4 ms·
Arbitrary restrictions like that just make me want to get around them... and reminds me of this phrase I heard many years ago (in the era when encryption laws w
by userbinator 6y ago
Arbitrary restrictions like that just make me want to get around them... and reminds me of this phrase I heard many years ago (in the era when encryption laws were far stricter):
"What's the difference between encryption and steganography? You don't know."
- squarefoot 6y ago"What's the difference between encryption and steganography? You don't know." Plausible deniability.
- arghwhat 6y agoDon't. Follow the rules, and get them changed if you disagree with them. Amateur radio enjoys the privilege of pretty lax regulation, largely due to the players not making any trouble. Speaking as a fellow radio amateur, we don't want our hobby ruined just because someone wants to be a troublemaker.
- teddyh 6y ago> Amateur radio enjoys the privilege of pretty lax regulation What. You literally have to have a license issued to you personally (no anonymity) by the government to even be allowed to do it. And the rules of what can and can’t be sent are, to my Internet-accustomed mind, excruciatingly onerous. No encryption? No foul language?
- adamtj 6y agoRadio spectrum is a limited and shared resource. It makes sense that it's licensed and regulated. But compared to other parts of the spectrum, the license is cheap and easy to get and the regulations are minimal. It's a public space for experimentation. If you don't want to be seen in public, go to some other area of the spectrum.
- arghwhat 6y agoThe rules are extremely loose. 1. You need a personal license to identify you, as an operator of a radio station. This is similar to how radios on ships and airplanes work - you need to be able to identify every transmission (even cellphones are uniquely identifiable). This is not only part of the entire sport (we're trying to contact and identify each other), but is also used to identify problems. 2. Just like for airplanes and ships, there are some rules to what you can transmit, as your transmissions can be heard (and cause troubles) for tens, hundreds and even thousands of kilometers away. 3. You have countless frequency allocations available, all over the spectrum, despite the scarcity. 4. Unlike everyone else, holding that license permits you to build your own equipment and transmit with kilowatts with no certification needed. It's extremely easy to cause massive issues with this, such as interrupting cellular communication/gps/wifi an a large area, blowing up your neighbors stereos, and fun things like that. There's a reason that everything else needs to be tested, certified, and require dedicated band allocations - we avoid it by showing that we have the sufficient skills to practice our hobby and not cause trouble. Unlike everyone else, we can do pretty much whatever we want as long as we keep it around a kilowatt and talk nice. I consider that to be extremely relaxed rules.
- kawfey 6y agoeveryone else like: - General Mobile Radio Service (GMRS) which is limited to a set of frequencies in the UHF band, 50w repeaters, and a few watts handheld, and requires an $80? license. - Family radio service (FRS) which is limited to store-bought handheld units with 0.5W maximum output - Citizens Band radio which is limited to 40 channels at 4 watts and is highly abused by its users and relatively unenforced - Multi-Use Radio Service (MURS), which is limited to a six VHF channels and 2 watts and shared with many users - Business Band/LMR Part 90, which is licensed and regulated for business/commercial use with many other shared users - Microwave, which is licensed and heavily regulated - Broadcast radio, which is licensed and very heavily regulated (and is one-way only) None of these services allow you free reign over a wide spectrum of radio with home-built equipment for the purposes of experimentation and recreation, except for the experimental license, which only allows you specific frequencies, power limits, and other regulations based on your license application and grant. I agree that amateur radio regulations are relatively relaxed, if not very generous, liberal compared to the other radio services.
- userbinator 6y agoI agree with the regulations on spectrum and power usage (i.e. "don't shout over someone else"), since it is a shared medium, but definitely not with restrictions on content.
- eythian 6y agoHam radio's purpose and band allocations are not designed to be a secure communication system. They're designed to be a place to experiment with radio, and as a substantial side effect of that can also be a communication system. Adding encryption (and I'd also argue proprietary encodings, but that's another debate) defeats the purpose. Similar to how it can't be used for pecuniary interest. There are places you can use secure communications, for example in the ISM bands (like wifi) or you can license a chunk of frequency for your own use.