6 ms·
>> (10-30 MPH, faster than walking, not quite car speed), battery-powered, lightweight transit devices. That's car speed. It isn't highway speed, but when an
by sandworm101 6y ago
>> (10-30 MPH, faster than walking, not quite car speed), battery-powered, lightweight transit devices.
That's car speed. It isn't highway speed, but when an ebike passes me at the dog beach doing 25mph I'm tempted to put a stick through the front spokes. In a car, 30mph in a school zone would get you a massive ticket ($$$+). Any vehicle capable of such things should be limited to the roads, plated and licensed like every other electric motorcycle. (Don't bother with the helmets. Darwin can work that one out.)
- ch4s3 6y ago> I'm tempted to put a stick through the front spokes You're tempted to risk killing someone because they're doing something dangerous? I'm not sure that's a reasonable response.
- sandworm101 6y agoAsk me that after I help take a dog to the dog hospital. Plenty of dogs, and people, are hit by ebikes. They are particular dangers at parks because, unlike pushbikes, ebikes are nearly silent.
- usaphp 6y agoPlenty of people get bitten by dogs, does it mean I have to attack every dog owner?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- anon_1_1_1 6y agoDo you think we should lay out spike strips to stop car drivers from running over dogs too?
- ch4s3 6y agoHas the particular cyclist you’re thinking of assaulting committed such a misdeed?
- nogabebop23 6y ago>> unlike pushbikes, ebikes are nearly silent. So an ebike is typically a regular bike PLUS an electric motor. Not sure how that can be quieter than just the regular bike. You can definitely hear whirl of the electric motor as well. >> Plenty of dogs, and people, are hit by ebikes Last year only 9 of the total reported bicycle-pedestrian acidents in NYC were with e-bikes.
- jacquesm 6y agoAn e-bike is just a bike from a traffic rule perspective. It is a bit noisier than a regular bike, goes about the same speed (in fact, the motor cuts out at about 15 mph). Its main advantages are that it helps with acceleration and with headwind/hills, but once you're at 15 mph you're on your own. If you have a situation where dogs regularly interfere with bicycles and the other way around then I suspect that the problem is more with the dog owners (you?) than with the cyclists. I've been a dog owner for many years and my dogs have never been in a situation where cyclists would endanger it, though, I have to admit, one of my hounds once did endanger a cyclist by giving chase (pink spandex, not 100% the dogs fault, but then again they supposedly don't see color). I consider that wholly my fault, the dog pulled the leash right out of my hand and then refused to stop giving chase and that should have never happened. It all sounds to me like you need something to be worked up about and you've decided that e-bikes are a menace to dogs when in fact the spaces where dogs are allowed to run free are not typically exclusive to dogs but are also shared by dogs with foot and cycle traffic. The responsibility for keeping the dogs and the other traffic safe lies squarely with the owner of the dog. A well mannered dog will stay with its owner and will not interfere with others on foot, bike or otherwise. Finally, dogs are a much bigger danger to other pedestrians, and children in particular than your typical e-bike will ever be to a dog.
- TulliusCicero 6y agoThe motor cuts out at 15 mph in the EU, in the US the standard ebike limit is 20 mph, and many ebikes go yet faster than that.
- Damorian 6y agoUnfortunately, I see this reaction all the time. The problem is bikes can do this, not just e-bikes, but the perception is that it's only e+bikes, which is why I fear they'll be legislated out of existence.
- aaronblohowiak 6y agoHopefully they will be nerfed and not banned -- there is an effort to get ahead of things with reasonable legislation: https://www.bosch-ebike.com/us/everything-about-the-ebike/stories/three-class-ebike-system/ https://www.bosch-ebike.com/us/everything-about-the-ebike/st...
- derekp7 6y agoNot all bikes / riders. Many cyclists have trouble with more than 10 - 12 MPH over an extended time period. I know that when I was a decade younger, and working out for 2 years cycling for 30 - 50 miles per day, a 15 mile ride into work (on a mountain bike) took a good chunk over an hour. I could average 15, but I'd be sweating heavily when I got to work. So the argument is that it isn't bad when a small percentage of cyclists hit 25 - 30 mph, but when all of them are able to that is where the issue is. My personal feeling, however, is that especially the models that are pedal assist (where you put some effort into it, and it multiples your effort) is a good way to get otherwise low-fitness people to bike ride more. The more cyclists, the more push for bicycle friendly infrastructure. And people still get exercise on them, more so than in a car. But regardless of powered vs unpowered, anyone that rides a bicycle fast by pedestrians and dogs is doing it wrong. On an ebike, it should be no effort to slow down to 5 - 8 mph, then speed back up after passing someone.
