4 ms·
So as long as you donate a percentage of your income to a good cause, it doesn't matter how you made that income? Like if you run a serial killer business or th
by Tichy 18y ago
So as long as you donate a percentage of your income to a good cause, it doesn't matter how you made that income? Like if you run a serial killer business or the Mafia, you are still good, as long as you donate to cancer research?
Not a judgement about Bill Gates Foundation vs Stallman, I don't know much about it, just questioning your logic.
My qualified opinion from reading lots of crime novels and watching mainstream Hollywood movies is that publicly donating to good causes is established standard practice for villains. (Again, not saying BG is a villain - being able to donate to good causes is one good motivation for trying to hit it big with a startup).
- ComputerGuru 18y agoGates didn't steal his money - he made it a way that Richard Stallman happens to disapprove of... there's a big difference. Gates took his capitalist profits and put them to good use treating malaria in 3rd world countries - doesn't smell like the mafia or organized crime to me; but what do I know.
- Tichy 18y agoIf you read what I wrote, I am not claiming that Bill Gates is running the mafia. I am merely making the strictly logical point that doing something good doesn't prove that your other actions are not bad. I usually defend the business practices of Microsoft in discussions (for example http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=229715 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=229715) - I am in general for capitalism (I say in general because people might have varying definitions of capitalism in mind). But if what Stallman says is true, that behind the scenes Microsoft is investing in damaging industries, I think it is fair to take that into account. Again, I have to stress I don't know the substance of Stallman's accusations - but something tells me you won't notice that I wrote that sentence anyway... In general, I like Bill Gates, I think he is a very capable guy.
- deleted 18y ago[deleted]
- Create 18y agoGates didn't steal his money - he made it a way that Richard Stallman happens to disapprove of... there's a big difference. Not only RMS would disapprove. Big difference. Backgrounder: http://www.theregister.co.uk/2008/05/19/ballmer_eggs/ http://www.theregister.co.uk/2008/05/19/ballmer_eggs/ http://www.theserverside.com/news/thread.tss?thread_id=49451 http://www.theserverside.com/news/thread.tss?thread_id=49451 How about spending those EU funds directly to cure illness and not let MS and lawyers chip away at it???
- krschultz 18y agoI agree with you on the point you are making. For example Hezbollah in Lebanon gains much of their power from their charity work - and uses that power for terrorist actions. BUT I don't think you can equate BillG with the mafia, villians, or terrorists. So in this instance, RMS is WAY off base, and winning himself no favors. In fact he just looks like a whiner.
- Create 18y agoAs a person who was born in a present day US colony, I can personally prove you wrong. These people make poor people suffer the exact same way as the Mafia and other villains. You can call it white collar crime, creative accounting, aggressive business practices or whatever euphemism you are comfy with. But the end result is the same: extort wealth from the defenceless.
- bayareaguy 18y agoYou probably have a point but your statement is a little extreme. You have to look at the benefit the software provides as well as the cost and there are times when a closed source system is better than no system at all.
- greendestiny 18y agoI'm not sure I follow your logic? ComputerGuru hasn't suggested that the Gates Foundation exonerates Bill Gates in anyway, just that its hypocritical of Stallman to use FUD.
- Tichy 18y agoMaybe I misread his post then.