3 ms·
Could someone please explain this one for me? From the info in the article, Geohot testified that he never signed up for a PSN account. Sony is said to have pr
by marshray 16y ago
Could someone please explain this one for me?
From the info in the article, Geohot testified that he never signed up for a PSN account. Sony is said to have produced evidence that he did, in fact, sign up for one under a different pseudonym.
Lying under oath is generally a crime, but whether or not he would be seriously prosecuted for that I have no idea. Microsoft seemed to do it with impunity in their antitrust trials years ago (e.g., they submitted video which turned out to have been fake to some degree).
In any case, it would seem pretty bad for his case since I think he was claiming that he never once accepted Sony's PSN user agreement.
That he's in South America, presumably with all the money people donated for his legal defense, makes it look even worse for him.
Hopefully, this will not have any negative impact on the general principle that it's legal to do whatever you want with the physical products you buy.
What is so special about California?
In some parts of California the economy appears to be largely based on "intellectual property". It's reasonable to assume that Sony chose this jurisdiction for a reason.
- Natsu 16y agoTechnically, they've produced evidence that someone using a PlayStation with the same serial number as his signed up for a PSN account. There are several possible explanations for that, for example, perhaps a friend used it or it was a refurbished PS. Of course, I have no way of knowing one way or the other, so we'll have to wait and see how it plays out in court.
- marshray 16y agoI think they said it was purchased at a store and activated from an IP address near his house, and the nick was also used to discuss things Geohot has special expertise in. Add up enough bits of circumstantial stuff and it starts to count for real evidence. Still, it would have been better if he had told the truth and not fled the country. All that's assuming everything in the article is accurate and complete, which it's probably not. Sony makes it hard to avoid on the PS3, but any real professional clean-room reverse engineer would have resisted the temptation to accept the PSN EULA. Which ironically lends a dab of credence to Geohot's claim that he's just a talented amateur for-the-love-of-it hacker rather than a professional profit motived pirate. An organized piracy ring probably would have covered their tracks a bit better.