5 ms·
> what the company perceives as a weakness: the paucity of apps in the Mac App Store. I think that the issue with the Mac App store, is that it imposes restric
by ChrisMarshallNY 6y ago
> what the company perceives as a weakness: the paucity of apps in the Mac App Store.
I think that the issue with the Mac App store, is that it imposes restrictions on a once-free-for-all development environment. I know many app developers that have abandoned it, after giving it a damn fair shake.
Mac developers just got used to being able to wander all over the house, poking their noses into whatever they liked.
iOS, on the other hand, started off restricted. iOS developers have never known the freedom that Mac developers have had.
To be completely fair to Apple, the iOS model is the one that needs to be followed, if security and privacy are the goals, and I think that a big part of MacOS 11 will be to add restrictions.
I suspect that non-App Store apps for the Mac may be seeing the twilight.
I am not looking forward to the restrictions on the Mac, but it has been quite some time since I've stepped outside the walled garden, myself.
- gjsman-1000 6y ago"I suspect that non-App Store apps for the Mac may be seeing the twilight." What about MacOS 11 makes you think this? Literally almost nothing of consequence has changed since Catalina in OS security. Gatekeeper hasn't gotten tighter, you can still disable SIP, homebrew works great.
- ChrisMarshallNY 6y agoThe move towards "iOSing" the OS. It won't be GateKeeper. It will be policies. They won't make it obvious at all, because they know how unpopular it will be. Let's see what the future brings. I'm not thrilled with it (for example, I have one app that I've written, that uses ffmpeg[0], and ffmpeg no likee sandbox). [0] https://github.com/RiftValleySoftware/RVS_MediaServer https://github.com/RiftValleySoftware/RVS_MediaServer
- gjsman-1000 6y agoBut once again, the only "iOS-ing" that has happened so far is the theme. Yes, the theme looks more iOS-like, but that's about it. There are almost no technical differences whatsoever underneath since Catalina and almost no security changes.
- ChrisMarshallNY 6y agoI know Apple fairly well. They have...control issues. They want as much control as they can get, over every aspect of the experience. It can get stifling, but I actually support it, and it's one of the reasons that I have always had faith in the company. The HIG (Human Interface Group) used to be nicknamed "The Blue Meanies" in the 1980s.
- duskwuff 6y agoIIRC, the Blue Meanies were simply the System 7 core developers, not a HIG-specific group.
- ChrisMarshallNY 6y agoI recall them as the HIG group. I first encountered it at MacHack, in 1987, or so. There were a couple of HIG engineers, there, and they referred to themselves that way. The reason was, because they insisted that app developers follow HIG guidelines.
- duskwuff 6y agoAre you sure? The story I've always heard is that the Blue (Mac OS) vs. Pink (Taligent) team split originated in a planning meeting around 1988, and the "Blue Meanies" were core members of the Blue team.
- ChrisMarshallNY 6y agoMaybe. I just remember people referring to them as "Blue Meanies" because of the characters in The Yellow Submarine[0]. They were the ones that hated music and creativity, and folks didn't like HIG telling them they couldn't have fuschia scrollbars in their new, five-thousand-dollar color Macs. But that said, I think you are correct[1]. The last MacHack I attended (maybe 1989?), Dean Yu hadn't yet been hired by Apple, and was infamous for writing system-crashing inits (Kill Dean's Inits!). I think he wrote the "Energizer Bunny" init that could have the EB running around every computer on the network. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blue_Meanies_(Yellow_Submarine) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blue_Meanies_(Yellow_Submarine... [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blue_Meanies_(Apple_Computer) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blue_Meanies_(Apple_Computer)
- hn_check 6y ago"The move towards "iOSing" the OS." People have been claiming this for literally a decade+ now. The death of macOS is perpetually imminent.
- ChrisMarshallNY 6y ago> The death of macOS is perpetually imminent. The same for PowerPC processors, Intel processsors, and now ARM processors. Remember when the first rumors of Apple switching to ARM surfaced? I think it was about five years ago. To be fair, Apple has been on its "deathbed" a hundred times, in the last three decades. I have been programming Apple since 1986. I have seen quite a bit.
- thejynxed 6y agoTo be fair, they nearly did bite the bullet until Microsoft stepped in with that loan (for entirely non altruistic reasons on their part of course).
