created another boundary line.
So it's not too surprising that the higher RAM, 64-bit processor, with hardware shader support is the oldest supported iPhone (from this year forward).
Post-2015, the iPhone has improved (obviously if you've switched from a 6S to the 11 like I did) in performance and capabilities, but it's also stabilized in many ways. I haven't dug into the post-2015 phones yet to see if there are any other natural boundaries that will show up as devices drop out over the next 2-3 years, but I'm sure they exist there somewhere. Eventually the OS and the applications will be dependent on specific hardware features that cannot be easily (or efficiently) recreated on old, lower clocked processors.
- gruez 6y ago> Moore's Law had stalled on PCs but was alive and well for mobile platforms at that time. That's not a very convincing argument. Moore's law was alive and well two decades ago for PCs, but Windows XP (initially released 2001, supported til 2014) was able to run on hardware from 1995 (according to https://www.winhistory.de/more/386/xpmini_en.htm https://www.winhistory.de/more/386/xpmini_en.htm).
- Jtsummers 6y agoThat gets into a difference in motivation as well, but watching hardware changes (for iOS) explains a lot about why different phones have lost support over the years. Microsoft has a different motivation, in that they were selling Windows and Windows support. Apple didn't sell iOS (and they'd stopped selling OS X sometime in the '00s). MS had a vested interest, then, in supporting all hardware that they could because of businesses (and governments, especially governments) that wanted the latest OS, but didn't want to drop $2-3k on new computers. MS made their money off of the OS, their software on that OS, and the money spent by developers to have access to MS's development tools. Apple makes their money off of their hardware. So some people like to claim that Apple does a shit job of supporting old hardware, which may be true. They tend to cut off support more readily than many people would like. But in mobile they do a ton better than any Android device manufacturer (who have the same motivation as Apple: selling hardware). But my point still stands, older versions of iPhones are harder to continue supporting because they lacked hardware capabilities/features of newer ones. From improvements to the GPU, increasing RAM, adding cores, and going to 64-bit. Each of those added capabilities that the OS and app developers took advantage of that created boundary lines that barred older devices. This is more akin to the changes from x86 to x86-64 processors than the 1995->2003 hardware changes (Pentium 1 -> Pentium 4, all 32-bit) and the change from fixed-function GPUs to hardware shader GPUs.
- jychang 6y ago> Apple didn't sell iOS Strictly speaking, Apple sold iOS for a while. iOS 2 was a $10 paid upgrade for iPod touch users.
- wenc 6y agoWith most technologies, there's a saturation point after which improvements are mostly incremental. For iPhones the saturation point was the 6S. For iPads it was the iPad Air 2. The 6S is the lowest model that contact tracing apps will run on, and of course the oldest phone the latest iOS will support. I switched from the 6S to 11 last Christmas, and most of the improvements I noticed were largely incremental -- apart from a handful of things like FaceID and the camera which were significantly better. Ok, the battery is a lot better too. But the 6S didn't feel obsolete at all -- it felt like a current generation phone -- because it was running current generation software. My iPad Air 2 runs the latest iPadOS and still works great -- not sure when I'll make the jump to a newer iPad. p.s. the only thing the iPad Air 2 lacks support for is Apple Pencil. But now that I'm into fountain pens and high quality notepads, I don't really miss it. Also if I need to create Martin Kleppmann-esque hand-drawn architecture diagrams -- which I do occasionally -- I just use any number of rubber-tipped styluses (many inexpensive options on Amazon) with the Sketches app. Gets the job done. Kleppmann himself uses Fifty Three and Maglus styluses I believe. I'm way cheaper -- I just use the styluses that I get as swag from tech conferences.
- Bud 6y agoI agree with your main thesis, but I'm going to disagree on the inflection/saturation points you chose. I think it's closer to the iPhone X and the iPad Pro, 2nd-generation, or thereabouts. Compared to the devices you cited, raw speed and graphics power improved massively in the A-series chips during the years in question, the camera system is almost unrecognizably better as is the neural-net processing and computational photography. The displays improved markedly as well. I agree with you that the 6S is not obsolete, and that's a credit to Apple, but my current iPad Pro is miles ahead of the Air 2, which I owned as well. This has enabled me to do all kinds of new things with the device, and do them better. I wouldn't be able to go back. The last couple iPad Pros are 3x faster in Geekbench single-core than the Air 2, and more than 4x faster in multi-core. It's going to start to get hard though, moving forward, to make that kind of massive improvement. We already have 120Hz refresh, we now already have raw CPU power that is superior to almost all current laptop computers including MB Pros, we now have about as good of a screen as can be imagined, laws of physics will start to bar further major physical camera improvements, etc. Apple's already at the 5nm mode with its silicon; there are only a couple steps left before transistor sizes are just a few atoms across.
- chooseaname 6y agoThe 6S is the point when a phone got "fast enough". It was fast enough to be useful as a mobile phone without being frustrating to use. Everything since has been gravy, but the 6S is still surprisingly useful as a mobile device.
- Jtsummers 6y agoThe 6S (see my other comment near here) was almost 30% faster than the 6, and doubled the RAM to 2GB. Those two factors alone probably made the jump seem so significant, ignoring any other changes they may have included in it. The 7 got another major clock boost, but kept the RAM (7 Plus had 3GB though) so that would've been another noticeable improvement, though mostly in games and such, many applications probably didn't see much change between the 6S and 7.
- wolfgke 6y ago> Mobile devices are typically underpowered compared to desktop systems. Early PCs/home computers were also underpowered compared to workstations. The difference is: buyers expected them to be supported for a much longer time and expected developers to (if somehow possible) to write sufficiently fast code that also runs decently on "outdated" computers.
- Jtsummers 6y agoYou wouldn't have run Windows 95 on your circa 1987 Tandy, there were massive changes in that time as well that impacted supported hardware when new OSes and software came out. Mobile phones (smart phones in particular here) saw changes in 1-3 years that took 5-10 years on PCs. That has to be taken into consideration when trying to understand why a piece of hardware isn't supported by the latest OS or software.
- wolfgke 6y ago> You wouldn't have run Windows 95 on your circa 1987 Tandy Windows 95 (formally) did run on a PC that has an Intel 80386DX CPU of any speed and 4 MB of system RAM: https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Windows_95&oldid=962821687#System_requirements The 80386DX CPU was launched in October 1985: https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Intel_80386&oldid=952503560
- sosborn 6y agoI mean, every OS release has left out older hardware. https://www.technologytips.com/windows-system-requirements/ https://www.technologytips.com/windows-system-requirements/ The software/application story is certainly better on desktops, I'll grant you that.
- katmannthree 6y agoA _substantial_ portion of the desktop PC market was running on 512MB of RAM in 2006[0]. Even today a significant portion of budget computers people buy have 4GB which is just barely on the edge of enough to run Windows 10 and a couple modern websites. [0] https://i.imgur.com/YiMobdC.png https://i.imgur.com/YiMobdC.png
- Jtsummers 6y agoFair enough, I guess my memory on RAM was biased by my environment (mostly around developers and CS students in that time period).
- dwaite 6y ago> I haven't dug into the post-2015 phones yet to see if there are any other natural boundaries that will show up ... I suspect TouchID will be the next one we hit, but that is going to be at least four years off because iPhone SE #2. The neural engine may be a feature cut-off after that, where there are just too many features and services being run on device which can't be done on older hardware. Other than that, I suspect Apple will still institute a vintage/obsolete lifecycle for phones - just choosing to drop support for phones where the hardware hasn't been sold in a certain amount of time (say five years), official replacement parts like batteries are no longer being made, etc.