16 ms·
Mathematicians urge colleagues to boycott police work in wake of killings
- koheripbal 6y agoThis doesn't seem to make sense. By more accurately predicting where crimes will occur, the police departments can reduce the amount of patrols needed.
- catalogia 6y agoIf they inaccurately predict where crime will occur, their recommendations could cause an elevated number of patrols in some neighborhoods.
- lawnchair_larry 6y agoNothing that these people are doing makes sense or demonstrates any capacity for forethought.
- eplanit 6y agoIt demonstrates an extreme and irrational fear of thoughtcrime, though.
- sudosysgen 6y agoThere are very good reasons why proactive policing leads to bad outcomes. You could read up on that before. Predicting where you will need to send patrols is proactive policing.
- uoaei 6y agoI urge you to read Minority Report, or watch the movie.
- mindcrime 6y agoOn that note, I encourage everyone to read more PKD in general. You can't go (too) wrong reading any of his stuff. Valis is pretty f'in weird, but still harmless. I think.
- nickff 6y agoThe book ("The Minority Report") and the movie have radically different messages.
- retortio 6y agoThat's like telling someone planning on getting their driver's license to watch The Fast and the Furious as if it has any relation to actual driving anyone encounters.
- chrisseaton 6y ago> I urge you to read Minority Report, or watch the movie. This is fiction.
- munk-a 6y agoFiction is a really powerful tool that can be used to warn us of societal dangers while sparing us actually needing to live through them. It is fiction, so it isn't a history book and there are plenty of assumptions on how things will work. However, in good fiction, those assumptions are plausible and highlight a future that may happen. Dismissing fiction is just like having a stock manager that dismisses quarterly reports since they don't definitively tell you how the company will be doing - they just tell you how it has been doing. Prediction and imagination are not flawless tools, but they are helpful to plan for the future. (Which is amusing to say in the light of the book being discussed)
- chrisseaton 6y ago
- mindcrime 6y agoI would agree with that, if we lived in the futuristic utopian society of Star Trek:TNG. But our world appears to be closer to a cyberpunk dystopia, where you can't trust the powers-that-be to use that kind of technology for good, peaceful, and just ends. Instead, they'll use it to advance their own greed and hate fueled agendas, and to perpetuate existing structural biases.
- qntty 6y agoPeople in high crime neighborhoods rightly regard the police as the enemy, because the police treat them as the enemy. Giving the enemy better intel is never desirable.
- sudosysgen 6y agoExcept this is not how it works. We are not accurately predicting where crimes will occur, but maximizing the amounts of arrests. Indeed, sending a police patrol will only catch the kind of crime that happens in socio-economically disadvantaged communities, which in turn contributes to skewing the data to suggest that more crimes there, which leads to more policing, which leads to more crime, and so on. Meanwhile, wage theft, over twice the size of all other kinds of theft put together, keeps growing year after year. Police patrols should be entirely reactive, and not proactive. Proactive policing does not work.
- gloryofman 6y agoNot all crime is equal, and to present crime as purely a dollar value is a bit disingenuous. Wage theft is important, and isn't pursued nearly enough, but it isn't on the same level as violent crime, which happens primarily in disadvantaged communities. Completely agree on proactive policing. End the drug war and it would cease to be necessary.
- oh_sigh 6y agoThe 'proactive' is just driving or walking around a neighborhood. It isn't (necessarily) doing things like stop and frisk or just going around accosting random people on the street.
- sudosysgen 6y agoIt's not just driving or walking around a neighbourhood, it's doing your best to find the maximum amount of crime. Otherwise, you wouldn't need mathematical models in order to optimize the "efficacity" of the operation. The vast majority of crime where police should be involved are crimes where the victim can call the police later. For those that don't fit this criteria, either police patrols are already ineffective (targeted assassinations, for example), or the police isn't being called because the victim thinks it will make the situation worse. Which in many cases is true, and I think fixing that problem would be a good step to take.
- 6y ago
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- jfengel 6y agoNot if the patrols they are sending have been taught to see all of the people in those places as targets. Police can literally make things worse. Even the victims of crime often don't want police there. This has been known in those communities for decades. It's only the most obvious, well-documented brutality that has begun to make other people aware of it. It's the broad reaction to that brutality, where other police and their strongest supporters reflexively excuse the inexcusable, that have made people like these mathematicians realize that sending the police doesn't solve the problems that their models are pinpointing. If the mathematicians want to help people, they'll model the broader causes of poverty, injustice, and inequality. Then we can try to solve the real problems, rather than "I heard there was a problem, let's send in people with guns until it gets better."
- oh_sigh 6y agoThe victim's desires for police involvement is usually not very relevant. The victim can not provide any information to the police, but that doesn't mean that the police can't or shouldn't do anything. Respecting the victim's wishes is basically giving tacic approval of spousal abuse and honor killings.
