4 ms·
Regardless of the intentions of the author, any piece of art can be read by some as a reflection on the real world (perhaps one of the best examples that is not
by tsimionescu 6y ago
Regardless of the intentions of the author, any piece of art can be read by some as a reflection on the real world (perhaps one of the best examples that is not post-modern is the often touted interpretation of The Lord of the Rings as an allegory for WWII, which is very explicitly against Tolkien's wishes and intents).
Especially in a pseudo-naturalistic game, it is interesting to observe which aspects the game chose to model and which aspects it chose not to model, and discuss the implications to the comparison between the game world and the real world. This is as valid for Factorio as it is for Conquistador or Monopoly or Civilization VI. If the reader believes that "important" (to them) aspects were left out, they may legitimately criticize this reading of the game and point out why viewing some aspect as realistic would be wrong, regardless. Of course, it would absolutely NOT be legitimate to automatically extend this criticism to the game itself, or even more so to the author, it is just a criticism of a certain reading of the game.
There are cases when this type of reading can be seen as an explicit intention of the game design, and in those cases it starts to become more acceptable to criticize the author(s) themselves. For example, while pollution was a major problem in early Civ games, it was removed from the newer ones (until the latest expansion for Civ 6). Given the known importance of pollution in recent human history and discourse, and its presence in the other games, this omission can naturally be seen as intentional and can be criticized or praised based on the message it sends. This would not be correct for Factorio.
- LoSboccacc 6y agobut often enough the blue curtain is just a blue curtain
- monadgonad 6y agoThat doesn't matter! Art is about what we, the readers, make of it.
- LoSboccacc 6y agono, that's the interpretation of an art piece, art in itself exist as an expression of a singular intent (well, potentially from a collective of authors) further reflections are independent thoughts which exist because of the interaction with the art piece, but not within the art piece itself. as such, these are observations of one's self, and not of the art.
- tsimionescu 6y agoMy whole point is that this is reductive. Even if the author meant the blue curtain to only be a blue curtain, that doesn't mean it can't be interesting to imagine some symbolism for it, and discuss the implications of that symbolism, and then criticize this interpretation. As long as we are not ascribing this interpretation to the author, and as long as we are not claiming that it is the ONLY true interpretation, what is the harm in this? Why is it invalid?