4 ms·
So this is a weird question, but I am actually serious.... Isn't all "good" literature meant to be "long dull and badly written[to the untrained eye]"? The mor
by gambiting 6y ago
So this is a weird question, but I am actually serious....
Isn't all "good" literature meant to be "long dull and badly written[to the untrained eye]"? The more I think about what you said, the more I realize that the image of "nobel winning" literature that I have in my mind is by definition long, boring, impossibly allegorical and it must feel like you have to be superhuman to read it and understand it. Equally, in my mind anything that's easy and pleasant to read must be trash(because anything I have ever read that was enjoyable was dismissed later as easy-reading garbage). My only experience with "great works of literature" is of that by Polish writers since that's where I grew up, anything by Sienkiewicz or Mickiewicz is considered almost sacred, literature with the "big L" as they say, those are big names with international renown, yet their books are the most soul destroying thing I have ever read, it's just so dull. Hell, Władysław Reymont won a nobel prize(!) for his novel "Chłopi"("Peasants") yet I'd rather stab myself with a fork that try reading that again. Same with more modern authors, Umberto Eco is impossible to read unless I'm actively trying to sleep, and he's considered a "good" author.
So my immediate thought after reading Lord of The Rings was....wow, it must be good(because it's so dull to read). It's almost like pavlov's instinct at this point, years of education has trained me to think dull book = great work of art.
- Kye 6y agoThe thing about contests/awards is they're judged by people at the peaks of their careers who have seen and/or done basically everything. It's hard to impress them. So the easy stuff is cool and fun to both see and make, but also doesn't surprise the judges. Example: photography contests. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kcxcGBbLIwk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kcxcGBbLIwk The cool, pretty, easy to access photos aren't surprising to someone who's seen it all. Anyone with enough money and time can take those photos, just as anyone with enough time and little concern for popularity can sit there and write something that surprises the people who give out writing awards.
- dash2 6y agoI think the problem is that LOTR is long, dull and badly written to the trained eye. (As a kid, I read it five times... including the appendices.)