- sudosysgen 6y agoYou don't fix spousal abuse nor honour killing by sending police to arrest people in poor neighbourhood. You fix spousal abuse by social interventions and honour killing by targeted response combined with social interventions.
- devtul 6y agoAre you saying that the visible presence of the police won't stop any type of crime, or just specifically your spousal abuse example?
- sudosysgen 6y agoIn general physical presence of police helps crime in the short term, but not in the media to long term, instead it likely makes it worse. The spousal abuse example wasn't mine, but the GP's.
- bena 6y agoBut if we put the wrong numbers in, we won't get the right numbers out. This sort of prediction depends on the data being good. That's not a given. Even the crime statistics are problematic. There is an issue with certain groups getting treated differently in arrests and convictions. So you could have an area that doesn't have much crime reported because when crime happens it's not reported as crime. Whereas you can have other areas that have a lot more crime reported because there is less leniency given to the population.
- bonoboTP 6y agoThe problem is, as someone in the field of AI, I can see how much overhyped low-quality products are sold to stakeholders believing they are getting a human-like or godlike artificially intelligent thing, when it's just a bunch of linear regressions or multilayer perceptrons operating on unsanitized data without proper evaluations or misleading numbers in the marketing, careless ways of separating training and test data etc. I think what the article says is likely to be true. It's a scientific cover-your-ass label for the high-ups to be able to do whatever they want and justify it. Similar to how CEOs bring in external consultants and pay them fat money so the CEOs can now do whatever they wanted originally, but now with Big Consulting Firm's stamp of approval. You can make these "AI" models skew to the direction you want. Just as it is with statistics and p-hacking, only that the machine learning community is even less versed in confidence values and is just generally less mature in terms of best practices as it's a newer field. And absolutely researchers should pay attention to who they work for and where the money comes from. Fundamental research is one thing, working on general AI is useful for all human endeavors just like working on energy efficiency or better cars. It's a necessary part of life that bad actors have benefits from a tide raising all ships. But it's not the same when directly working on a project for a bad actor. Similar to how Google engineers stood up against military projects or serving the Chinese censoring machine, it is important for mathematicians and computer scientists to consider whether they are building something unethical. These are professionals, intellectuals who have more responsibility than lower paid workers. We cannot blame the cleaning personnel or the cooks at the police canteen in the same way. It is part of one's civic duty as an intellectual to reflect upon one's societal role and impact. Again, this is not about fundamental research, that might be used for evil purposes. It's about directly working for corrupt organizations. Whether the police in general (or which specific levels or branches) is corrupt enough to refuse working for them and how much worse they are compared to big corporations is hard for me to judge from Europe. But it's certainly something that people working for them should reflect on and make a moral choice because they are the ones who see what they actually work on. There are many places for mathematicians and computer scientists to work at and so they have the luxury to follow their conscience. And all this also applies to intelligence agencies, like the NSA and others as well.
- pizza 6y agoThere is a contradiction in expecting an organization that enhances its capabilities to use its capabilities less. Not that predicting where crimes will occur is really a thing - more likely you are just predicting where a population is getting policed.
- Nasrudith 6y agoIt holds on the assumption of preventative power from those capabilities. Communicable diseases are a good example of a context - if everyone was treated for say tuberculosis with increased capacity then the number of cases would stay down vs just 'stabilizing" the numbers. See nuclear weaponry for an example of declining use. Deterrence and deescalation are where predictive policing could theoretically be useful but in practice it is often just bias laundering or reinforcing their tautologies. Looking at the "wrong side of the tracks" more and the arrest rates will climb there even if crime is actually lower there - let alone confounding variables. Like say the police being called in domestic disputes by witnesses in thin walled apartments and trailer parks but not in large fenced estates even if they are just as loud and violent because they weren't literally heard.
- pessimizer 6y agoIf your response to a set of data showing areas where arrests have occurred in the past is to police those areas more, there is no doubt that in the future there will be more arrests in those same areas.
- timy2shoes 6y agoExactly. Biases in previous data will be amplified with predictive policing algorithms. See, for example, https://rss.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1111/j.1740-9713.2016.00960.x https://rss.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1111/j.1740-...
- coronadisaster 6y agoBut somehow, their budget always increases...
- throwaway_pdp09 6y agoI don't know enough to agree or disagree, but to me having academics even ask questions on the ethics of their work is the most important thing; if one's work affects the real world then you can't duck responsibility for it.
- ISL 6y agoAcademics often ask ethical questions about their work. There are a huge number of physicists who devote time to non-proliferation work, cleaning up the ethical detritus from generations past.
