>Do we really need another chat app? Wouldn't it maybe be >better to capitalize on the existence of an open network >that is already around, and build a better

>Do we really need another chat app? Wouldn't it maybe be >better to capitalize on the existence of an open network >that is already around, and build a better client for it >that kicks the pants off of whatever's already out there? First thanks for the reply I could have explained this a bit better it isn't a chat app replacement, not trying to dislodge messenger, whatapp, etc. Group and direct messaging is core to the product but not the value prop just by itself. I am specifically asking the group chat part as it has been done meany times so I would like to not make it again but use already built or at least mostly built. Then can focus on other part that makes is unique and makes it valuable. >Then who's going to build it? Are you hiring a team to do this? Don't underestimate >what's involved here to get something working and keep it running. At the very >least, if you don't go with a decentralized model, you're in for expensive server >bills and considerable ongoing maintenance to keep up with security patches, etc. At the moment I have someone part time who is smart but is still learning. I may also hire a very small team but thats the reason I am trying to get a full understanding of options and pros and cons, so there is a clear roadmap. >There are already too many options in this space. Why would anyone choose your >client when Signal, Telegram, Riot/Matrix, etc. are all free and decent to use? >What is your unique value-add? By too many options I mean frameworks, languages, backends, etc. That why am soliciting feedback from HN on it. Again it isn't a signal or telegram replacement. Group chat is core to the product but not the value-add. It isn't a slack replacement, no web or desktop. Just iOS & Android. The nature of the product it does have to be on both, can't start with only one. >Don't do this unless you have a business plan good enough that someone will lend you >$1MM to get it off the ground. Seriously. You're talking about entering a massively >crowded marketplace, and you're clearly out of your element. I have already brought my tent to Sand Hill road and written out my cardboard sign. (j/k) But again not replacement for existing options. I have lead the creations of products before. I asking newbie questions because I want to see the situation with no preconceived ideas for this specific part.