6 ms·
He did it so well that most "high" fantasy that came out after him felt derivative of Tolkien. I'd really like to see counter-examples though; I feel like I ha
by Cthulhu_ 6y ago
He did it so well that most "high" fantasy that came out after him felt derivative of Tolkien.
I'd really like to see counter-examples though; I feel like I haven't dived into the genre enough, in part because I'm turned off by the sheer volume of some book (series) on the one hand, and the juvenile tropes (generic hero's journey formula) on the other.
- macleginn 6y agoOne way to avoid Tolkien’s shadow was to branch into related genres. Cue weird/ubran fantasy (e.g., Perdido Street Station), historical fantasy (e.g., The Spirit Ring), or pseudo-fantasy (the Ghormengast series, The Buried Giant). Interestingly, it seems that only works from last category have some real literary value.
- saalweachter 6y agoI've fallen for the LitRPG genre, in all its variety. A lot of it is very Tolkien-esque, given Tolkien's influence on D&D and its influence on RPGs that followed, but it has a different feel than the fantasy of the 70's-90's that lived deep in his shadow.
- pjc50 6y agoIf you don't like hero's journey, you're probably going to struggle to like fantasy; on the other hand, both of Tolkein's most popular works embed the moral journey in a very literal, physical journey and do just fine. UKLG's Earthsea is the series that I hear most often loved by other authors, although I'm not familiar with it myself. Then there is Pratchett, who set out to do simple parody of high fantasy and ended up creating a deeply humanist character-driven universe.
- gvjddbnvdrbv 6y agoYou should read UKLG's Earthsea. They are objectively quite simple books (targeted at teens) but they are fantastic. As a side note in my opinion this series is an example of how the current phase of thinking someone has to be of a group to understand the group is wrong. The female author brilliantly captures a young male's journey towards a strong, compassionate, brave and very masculine manhood with all the mistakes along the way. As I grew up (and indeed still grow up) I often reflect on what Ged would do at different phases of his growth. So essentially the female UKLG is guiding me in my life. (Or maybe men and women are even more similar than I'm accounting for and a young woman's journey is just that similar to a man's).
- pjc50 6y ago> the current phase of thinking someone has to be of a group to understand the group is wrong. > Or maybe men and women are even more similar than I'm accounting for and a young woman's journey is just that similar to a man's You're almost there; the point is not that you have to be in a group to understand a group, but that because of the power structure some are much more visible and celebrated than others. A female writer is more likely to be able to see what the male journey is like (due to thousands of examples) than a male writer, who is in turn more likely to project his own prejudices than actually find out what it might be like. (In turn, there have been a number of literary fights lately about white female authors doing terribly bad racial stereotypes of their nonwhite characters...)
- arkades 6y ago> You're almost there; the point is not I take issue with this statement. It's essentially a variant of the No True Scotsman. I constantly see the OP's statement asserted, in various contexts, by various parties, in the same way he worded it. I don't doubt that you've seen a more refined version of it. "People" are a fairly heterogeneous bunch, and when it comes to race/gender stuff I constantly see nuanced (whether or not agreeable) arguments filter out from academic circles into the general public and to activists, where they're distorted or simplified. You're absolutely welcome to raise a more refined version of the argument and point out where it's more valid - I think that's a healthy contribution to any discussion. But you don't get to unilaterally assert that the version of the argument that is constantly being put forward ... isn't being put forward, or isn't "the real" argument.
- riffraff 6y agoI would think "high fantasy" to be defined as "tolkienesque" (great evil to defeat and save the world). But there's a ton of fantasy where the other important tropes of Tolkien (great lost past, the dark empire, all good on one side and all bad on the other, the pure heroes) is missing. The first that come to mind are "the wheel of time" and "the chronicles of Thomas covenant". Also if you move from high fantasy there's a ton more interesting stuff, imvho :)
- thaumasiotes 6y ago> there's a ton of fantasy where the other important tropes of Tolkien (great lost past, the dark empire, all good on one side and all bad on the other, the pure heroes) is missing. The first that come to mind are "the wheel of time" We must see different things. As I see the wheel of time: - Great lost past. This one's obvious; the Age of Legend is a huge focus of the books. - The dark empire. Doesn't exist in the present, but it is a feature of the great lost past. - All good on one side and all bad on the other: this seems to describe the wheel of time well? The whole story arc is Rand fulfilling the separate prophecies of every ethnic group in the world, bringing them all under the same government (his), and taking them to battle the even more unified forces of evil. - The pure heroes. Not sure what this means.