- ummonk 6y agoWell even that is not an ethically straightforward issue. Nuclear proliferation reduces the frequency and typical intensity of violent conflicts, in exchange for risking an extremely high intensity conflict.
- RhysU 6y agoIt's also about the only direction left. There's hardly any lawful, paid proliferation to go around.
- jariel 6y agoThat responsibility includes helping the police (and others) do their jobs well. It's just as much about participation as it is non-participation.
- munk-a 6y agoWell, as a mathematician (or I think, more accurately in the context this article is talking about, a statistician). You do have a responsibility to make sure you work is used honestly and correctly. If someone is taking findings and tools you've developed and misapplying them to make the world less just then you need to take a stand and make sure they're used properly. Also I think the US has a real problem with valuing personal well being over societal well being somehow being warped into being a virtue. If you cheat on your taxes and manage to save 5$ while depriving the US Government of 20$ then you're a hero - this slippery slope has led acting in a morally grey manner for your own benefit being seen as a strength which makes it much more societally acceptable for people who contribute to systems of oppression (facial recognition and people tracking, supporting the spread of disinformation, helping to erase painful truths from public consciousness) to be viewed as "winners" so long as they walk away with a fat check. It's hard for me to tell if this has always been a valued virtue, but having grown up in the US it certainly was an apparent virtue that I was imbued with - somehow we need to work at changing that.
- Bostonian 6y agoSo-called Black Lives Matter costs black lives by making policing less effective. The "Ferguson Effect" has been documented. Recent headline: "104 shot, 14 fatally, over Father’s Day weekend in Chicago" https://chicago.suntimes.com/crime/2020/6/20/21297470/chicago-fathers-day-weekend-shootings-homicide-gun-violence-june-19-22-104-shot https://chicago.suntimes.com/crime/2020/6/20/21297470/chicag... .
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- alexilliamson 6y agoWhat do you mean by "making policing less effective"?
- SamReidHughes 6y agoHe means policing that results in increased homicide rates and reduced homicide clearance rates. Don't you want to solve crimes and put murderers in jail? And scare others away from delinquency?
- psychometry 6y agoHa! Police in the U.S. are hilariously bad at solving crimes. Even murders are solved at less than a 50% rate in many cities.
- alexilliamson 6y agoLess than 50%???? Ha! Try closer to 10% in Chicago. Yes I want murders solved and think there should be someone doing that job. However, the police aren't doing that so why help them with whatever it is that they are doing.
- google234123 6y agoA large issue is that people refuse to help them. How do you solve a crime if no there are witnesses willing to talk...
- raarts 6y agoThere is no question that the advancement of science has been good for humanity as a whole. Using math to improve the effectiveness of the police is a good thing. This effort - however well intended maybe - would throw out the baby with the bathwater.
- sudosysgen 6y agoUsing math to improve the effectiveness of police is not necessarily a good thing, because this kind of works really works to perpetuate proactive policing and over-policing, as well as encodes bias.
- mc32 6y agoSo maybe address the biases? People who live in areas that experience high incidence of criminal activity also want to have crime reduced. They want someone to establish order—when you have a vacuum, someone will fill it, usually someone with even less oversight, though occasionally you can luck out with a benevolent dictator of sorts. So yes people in those areas want policing —though they may also want some reform as well. Few people want no police. They know that’s a recipe for a power vacuum and the domino effect that has.
- bena 6y agoAnd solving world hunger is simple. Maybe feed the people? The biases are deep and insidious. They exist in each and every one of us. "Addressing" them is a complicated issue.
- coffeemaniac 6y agoWell, when you're witnessing multiple instances of officers willingly and enthusiastically assaulting defenseless and innocent citizens/journalists on the street every day, you're past the point of "bias" correction. These instances are not the result of some nebulous ingrained tendency to view others as less than themselves, they're the result of a coordinated and deliberate attempt to assert power. Your assertion that removing police would create a "vacuum" assumes incorrectly that there is currently a sense of "order" established. This is not the case, as there is no set of behaviors black men in particular can adopt which will not result in their extrajudicial execution. Police are more accurately viewed as an occupying militia and I see no reason to believe it would just as soon be replaced by something similar.
- tj-teej 6y agoA lot of comments here are missing the point of boycotting, it's an expression of power with the concrete goal, it's not individual decisions of whether the mathematicians feel the work is "ethical". Yes, having more liberals working in policing is probably more inline with the goals of those liberals than not, but that's not the point of a boycott. If the police can't get the help they need from mathematicians because of a large enough boycott then it gets them to the table and forces them to reform. I'm not arguing whether or not this will work, or making a value judgement, I just see a lot of comments which don't seem to understand this point.
- Uhhrrr 6y agoIf they can't get help from mathematicians, they'll try to do their own analysis with Excel spreadsheets or just use their gut instincts.
