6 ms·
> We locked down _too soon_ in many places Or maybe the real answer was a coordinated national response. Why wasn't the NYC cluster confined to NYC or NY stat
by triceratops 6y ago
> We locked down _too soon_ in many places
Or maybe the real answer was a coordinated national response.
Why wasn't the NYC cluster confined to NYC or NY state? If the initial lockdown succeeded in killing community transmission in Oregon, how did it start growing again? Most likely from external sources.
Only a national strategy could have made these individual state-level lockdowns worthwhile. Since we didn't have that, the states implemented a haphazard, patchwork of lockdowns that weren't coordinated.
> I doubt anyone will give a shit what the Governor says. Goodwill has been burned through and then some.
Unfortunately you're right about that.
- salmon30salmon 6y agoState border closures are unconstitutional in the United States, we could never have a national lockdown. The interstate commerce clause prevents it. Among other laws I am sure.
- triceratops 6y ago> State border closures are unconstitutional in the United States I'm not an expert, but that doesn't seem to be the case.[1] > interstate commerce clause I thought that just gave Congress the power to regulate interstate commerce. Again, I'm not a legal expert. 1. https://www.claimsjournal.com/news/national/2020/03/18/296072.htm https://www.claimsjournal.com/news/national/2020/03/18/29607...
- salmon30salmon 6y agoRight, closing borders between states could be seen as an uneven application of a law and prevent interstate commerce. Especially if it were applied unevenly in the sense of "Oregon can have an open border with Idaho but not Washington" because Washington had more cases. Businesses that rely on the border between OR and WA would sue for relief in a hot minute. I am probably wrong about the law used. IANAL.
- triceratops 6y ago> Businesses that rely on the border between OR and WA would sue for relief in a hot minute. So if you gave them relief preemptively they'd be OK, right? In any case, you don't need border closures. Even things like suspending or massively reducing domestic air travel, introducing compulsory self-quarantine upon arrival in a new state etc. might be better than doing nothing. I'm not an expert, but it seems like we never even tried.
- fyfy18 6y agoIn the EU most countries still had borders open for commercial traffic even during the height of the quarantine. This applied not only to trucks shipping tomatoes from southern Europe (rather vital), but also to a plumber hopping across the border to get slightly cheaper products (not so vital).
- minkzilla 6y agoThere is also: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Freedom_of_movement_under_United_States_law https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Freedom_of_movement_under_Un...
- glofish 6y agoyou cannot eradicate this disease unless you turn the nation into China. The viable model is the Swedish model, schools are open, restaurants are open, nobody wears a mask. What they do is voluntarily keep more distance between people. That's it. that will do it. The sky has not fallen, they are exactly on the same track as the US.
- triceratops 6y ago> you cannot eradicate this disease unless you turn the nation into China. Or India? 4x the population, 1/5 the deaths so far. Although they'll catch up eventually - this disease is simply too contagious. But they have a national strategy, everybody is making plays from the same playbook. > nobody wears a mask Why not though? If it's been proven to reduce transmission, it seems stupid to not do it. > that will do it. All that's done is take the US to the top in lives lost to this disease. If that's where we wanted to end up then mission accomplished, I guess. > The sky has not fallen, they are exactly on the same track as the US. See above.
- salmon30salmon 6y agoWe also have a much higher life expectancy than India. One of the theories as to why Africa has not been hit is that they have far fewer old people. Hoisted by our own petard.
- glofish 6y agoYeah like Burundi. They ran 300 test. Only 1 death attributed to COVID, making Burundi the country with the fewest deaths per population.
- glofish 6y agoIndia? You think they have the disease under control? The US is at the top for two reasons, huge and extremely varied country, lots of testing and accountability. China most likely has had more deaths than the US, they just simply chose not report it, ergo they are all good (and that's what Trump wishes the US could do).