5 ms·
> I'd expect a more robust defense of personal privacy from a "rationalist", because this reason is bunk It's bunk to call Scott's concerns bunk. You may think
by zozbot234 6y ago
> I'd expect a more robust defense of personal privacy from a "rationalist", because this reason is bunk
It's bunk to call Scott's concerns bunk. You may think that he ought to self-disclose, but that's simply not his call: he has a job as a psychiatrist and has to stick to what his employers require of him if he wants to keep working in the field, and support his patients.
- maybel_syrup 6y agoI didn't say he ought to; I said that if he were to self-disclose, there'd be little damage that could occur to his effectiveness as a clinician, contrary to what he claimed. Further, to cite that as his first reason for wanting to remain pseudonymous is odd, because it's flimsy for the reasons I cited. His second reason (that he's gotten death threats) is much more compelling, and to me is all he needs to make a good argument here. Why sully it with things like this?