2 ms·
That's not a language feature though, right? It's just a struct containing a union and a discriminant. That means: - No pattern matching means your stuck with
by nicoburns 6y ago
That's not a language feature though, right? It's just a struct containing a union and a discriminant. That means:
- No pattern matching means your stuck with the awkward if-elseif-else
- It doesn't check that you've accounted for every possible variant.
- You can only hold one variant of each type: you can't have two variants that both contain a string.
- The specific instance isn't it's own type, so you can't implement methods on it.
- TFortunato 6y agoTake a look at my reply above. Your right it isn't built into the language, but it does come with a helper method, std::visit, which does take into account that you've accounted for all possible variant types, and will throw a compile error if you didn't. You also aren't stuck with if, else-if style syntax.
- etalian 6y agoA language that I am working on has those things "built-in" (it still generates compilable C++ in the backend). I did recently add pattern matching (and not just on variants) where the above would be equivalent to: $v:|[:int, :bool, :double] = 5; $vi: = v.[:int]; $holds_int: = v.?[:int]; switch v { .[:int]$i { /std cout << "got int:" << i }; .[:bool] { /std cout << "got bool" }; .[:double]$d { /std cout << "got double: " << d }; }; If a type repeats in the same variant, you would match by index to tell them apart: $v:|[:int, :int]<(.[0] = 5); switch v { .[0]$i0 { /std cout << "got first int:" << i0 }; .[1]$i1 { /std cout << "got second int: " << i1 }; }; (I have some ideas to allow named labels instead of numerical indices but that is not yet implemented) It is, in spirit, an implementation of the inspect proposal [1], but with a (subjectively) much simpler and more powerful syntax (the grammar of the entire language is fully LALR(1) without ambiguities). [1] http://www.open-std.org/jtc1/sc22/wg21/docs/papers/2019/p1371r1.pdf http://www.open-std.org/jtc1/sc22/wg21/docs/papers/2019/p137...
- pjmlp 6y agoYou can use std::visit() for the time being, and pattern matching is being discussed.