4 ms·
> Nina Lakhani is an environmental justice reporter with Guardian US, where she's reporting for the Our Unequal Earth project. I'm not really up to date on Ame
by roenxi 6y ago
> Nina Lakhani is an environmental justice reporter with Guardian US, where she's reporting for the Our Unequal Earth project.
I'm not really up to date on American water politics. Is this article presented with a partisan slant or is it fairly neutral?
Job titles like that were a fair signal of things being partisan pieces a few years ago but the style might be changing.
- DanCarvajal 6y agoAt the very least the sample size of cities they use is 12, which seems insufficient. The mention they they are diverse selection but half the cities on the list are in desert or near desert climates, where water scarcity comes into play. I'm not saying that water can't be expensive, and that in some places agricultural uses are just downright wasteful (we grow a lot of food in irrigated deserts), but all of my bias flags have gone up in this article.
- justin66 6y agoThey spend a few paragraphs on Cleveland, which is pretty close to the opposite of a desert city. Rebuilding the sewers is an expensive, multi-decade project here that needs to be paid for, and water treatment and pumping isn't free anywhere. They're quite right that rising water and sewage costs are a concern here, but it would have been interesting for them to spend a little more effort and explain how the guy they mentioned accumulated $30k in debt to the water company, which is a bit extreme even for the area. (googling the guy revealed a separate story of him being foreclosed on because of taxes: https://www.news5cleveland.com/news/e-team/warrensville-heights-man-could-lose-his-home-over-25-cents https://www.news5cleveland.com/news/e-team/warrensville-heig...)
- igammarays 6y agoPartisan bias notwithstanding, the plain facts presented in the article seem to indicate pretty objectively that there is a major nationwide problem with water infrastructure. Denial is blindness. - "Nationwide, the rising cost of water has significantly outstripped the consumer price index over the past decade." - Federal funding for water systems has fallen by 77 percent in real terms since its peak in 1977. - The U.S. is the only country in the industrialized world without a regulatory system, responsible for monitoring rates and performance, according to Stephen Gasteyer, professor of sociology at Michigan State University.
- roenxi 6y agoYeah, and if the piece is neutral those are quite persuasive. But if it is partisan, those facts could be carefully selected to be highly misleading. It is easy to lie with true statistics. Every group of loons has a set of favoured statistics that they can trot out. Hypothetically, if it was decided in 1975 that there was going to be a transition from Federal to State management of water then the last two points would be evidence of a system working as intended. It isn't a fundamental truth that the US Federal government in particular has to be the body that regulates and funds water infrastructure. After reading the article I doubt there was such a deal but that is assuming the article is neutral despite a signal that I usually assume shows strong bias. It would be absolutely routine for a partisan to assume that their pet issue requires national funding by the Federal government. Happens in every country on every topic and it is often a stupid assumption.
- runako 6y agoYour question (perhaps unintentionally) cuts to the heart of the matter. Any discussion income or wealth inequality in the US is inherently partisan, as one side largely insists the topic is irrelevant/is overstated/etc. and therefore is not worthy of discussion. Similarly, mentioning climate change or counting firearm deaths are also partisan topics in the US. So to answer your question -- yes, this article is partisan because it attempts to examine a topic that we have decided is inherently partisan.