- riffraff 6y agoYes, the age of legends is the same trope, but I don't think the rest matches. There is one Big Evil but the lesser ones are all scheming against each other. In Tolkien there's just a bit with Saruman and the spiders, but you don't really have factions amongst the ringwraiths, for example. It's all just a battle between Sauron/everyone or Melkor/everyone. The good ones in WoT don't simply start separated but actively hating and fighting each other, Rand has to go to war with many nations and specific groups within nations, and some of them just split and start killing each other. This is not the same as Gondor and Rohan being on bad terms, or some elven clans just standing on the sides. In Tolkien's universe you 99% of the time know who is evil and who is not (elf, dwarf, hobbit, ent, eagle, northern man = good; orc, goblin, troll, dragon, great spiders, eastern man= bad). Yes, a couple human characters are ambiguous, but it's a pretty small minority. In WoT you have a couple evil races and you, the reader, have a clear view of who is good and who is bad. But in-world people want to kill other people because each thinks the other is evil: that looks a substantial difference to me. Re: pure heroes, I meant that the main characters basically are all 100% good. This is the same in both universes too, just not a constant in all high fantasy. At least I think, I didn't finish the wheel of time ;)
- simonh 6y agoFor post-Tolkien fantasy with little or no Tolkien influences or tropes, the most obvious recent example is Game of Thrones. I suppose it's arguable whether it's High Fantasy, but looking at the character arcs of John Snow and Daenerys I think it clears the bar.
- danans 6y ago> For post-Tolkien fantasy with little or no Tolkien influences or tropes There's perhaps no direct borrowing of names and character types, but by George R.R. Martin's own attestation, he sought to write a story with a scope approaching Tolkeins but disposing of Tolkiens idealism and dualism. He was deeply influenced by Tolkiens writing, and sought to correct it's flaws. https://www.tolkiensociety.org/2019/09/george-r-r-martin-i-keep-wanting-to-argue-with-professor-tolkien/ https://www.tolkiensociety.org/2019/09/george-r-r-martin-i-k...
- einpoklum 6y agoSo, an unoriginal _scope_ ? Hmm... I don't know about that.
- BolexNOLA 6y agoYou should check out the “Mistborn” series by Brian Sanderson. You’ll recognize some tropes/themes but it’s really different from what I’ve usually read and the characters are absolutely fantastic. It’s 3 books and they’re a bit lengthy but it’s a self-contained, satisfying story. Elevator pitch for you: you know the epic good vs. evil showdown where the good guys charge epically against the likes of Sauron and his evil army? Well, the good guys lost. It’s 1,000 years later and the evil dark lord is running the show. Now a team of magic wielding (illegal) misfits is planning an ocean’s 11 style heist to get filth rich and topple the evil empire at the same time! Again, fantastic series. I was hooked just a few dozen pages in. The Magic also has a crazy interesting mechanic/rule set that makes it more of a strategy issue in some ways.
- jhauris 6y agoMinor correction, it's Brandon Sanderson. He is a fantastic fantasy author. The Stormlight archives is another series by him that is really good.
- BolexNOLA 6y agoAhhh good catch. Thanks! I always do that with his name. And I started stormlight recently!
- frabbit 6y agoOut of interest do you dis/like Tolkien's work?
- BolexNOLA 6y agoLove the movies, mixed on the books. They’re obviously classics and have a lot of beauty but I don’t feel the need to revisit them. I like a little faster pacing in what I read.
- BolexNOLA 6y agoYou should really check out Brian Sanderson’s “Mistborn” trilogy
- zipwitch 6y agoMalazan Books of the Fallen by Steven Erikson. They've got more than a few roots in fantasy gaming, which in turn does owe something to Tolkien, but they're unquestionably high fantasy, and they certainly struck me a very diffent from Tolkien.
- atombender 6y agoGene Wolfe's The Book of the New Sun would be a great counter-example. The novel owes absolutely nothing to Tolkien; it's entirely its own thing, subverting generic fantasy tropes left and right, while providing a clever variation on the classic hero's journey. And the same time it has this magnificent aura of otherwordliness, like a mythological narrative written thousands of years into the future (which it purports to be). It's an absolute masterpiece. Wolfe really made a career out of subverting fantasy tropes. His Latro series [2] (Soldier of the Mist, etc.) is set in Ancient Greece, and features an amnesiac mercenary whose memory resets every day. The Wizard Knight is another good one; essentially a riff on Tolkienesque Norse mythology and Medieval romances, it features a prepubescent boy who is accidentally transported to a fantasy dimension, and then into the body of an adult knight. It's absurd, but also deliciously weird, just like some of Wolfe's other books (the Long Sun and Short Sun books, etc.). [1] https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B075JL493G https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B075JL493G [2] https://www.amazon.com/Soldier-Mist-Latro-Book-1-ebook/dp/B009E6VSBG https://www.amazon.com/Soldier-Mist-Latro-Book-1-ebook/dp/B0... [3] https://www.amazon.com/Wizard-Knight-Gene-Wolfe-ebook/dp/B086S3X5CP https://www.amazon.com/Wizard-Knight-Gene-Wolfe-ebook/dp/B08...