4 ms·
I believe Apple can make processors for laptop and normal desktop in A-series way but I'm curious how they make for Mac Pro. Adopting architecture like chiplet?
by fomine3 6y ago
I believe Apple can make processors for laptop and normal desktop in A-series way but I'm curious how they make for Mac Pro. Adopting architecture like chiplet?
- marricks 6y agoThey said they'd be using Intel chips for a while, it could specifically in regards to Mac Pro. Even if apple could make a great server/high performance chip that seems like possibly a lot of additional work for little gain in the market? Keeping intel chips for some computers may make more sense in keeping their toes in the water for intel incase they need to rekindle that relationship for future projects down the road.
- fomine3 6y agoI'm also agree that keep using Intel for Mac Pro is reasonable but I heard that they transition for own chip within two years.
- kshacker 6y agoTransition = all products have an option within 2 years Also means == some products (13" mbp) migrate fully and are Apple only, And some don't (Mac Pro) and have both options. Just reading the tea leaves.
- pier25 6y agoYou think these 2 years is also the number of macOS versions that will keep supporting Intel?
- Pxtl 6y agoUp until last month I would've said they would keep things around much longer - I mean, they supported old iPods and iPhones far longer than their competitors... But the killing of openGL and 32-bit software is making me wonder about their previously-amazing commitment to supporting older things.
- wiredfool 6y agoI suspect that killing 32bit was a necessary step, as they aren’t going to port deprecated features to new platforms. They did some of this before intel, I think with some of the transitional MacOS->OS X APIs.
- terramex 6y agoNo way, in 2 years they will only stop shipping new Intel Macs but will continue supporting existing ones for a few years more. Last PowerPC Macs were released in October 2005 and first Intel-only MacOS X was released in August 2009, almost 4 years later.
- labcomputer 6y agoThat's what happened last time: Intel support was announced during OS X Tiger, and 10.4.4 was the first public release with support for x86. 10.7.0 was the first release without support for PPC. So 10.5 Leopard and 10.6 Snow Leopard were the two major releases with support for both Intel and PPC. Now, Apple tends to provide security updates for at least a few years for each OS release, so I can envision recent Intel Macs getting security updates for another 4-5 years.
- TheOtherHobbes 6y agoThe goal is to transition in two years. Given Apple's record at the high end, I believe that goal is optimistic. I would be astonished if an Ax chip can match the media creation performance of the Xeons in the MacPro and iMacPro any time soon. The top Xeon has 28 cores, and matching that is going to be an interesting challenge. I think it's more likely there were be further splits in the range, with prosumer iMacs running Ax and no-compromise pro models staying on Xeon for at least the next few years.
- johnbellone 6y agoEven if the goal to transition is 2 years that still means there will be a long tail of having to support Intel chips for future updates to the operating system. I have a 2011 Mac Pro that is chugging along perfectly fine with zero issues.
- nikodunk 6y agoTim Cook did say at the end that they still had intel hardware in the pipeline. Maybe Mac Pro will stay intel for a while?
- saagarjha 6y agoRumors have it that there's a new iMac with Intel processors.
- grecy 6y agoI have to assume they'll just put a bunch of processors in there, go massively parallel.
- masklinn 6y agoMayhaps ARM will be for non-pro lines at least initially aka Macbook (Air?), then iMac, and possibly later MBPs and Mac Pro?
- enos_feedler 6y agoI was thinking they would put ARM into an "i" line of laptop and desktop machines. iBook and iMac naming maybe.
- masklinn 6y agoPossible, they've yet to drop the i-moniker of the imac after all, though resurrecting the ibook after so long and when the macbook remains "available" would be a bit odd.
- AgloeDreams 6y agoI imagine they may use a mass amount of SOCs. Keep in mind that their Laptop game plan may be to build CPUs to the Max limits of the TDP and then use their (rather incredible) power management system to reduce power far below Intel chips for normal use. This is the iPad Game-plan, the chip is rarely ever fully hammered. You may see a 12 core Macbook Air capable of (unsustained) desktop Ryzen-level performance but it will generally be ran as 6 low power cores and one or two high power cores, with bursts of insanity when needed. If you can pool a few of those together, it would be easy to beat Intel's server offerings.
- fomine3 6y agoUsing mass amount of SoCs effectively on a single machine isn't trivial. Even AMD go for simple solution on EPYC 7002.
- AgloeDreams 6y agoOf course it isn't, but it's very, very valuable for them. Even if they make a custom chip that is the CPU minus the SOC portions.
- johnbellone 6y agoI'd expect that the high end Mac Pro is the last model to drop.