3 ms·
This is reading way too much into the game. The game is not a didactic device that aims to teach a lesson about ecology, conservation, and the peaceful coexiste
by kccqzy 6y ago
This is reading way too much into the game. The game is not a didactic device that aims to teach a lesson about ecology, conservation, and the peaceful coexistence with nature, just like plenty of works of fiction do not address anything in the real world—they are simply figments of the author's imagination.
> Also, a game is not a lecture in economy or ecology.
Okay good, because this sentence invalidates pretty much all of the author's criticisms.
I feel that the whole article is just like the people who say shooting games are harmful because they promote violence in real life (they don't). Why not write about them? "Shooting games actively ignore the basics of human-human interaction, and ultimately the basics of life."
Also, I don't think the author played this game where pollution is turned off:
> As a game device, the aliens force the player to build a machinery of war. If one would take out the products, the buildings, the technology research etc. directly or indirectly connected to military, there is only a fraction left. So for a great deal, this game is a war game, with little strategic value I might add.
When you turn off pollution, you turn off the militaristic aspects of the game, and I can assure you there are plenty of interesting things to explore without the military. From basics like fully utilizing the two-sided nature of conveyor belts (you can totally have each half delivering completely different products and prevent them from mixing up, therefore saving space), to intermediate stuff like fluid mechanics (how many pumps and where), train station design (how to load and unload efficiently) and railroad planning (train signals are surprisingly rich), to advanced things like circuit networks and combinators.
- pmoriarty 6y ago"The game is not a didactic device that aims to teach a lesson about ecology, conservation, and the peaceful coexistence with nature, just like plenty of works of fiction do not address anything in the real world—they are simply figments of the author's imagination." The concepts of Procedural Rhetoric[1] argues against this view of games. "The term "procedural rhetoric" was developed by Ian Bogost in his book Persuasive Games: The Expressive Power of Videogames. Bogost defines procedural rhetoric as "the art of persuasion through rule-based representations and interactions, rather than the spoken word, writing, images, or moving pictures" and "the art of using processes persuasively." ... "Procedural rhetoric also views games as strongly rhetorical--we "read games as deliberate expressions of particular perspectives." The exploration of possibility spaces becomes rhetorical and instructive as soon as games make claims about aspects of human experience, whether they do so intentionally or inadvertently." [1] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Procedural_rhetoric https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Procedural_rhetoric
- ajuc 6y agoYou can take the same set of rules and reskin it with the opposite narrative. So I disagree. The rules aren't persuading - the narrative is. In case of factorio the resking could be about evolving an ecosystem of plants, bacteria, fungi and animals that defend against invasions of robotic miners. Instead of pollution the determining factor that causes invasions would be biomarkers in the atmosphere (which alien probes notice and aliens send the robotized fleet). There are games like "Cards againt Humanity" or "Dungeon Keeper" where if you take the narrative seriously (which you shouldn't) - it's persuading people to kill everybody. But I'm pretty sure nobody went on a rampage because of these games :)
- SiempreViernes 6y agoFactorio as it exists now is the result of a series of deliberate choices, and the point about the bugs being there to force you into weapon production is explicitly stated in the gameplay trailer[0]. You can also compare with Minecraft that has some mobs you can domesticate or otherwise just keep at bay with a simple door. > Also, I don't think the author played this game where pollution is turned off As I'm sure you can see yourself, Factorio without bugs and pollution is a very different game, a game that you don't play by default. [0] https://youtu.be/KVvXv1Z6EY8?t=88 https://youtu.be/KVvXv1Z6EY8?t=88
- tsimionescu 6y agoRegardless of the intentions of the author, any piece of art can be read by some as a reflection on the real world (perhaps one of the best examples that is not post-modern is the often touted interpretation of The Lord of the Rings as an allegory for WWII, which is very explicitly against Tolkien's wishes and intents). Especially in a pseudo-naturalistic game, it is interesting to observe which aspects the game chose to model and which aspects it chose not to model, and discuss the implications to the comparison between the game world and the real world. This is as valid for Factorio as it is for Conquistador or Monopoly or Civilization VI. If the reader believes that "important" (to them) aspects were left out, they may legitimately criticize this reading of the game and point out why viewing some aspect as realistic would be wrong, regardless. Of course, it would absolutely NOT be legitimate to automatically extend this criticism to the game itself, or even more so to the author, it is just a criticism of a certain reading of the game. There are cases when this type of reading can be seen as an explicit intention of the game design, and in those cases it starts to become more acceptable to criticize the author(s) themselves. For example, while pollution was a major problem in early Civ games, it was removed from the newer ones (until the latest expansion for Civ 6). Given the known importance of pollution in recent human history and discourse, and its presence in the other games, this omission can naturally be seen as intentional and can be criticized or praised based on the message it sends. This would not be correct for Factorio.
- LoSboccacc 6y agobut often enough the blue curtain is just a blue curtain
- monadgonad 6y agoThat doesn't matter! Art is about what we, the readers, make of it.
- LoSboccacc 6y agono, that's the interpretation of an art piece, art in itself exist as an expression of a singular intent (well, potentially from a collective of authors) further reflections are independent thoughts which exist because of the interaction with the art piece, but not within the art piece itself. as such, these are observations of one's self, and not of the art.