4 ms·
So if you read the actual text of Apple's rejection, it seems even worse that merely doing something asinine and dumb like rejecting astrology: > "We continue
by crazygringo 6y ago
So if you read the actual text of Apple's rejection, it seems even worse that merely doing something asinine and dumb like rejecting astrology:
> "We continue to find your app to be an Astrology based dating app. As such, it duplicates the content and functionality of many other similar apps currently available on the App Store. While these app features may be useful, informative or entertaining, we simply have enough of these types of apps on the App Store, and they are considered a form of spam."
So, holy shit -- Apple will reject your app because there are already "enough" other apps that incorporate some particular functionality or theme?
While not illegal, that's so blatantly anti-competitive because it says "no more competition, nobody else can try, you lose, sorry".
That's infuriating. This isn't a grocery store with limited shelf space. Either reject an app because it breaks policies or don't, but don't reject an app because we already "have enough". Look, if it fails, it'll sink to the end of search results and nobody will find it anyways. Or de-list apps that don't meet some tiny minimum number of installs, but to it in the open, for all types of apps, with explicitly known thresholds.
But don't prevent someone from competing in the first place! It's just so... unsportsmanlike. And ultimately harmful to consumers who want better apps.
- tradertef 6y agoYes. Apple rejected an app I was working on as spam since there are already apps which does the same thing. It was a simple app but I thought its appeal would be its simplicity anyways. With this logic, they would reject new games as there are already many games in the app store :)
- Delk 6y agoI'm not using the Apple ecosystem but I thought that was at least originally part of the premise of the App Store. Curated content, at Apple's discretion, where they could decide that something should not be included if it somehow didn't fit their vision by adding too many confusing choices or something. Maybe that has changed over the years while I wasn't watching, either in letter or in practice, and it is indeed not something you would expect to happen. But to me it kind of sounds like just Apple being Apple.
- colejohnson66 6y agoThe idea behind that rule is to prevent another flood of clones of the next Flappy Bird. That’s why it was added. In practice, it’s arbitrary.