4 ms·
First, "extractive" isn't a binary, it's a continuum. All economies are extractive to some degree - everybody's got taxes. But some are considerably more extr
by AnimalMuppet 6y ago
First, "extractive" isn't a binary, it's a continuum. All economies are extractive to some degree - everybody's got taxes. But some are considerably more extractive than others.
Second, China. China's economy was very extractive under Mao. (If you don't like the term "extractive", call it "state dominated" instead.) Under Deng, they became less so, and the economy prospered. If there's enough latent potential in the economy, you don't have to go all the way to "100% non-extractive" to tap it. Just less extractive will get you some of the gains.
Now, I grant you that the results are not a good definition of "extractive". But "abolition or severe limits on private property, state-run enterprises, excessive regulation and taxation" are in fact a reasonably good definition.
- asdfman123 6y agoI'm just anticipating the ideological implications there: once again conflating reasonable goventment solutions with radical socialism. Obviously authoritarianism is bad, especially when it does not care for economic realities, but does that really mean anything for western democracies?
- AnimalMuppet 6y agoIt means: Don't become authoritarian. Don't ignore economic realities. That applies to both the government, and (since it's a democracy) to the people.