3 ms·
Most of it is not very good. The aesthetic reason is that it's all form and no content. The difference between a real Mondrian and a generative pseudo-Mondrian
by TheOtherHobbes 6y ago
Most of it is not very good.
The aesthetic reason is that it's all form and no content. The difference between a real Mondrian and a generative pseudo-Mondrian is that the real Mondrian is the result of a long process of metaphor and abstraction, while the generative pseudo-Mondrian is a superficial mimic of the result which misses key details in the original and all of the history of the process.
It doesn't have to express some deep truth about the world, but it should express something more interesting than "Look I made a sort-of geometric thing with code."
The philosophical reason is because it's rooted in modernist abstraction, and that's more than a century old now. So mostly it's formulaically repeating an aesthetic based on weightless disembodied abstract repetition that hasn't changed for more than a hundred years. The fact that it's doing it with code and not with something else doesn't rescue it.
The visual result is that it's often stiff, unsurprising, stale, and repetitive. Occasionally you get people who take it to the next level and show real mastery by doing something rich and surprising with it - I'm a fan of Raven Kwok for example, and Jared Tarbell was ahead of the game before he moved on to start Etsy - but they spend months working on their projects. Most people just dabble superficially and never get past the "I made a sort-of geometric thing with code" stage.
tl;dr Most often it's an excuse for yet more hobby coding made by people who are interested in code, but not really interested in art at all.