- ChrisMarshallNY 6y agoThis is true. I think they also brought stock. I wonder if MS hung onto any stock? It would have been a pretty good investment.
- defnotashton2 6y agoAnd we have made strides in the decade towards that then in the years prior. Sip and custom delivery of software are increasingly difficult.
- hn_check 6y agoIt's remarkable how overwhelmingly negative the comments on HN are to everything Apple does. The top comment is always some "this is the final straw...I'm leaving the platform" screed (if you look back, those people have usually made that declaration a dozen times), and everyone who claims anything contrary is pushed to transparent. HN needs to go out and take a walk and get some perspective. What a bunch of sour assholes.
- scarface74 6y agoPeople have been saying that MacOS was going to be App Store only eventually for over a decade.
- amatecha 6y agoMac App Store was announced in October 2010 (and released Jan 2011) so that's not yet possible, hahaha ;)
- k__ 6y agoIsn't it more the web model? I mean, the web is older, it's locked down, and browsers get more and more features.
- ChrisMarshallNY 6y agoI wouldn't call the Web "locked down." Maybe to JS coders, but it's a real leaky bucket.
- ben_w 6y agoI think the useful similarity between the web and iOS is that neither a rogue app nor a rogue website can access your documents without asking you.
- 0x0 6y agoOn the other hand, what a modern desktop is sorely lacking right now is protecting users and developers from themselves. Whenever I run "npm install" I have to close my eyes and ignore the chills down my spine thinking about how a thousand random npmjs.org account holders just ran their postinstall scripts on my computer with full access to ~/Documents/. The traditional multi-user Unix permission system is no longer appropriate for the modern waterhole malware world. Nobody cares if you break root and hack system binaries, they can always be restored. The gold is in the user's content. We need a system where regular users don't need to worry about defending against software developers who don't carry the user's best interest in mind, and we need a system where even the cowboy I-know-what-I'm-doing developer doesn't point a gun at their foot, while still providing the freedom to tinker and share.
- ChrisMarshallNY 6y agoYup. My thoughts, exactly. The iPhone is a success, because developers are not its target audience.
- moondev 6y agoSeems like docker solves all those issues
- adrianN 6y agoDocker is not meant to be used for security.
- smabie 6y agopledge(2) from OpenBSD pretty much solves this problem.
- sadfklsjlkjwt 6y agoVagrant gives this for dev environments.
- chongli 6y agoscripts on my computer with full access to ~/Documents/ ... Nobody cares if you break root and hack system binaries This is exactly it. Unix is a multi-user system trying to cope in a single-user world and it's not working. The Unix threat model is students on a university mainframe trying to break into each other's accounts. It's totally unprepared for a world of single-user devices where non-technical people want to run untrusted software.
- jayd16 6y ago>the iOS model is the one that needs to be followed, if security and privacy are the goals How so? Why should a centralized store be the zenith of these goals? Even if you assume the only way to be protected is for Apple to anoint binaries as good and pure, you would still gain privacy through decentralized distribution and secure signatures even if Apple controls the whitelist.
- codetrotter 6y agoI don’t think that part of their comment was referring to the App Store, but rather to the way that apps on iOS are sandboxed preventing them from accessing system wide settings and files outside of their sandbox. That’s the way I read that part of their comment anyway.
- ChrisMarshallNY 6y agoYup.
- PeterCorless 6y ago"I suspect that non-App Store apps for the Mac may be seeing the twilight." Obv someone doesn't shop on Steam.
- ChrisMarshallNY 6y agoI do, and being a Mac user on Steam sucks. Epic is even worse. Apple doesn't seem to be particularly worried about it. For all the hate dumped on Mac as being a "toy" computer, it is a terrible gaming computer. I use it to do work.
- amatecha 6y agoOh yeah, I can't even run Steam anymore (because they require 10.11 or newer) so I can't play any of the hundreds of games that WOULD run on my machine, because the downloader (Steam) can't run... :)
- benologist 6y agoMy x86 Macbook Pro has been just extraordinarily capable, dual-booting Windows and using an eGPU has been great for gaming. Maybe some of this will survive through virtualization if we can assign eGPUs to virtual machines.
- duskwuff 6y agoValve doesn't seem particularly worried about it either. Steam's macOS support has always felt like an afterthought -- they've put more effort into supporting the miniscule number of users on Linux (through efforts like Proton) than macOS.
- thejynxed 6y agoFrom my understanding it's because Valve really wants to directly interact with Apple as infrequently as possible.
