2 ms·
The clear examples given of FB repeatedly trying to gain the personal owner details of non-shady websites, purely in order to sue them... that's ok with you?
by justinclift 6y ago
The clear examples given of FB repeatedly trying to gain the personal owner details of non-shady websites, purely in order to sue them... that's ok with you?
- sokoloff 6y agoThis might be an unpopular opinion, but it’s ok with me. I don’t find restricting discovery needed to allow the filing of lawsuits to be something beneficial for society. There’s a real reason corporations need to have registered agents, mostly so they can be contacted (including to be sued) via a reliable process. I don’t see why a domain owner should be entitled to avoid official contact via privacy policies. I’m fine if there’s a reasonable policy to access it (including a possible workaround of an agent willing to accept official contacts). That someone would use the information purely in order to sue someone is a desirable feature, not a bug.
- searchableguy 6y ago> That someone would use the information purely in order to sue someone is a desirable feature, not a bug. The only problem with this is that your legal system is fucked so the winner is always that big corp. Have fun being sued to hell and bankrupt after a corp decides to go after your website criticising them. Have you even looked at the list of domains they are going after? > And then it has a whole section for “domains that use the full trademark [but] nevertheless evince an indication that the domain is or will be used to discuss grievances with the company in question.” Every one of them comes from Facebook: addictedtofacebook.org, banned-by-facebook.com, divestfacebook.com, facebooksucks.org, protestfacebook.org, saynotoinstagram.com. And there are legal processes to sue someone as others have explained. Facebook wants to avoid them. Also did people forget - https://www.theverge.com/2020/6/15/21291666/ebay-employees-arrested-journalist-harassment https://www.theverge.com/2020/6/15/21291666/ebay-employees-a...
- ClumsyPilot 6y agoI don't see how owning a domain could possibly be anything like running a company. Just by incorporating you take on resposibility of paying taxes, accounting, submitting regylar reports, etc. Presumably you will be selling something, and people need to have an address for recourse. That 'address' could be a PO box somewhere, or be in a tax heaven. By contrast owning a domain does not obligate you to do anything in society, and doesnt affect anyone life. Most people register a domain to have a custom email. Why should you have the right to deanonimise that? If you are concerned about hatemail: you can send real post anonymously, with a postage stamp, though an unattented mailbox. I can even put somone else's return address on it.
- rbrtl 6y agoThey do not avoid official contact. They avoid unofficial contact, such as that of FB directly approaching any domain owner they feel like without proving to a judge that there is reasonable grounds to file suit. The same way you put your email address in a mildly obfuscated format instead of jim@cimpress.com. You don't want anyone or anything that comes across your bio having access to your email address without human intervention, or at least a degree of intelligence. > but it's ok with me.