- gav 6y ago> pedal assist I can’t wait for pedal assist ebikes to become more affordable. It opens up biking as an option for a lot more journeys, not just for lower-fitness people, but in regions where it’s hilly. For where I live in Los Angeles, the places I bike to are a couple of miles away (or close enough that walking makes more sense), but uphill all the way. Having pedal assist would mean that I don’t arrive sweaty with tired legs. I don’t need to go 25mph, just 10mph with less effort.
- dmix 6y ago> In a car, 30mph in a school zone would get you a massive ticket Bikes can stop faster, maneuver easier, and cause significantly less damage than a car when striking something. You rarely ever hear of bikes seriously harming pedestrians for a reason (but of course yes it does happen on occasion). I'm not supporting dangerously biking through a school zone but this is a silly comparison to make, of course the fines would be lower for a bike.
- jcampbell1 6y agoBikes don’t stop faster than cars. Plenty of cars approach 1G of deceleration. At .3Gs I’m going over the handlebars of a bike. Furthermore, in NYC, half of serious pedestrian injuries are caused by bikes, meaning a cyclist is about 200 times more likely to seriously injure a pedestrian than a driver. I am all for bikes, but let’s not be delusional about the safety issues or basic physics of how poorly they brake.
- sudosysgen 6y agoIf you're going over the handlebars of a bike at .3Gs, I think you might be using your bike incorrectly. I'm personally limited as far as braking mainly by my tires slipping or, on downhills, by stoppies. All of which happen at much more than 1G. Motorcycles can also generally brake at 1G, again limited by the presence of an ABS system, so it's not a physics question, it's that either you have bad brakes or you do not know how to brake on a bike. Even only using the rear wheel should allow you significantly more than .3G
- jcampbell1 6y agoI did some measuring and thinking when I returned my bike to the bike room. I looked up some stuff, and .5g is where one typically goes over the handlebars. .3g is typical stopping speed for an average rider. Elite riders can achieve .7g by moving their butt way behind and below the seat. The front tire friction limit is around .8g with good dry conditions. My bike is way too small and I have the seat post about 1cm into the tube, and I’m also a bit top heavy. The wiki page on bike physics says rear wheel only braking gets about .25g. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bicycle_and_motorcycle_dynamics https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bicycle_and_motorcycle_dynam... I measured my mountain bike, and the seat is 41” high, and 35” behind the front contact patch. This is terrible for braking, though not entirely out of line with some of the fancy road bikes in the bike room. I should probably get a different bike, as I am quite sure I go over the handle bars at about .3g rather than the more normal .5g. At any rate, I am not sure how one learns limit braking on a bike. Modern cars the computer does it for you if you just stomp the pedal and some cars even do it preemptively with collision avoidance.
- rangibaby 6y agoI agree with you, other than the murder part. Electric bikes allow people who don’t have fast riding skills to ride faster than they can control, which makes them a danger to other users of the footpath.
- jacquesm 6y agoAll motorized vehicles allow people who don't have fast riding skills to go faster than they can control. E-bike users usually have a better handle on the control part than the users of other motorized vehicles, if not they won't make it past the first turn. Besides that, all e-bikes sold legally have a motor that progressively down-tunes as it approaches it's legal limit speed (usually at or near 15 mph / 24 km/h). That's easily achievable on a regular bike so people can't ride faster than they could normally. They can however do so for longer and it takes them less effort to start up or go against the wind or up a hill.
- rangibaby 6y ago> All motorized vehicles allow people who don't have fast riding skills to go faster than they can control. Yes, but all other motorized vehicles need a licensed operator and to be driven on a road, which I think should be the case for e bikes as well > That's easily achievable on a regular bike That really depends on your definition of a regular bike. The Japanese commuter bikes everyone rides to work or school might get up to 10km/h with some effort. Giving someone who has only ever rode at about a pedestrian’s jogging or running pace a machine that can hit twice that is a recipe for injuries or death. TL;DR: E bike riders should be licensed and not share footpaths with pedestrians
- xavieralexandre 6y agoI'm wondering if a workable idea would be instead of having pedestrian paths and bike lanes and wondering where new kind of vehicles should go to have different tiers of lane with different speed and weight limits. For exemple: * < 10 km.h^-1 & < 15 kilograms vehicle for pedestrian paths (Which would for exemple allow small kids to ride there). * < 25 km.h^-1 < 30 kilograms for the bike lane equivalent. * > 25 km.h^1 or > 30 kilograms on the road.
- jacquesm 6y agoWow, what an asshole thing to say. A 'dog beach' isn't exclusive to dogs and you are still responsible for what your dog does. It's a beach where dogs are also allowed.