3 ms·
He apparently said 'the Lord of the Rings is of course a fundamentally religious and Catholic work; unconsciously so at first, but consciously in the revision.'
by notahacker 6y ago
He apparently said 'the Lord of the Rings is of course a fundamentally religious and Catholic work; unconsciously so at first, but consciously in the revision.'
But what he didn't like were crude 'Saruman represents Judas' type comparisons, not least because he'd criticised his friend CS Lewis for being as explicit as to incorporate Jesus as a talking Lion who is resurrected into his novels and said he found their symbolism heavy handed [it's interesting Lewis himself rejected the idea of his books as allegory, but not the idea that Aslan was supposed to be that world's Jesus or that respective books in the series were supposed to have Creation/Crucifixion/Antichrist themes. Perhaps they both viewed the term allegory as an accusation the scope of their work was too narrow]
LOTR is Christian inasmuch as it has very explicit concepts of good and evil and temptation, but it's also a book involving more explicit anti-industrialization messaging and Tom Bombadil.
- goto11 6y agoGandalf "dying", fighting demons in the underworld, and returning as "Gandalf the White" is also a pretty clear parallel though. But arguably Tolkien is a better writer so it doesn't seem so on-the-nose.
- eredengrin 6y agoYeah that quote does sound familiar, but I'd say that's a bit different than "the whole mythology is directly based on christian mythology". I think the moral framework of his world certainly has strong roots in the Christian tradition and I expect that is what Tolkien was referring to in that quote, but the stories themselves are generally quite distinct from anything you'd find in Christianity. I think this is pretty much what you are saying as well, so I think we're mostly in agreement here.