5 ms·
Only the US and Brazil, and some of the small Gulf states, seem totally unable to get their coronavirus epidemics under control.[1] Remember when Italy had a hu
by Animats 6y ago
Only the US and Brazil, and some of the small Gulf states, seem totally unable to get their coronavirus epidemics under control.[1] Remember when Italy had a huge problem? That's over. China? Over.
[1] https://ig.ft.com/coronavirus-chart/?areas=usa&areas=chn&areas=ita&areasRegional=usny&areasRegional=usnj&cumulative=0&logScale=0&perMillion=0&values=cases https://ig.ft.com/coronavirus-chart/?areas=usa&areas=chn&are...
- meddlepal 6y agoWhen mainstream and social media turned the public health crisis into a political issue it ruined any chance of ending well. Politics destroys everything it touches in this country. Or put more simply: We would be a lot better off if everyone would just shut the fuck up for 10 minutes.
- untog 6y agoSo the current administration botches the response to a pandemic but the media is blame because they politicized it? Healthcare is a political issue. Pretty much everything is a political issue. To pretend otherwise is to bury your head in the sand.
- archagon 6y agoSure, let's just take politics out of things that affect people.
- K0SM0S 6y agoThere is a popular expression in French that explicits a worthy distinction: “Politique politicienne”. It literally means politician politics, or politicians' politics (a politician is a political figure, like an elected official), and it very derogatorily qualifies all the noise, the blablabla, the unimportant chatter in politics — Wherein politics speaks of egos, not ideas; the part that seldom leads to actual or worthwhile "policy". When a leader is said to be making “de la politique politicienne”, it basically means that's degree zero of intelligent discourse, and solely aimed at tackling political opponents. Cue false claims, supporting opinions you provably don't believe yourself (but party line prevails), etc. It's an old expression, before my time (1980s). It's fallen out of flavor. Probably because 99% of politics has now become de la politique politicienne...
- salmon30salmon 6y agoSee the reply I just posted. You are comparing a Italy to a massive nation. We only had uncontrolled community spread in a few areas in the Mid-Atlantic and New England, MI and LA. Other than that, we had very few cases and locked down burning through all potential goodwill while there was nothing to lock down over. Compare the states of New York and New Jersey to the country of Italy. That is a more fair comparison. Not USA -> Italy. One more thing. Italy didn't beat it. As soon as free movement is restored to the EU, it will spread again. The only thing that would prevent that is the ballyhooed theory that there is latent immunity in 40-60% of the population. If that is the case, than yes Lombardy is in the clear. But if that is the case, then we also ruined the economy over a disease that was only going to infect a quarter of the people feared, and kill even less. Changes the math, doesn't it? Edit: Fixed my stupidity about regions of my own country.
- glofish 6y agoYes, exactly plotting Lombardy and New York show very similar trends. To be fair, in my opinion neither region "defeated" the virus - they just ran out of people that could be easily infected. The seropositivity in NYC is probably pushing 30-40 percent now.
- salmon30salmon 6y agoHa! I just added the "Italy didn't defeat it" caveat. Great minds or something :)
- kgwgk 6y agoSo 70% that could be infected rather than 100% is "running out of people"?
- salmon30salmon 6y agoNo infection, in the history of infections has EVER infected 100% of people. So already I can ignore you as an alarmist. But I won't. I will say that being susceptible is not evenly distributed across a population. This is why prisons, meat packing and old people homes are more likely to have outbreaks. The corollary to that is that R0 is not consistent in a population. The R0 for people who live in old folks home is far higher than a bachelor who works from home. So when the person said that they ran out of easy people to infect, that is absolutely true.
- glofish 6y agoWould you like to live like the Chinese? No. Would you like to have the same death rates as Italy (much higher than US)? No. Is the disease eradicated in either country? No. The story of who did better remains to be written. If anything California shut down way too soon. That's the problem that no one seems to talk about.
- Judgmentality 6y ago> If anything California shut down way too soon. That's the problem that no one seems to talk about. What?
- cvlasdkv 6y agoWhat is the death rate of Italy given demographics? Is it still "much higher than [the] US"?
- s1artibartfast 6y agoCurrent deaths per million population: UK: 642 Spain: 576 Italy: 575 France: 441 US: 365 Netherlands 340 EU Average: 208 Germany: 107 I dont have an easy way to adjust for demographics, but the median age of most of the countries listed is 2-3 years greater than the US. Italy is ~ 6.
- MarkMarine 6y agoCountless lives were saved by California shutting down, that’s WHY the death rate isn’t like Italy.
- tenken 6y agoYet ...
- addicted 6y agoItaly was the first western country to be hit with COVID. Italy is also not the richest country with the highest per capita ICU bed availability with a ridiculously expensive healthcare system which while terrible for general welfare was excellently places for an emergency like the pandemic. And if California shut down too early, it was still not a bad decision because you did not know what a good decision was at the time. The fundamental problem in the US has not been shutdowns. It’s been shutdowns which have involved absolutely no planning for the reopenings. That’s the fundamental disaster in the US handling of the situation. The northeast could maybe be forgiven for not doing planning for reopening because they were actually dealing with a crisis during the shutdown. But the rest of the country had no excuse. And unlike the northeast they weren’t the first to be hit, so they had time to see and prepare. Instead, they declared it a Northeast problem as if the virus could tell Jersey Shore residents from South beach residents, and decided to go on with their lives without any planning or preparation anyways.