5 ms·
It seems like a stretch to call the algorithm "racist". It's the humans with the bias here. It only seems racist because you are capable of recognizing the imag
by jeffbee 6y ago
It seems like a stretch to call the algorithm "racist". It's the humans with the bias here. It only seems racist because you are capable of recognizing the image on the left and you know he identifies as a black man. The point of the algorithm is that the photo on the right closely resembles, when downsampled, the photo on the left, and the photo on the right is a generative artifact that has characteristics of human faces. It only seems "racist" if you cherry-pick one example and don't look at all the other faces the algorithm generated.
- JulianMorrison 6y agoThe training data is racist. This is a common problem in AI. It produces no black faces. Even as a guess.
- jeffbee 6y agoHow did you conclude this? The paper says 10.1% of the produced face are Black.
- JulianMorrison 6y agoI was mistaken, and going by examples I saw.
- pc86 6y agoCitation needed, because you're making a claim in direct opposition to the paper itself.
- JulianMorrison 6y agoI was mistaken, and going by examples I saw.
- mola 6y agoIt takes one bad application of such technology to ruin a person's life. We can't have a mindless algorithm take or assist decisions that can effect a person's life without extreme caution. Not because people who make these decisions are never wrong but because they are held accountable. These algorithms give false impression of realness and truth while being totally unaccountable. Just look how Yan Lecun (who wasn't even accused of anything) immediately took to throw the blame on the data and not the algorithm. His claim is just a silly demagoguery because with ML there's no real distinction between data and algorithm. But the point is ML is dangerous because it makes it way too easy to pass the buck and doing harm without accountability. Lecunn just made a great demonstration....
- jeffbee 6y agoI think it's interesting in that it points out the range of faces that could have produced the pixelated version. You think it's Obama but on a certain objective metric it could just as easily have been anonymous guy. Why couldn't it be used to exonerate someone who supposedly appears in a blurry surveillance video?