- mikenew 6y agoI tried so hard to be a gamer on macOS, and I kept telling myself it would eventually get better. But I had to give up. You can't even turn off mouse acceleration, which is a bare-level requirement for RTS games like StarCraft. There's something about an OS that won't let me decide how my mouse works that just irked me to no end. For a while there was some sketchy kernel extension you could pay $20 for to kill the acceleration, but even that stopped working.
- swiley 6y agoMeh. I still can’t find most apps for my iPhone that I had on my mac. Sure there are lots of “webpages but in objective-c with notifications“ and the occasional interesting project that disappears after 2 years because the developer can’t work full time to keep up with API churn, but lots of arguably critical stuff is just missing. There’s no IRC client with working notifications that doesn’t cost money. I haven’t found a working gvim port (occasionally broken ones show up.) I haven’t found an ssh client I like (has key support, has sftp support, has a vte that doesn’t suck) (and no, ish doesn’t count. I shouldn’t have to reinstall my stuff after having my files deleted with no warning every couple weeks.) This is pretty bad for an OS that’s been around for over a decade. I’m pretty sure both palm OS and windows had decent ssh clients after 10 years. I haven’t found a replacement for wish (which is super useful for flinging together a quick GUI app when someone needs one) There’s nothing that really replaces AppleScript (shortcuts is more like the goofy graphical automation thing OS X had that uses the same API) There’s no Arduino IDE There’s no sync thing port or anything that could even replace it. No BitTorrent client, no useful mail clients (none of them can download mail in the background) no good alternative podcast/rss clients (see mail) no cron. And of course lots of little tiny (and some not so tiny) shell utilities that are trivially easy to find on OS X are at best reimplemented badly in awkward apps and more often totally unavailable. The Mac App Store is more empty than the iOS store but both are nothing compared to the OSX software library.
- saagarjha 6y ago> I shouldn’t have to reinstall my stuff after having my files deleted with no warning every couple weeks. iSH shouldn't really be doing this. Do you have any more details?
- swiley 6y agoYou get kicked out of the beta pretty fast if you don’t use it. This means you absolutely can’t rely on it.
- Shivetya 6y agoI am really curious what will happen to applications like Steam and similar. Will the Mac suddenly find itself in the same restrictions as the iOS App store? Will there even be a separate Mac App Store? Steam allows for users to apply activation keys paid for outside the client, normally these are sold directly by the game developer but can be the result of a give away. Can that happen in the current App store? The promises of better performance and all are nice but I am waiting to see if the walls come with it and will Apple pass the savings on to the consumer or lay claim to the increased performance as the reason prices stay the same or get higher.
- PopeDotNinja 6y agoI used the App Store to install a couple apps once, and I didn't see the value add. It offers nothing (I care about) and can't comes with trade-offs I don't need, such as untimely updates.
- jmull 6y ago> I suspect that non-App Store apps for the Mac may be seeing the twilight. I doubt it. There's literally no reason at all to transition macOS to be like iPadOS... since iPadOS already exists. If they wanted to do that they could literally simply discontinue macOS and only sell devices with iPadOS. Boom, done. Of course, there are a million reasons to not do that, which is why macOS will continue to exist.
- pier25 6y agoI agree. I just can't see Adobe, Autodesk, etc, distributing their desktop apps via the Mac App Store.
- ChrisMarshallNY 6y agoI think Apple wants to achieve the “philosopher’s stone” of software development: write once, deploy everywhere. Securely and robustly. I’m not sure that making money (in this case) is their biggest goal. I think having as much control as possible, over every aspect of the process is more what I suspect they want. That’s fairly typical “strong brand” stuff, and Apple has one of the strongest brands in the world. I’m not sure they can achieve it, but everything they are doing (SwiftUI, etc.) points that way. Since they have full control of the hardware, SDKs and operating system, as well as a huge pile of money, they may actually pull it off. There’s no reason to think they wouldn’t establish “special deals” with Adobe and Microsoft, to allow their software to be distributed through the store at a reduced (or possibly even subsidized) rate, as it would definitely be to Apple’s advantage to have the software in the store. Big corporations do that all the time. In a previous job, Intel gave us tens of thousands of dollars worth of help in optimization, for similar reasons. They seem to have done a number of really difficult things. I’ve learned not to write them off. They are fairly good at playing the long game.