- coffeemaniac 6y agoGood, and their word can be treated exactly like we treat the word of any other agency full of non-experts that roll their own analyses with excel. No need to lend them the legitimacy of established mathematicians and other academics.
- romwell 6y agoAnd if they can get by with Excel just as good, then they didn't need mathematicians in the first place. If not, this will make someone unhappy. And this is the whole point of boycott. The police is making mathematicians unhappy. Bad cop, no donut in any dimension.
- Uhhrrr 6y agoIt probably won't be as good, and the people they make unhappy will be the general populace, who will experience more crime and worse policing.
- LegitShady 6y ago>If the police can't get the help they need from mathematicians because of a large enough boycott then it gets them to the table and forces them to reform. They will just hire someone else. Google was making AIs for the chinese government that almost certainly have deep ethical issues and it was barely a thing. Now helping the police is a boycott issue? The question is not "do the police want a seat at the table", its if you want the people working with police to be only people who disagree with you and reject your position?
- exabrial 6y agoThis sounds like _exactly_ the opposite of what needs to be done in fact. I do support ethical decision making, academics should be conscious of first and second order consequences.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- drocer88 6y agoIt appears that one of the signers is selling a competing/alternate/supplemental product: Cathy O'Neil : https://orcaarisk.com/ https://orcaarisk.com/ From her twitter page ( https://twitter.com/mathbabedotorg/status/1273941375382405120 https://twitter.com/mathbabedotorg/status/127394137538240512... ) : Cathy O'Neil @mathbabedotorg I'm interested in algorithmic accountability, civil disagreement, and the social mechanism of shame. Algorithmic auditor at ORCAA.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- SomeoneFromCA 6y agoI wonder if any of the scientist or commenters in this thread have ever lived in a bad hood. The hoods require more and better policing, the worst offenders, who kill orders of magnitude more people are criminal gangs. You remove police - you'll get spike in homicides.
- nerdponx 6y agoRelatively few people are opposed to the idea of police. A much larger number of people are opposed to policing in its current form in the USA.
- kingkawn 6y agoDoes it occur that the gangs are an attempt from within consistently brutalized communities to mirror their brutalizers
- beervirus 6y agoNothing is anyone's fault, huh. He's not a murderer--he's just brutalized and oppressed.
- Nasrudith 6y agoIt has little to do with their brutalizers, it is the nature of physical power and corruption. Many times throughout history gangs form for self protection in absense of a functioning authority. Regardless they inevitably get involved in a racket of some sort or assert their claim to some sort of territory and become just another band of violent thugs out for themselves and a scourge on their host community. The remotely closest thing to a gang that hasn't progressed to that probably isn't like that are the Guardian Angels safety patrols. Being brutalized is neither neccessary nor sufficent, although it may make them more likely. If the "configuration" arises essentially they will go down that path.
- greenhatglack 6y agoI guarantee many of the privileged predominantly white ACAB crowd never lived in areas where their own mom had a higher than average risk of being sexually assaulted or brutally beaten for fun whilst being on public transport during evenings. Their heads can’t fathom such notions and it’s hard for them to comprehend the idea of different opinion. I’ve taking a different approach IRL of not showing my cards on the subject and just agreeing with them. The first chance I get, I will accuse them of racism and homophobia to HR so they can have some of their own medicine. It’s the only way they learn.
- lazyjones 6y agoThey are complaining about "racial bias" in predictive policing products. This "racial bias" is composed of data collected from crime statistics. If reality doesn't support the ideology, reality must be ignored. This is the sorry state of academia nowadays.
- danharaj 6y agoYou are engaging in circular reasoning.
- truculent 6y agoAre you suggesting that data cannot be biased? If so, might I suggest you try reading an elementary guide to statistics? Heck, even a blog post would do.
- josefresco 6y ago"It is simply too easy to create a ‘scientific’ veneer for racism." It seems, law enforcement was using data to create their own reality.
- lazyjones 6y agoNo, it seems certain mathematicians simply assume this to be the case without any scientific argument behind it. Perhaps it's just too easy to call something "racism" just because we don't like it?
- psychometry 6y agoYour asinine point was addressed in the article you're commenting. Evidently, you didn't read it.
- wdevanny 6y agoI think many of the mathematicians would agree with: >This "racial bias" is composed of data collected from crime statistics. They disagree that crime statistics are reflective of where crime occurs. They are more reflective of where police officers are and where crimes are most easily spotted. For example, the racial disparities in policing crack cocaine versus powder cocaine. Predictive systems that read in biased data will produce biased data.
- waffle_ss 6y ago> widely documented disparities in how US law-enforcement agencies treat people of different races and ethnicities Citation needed, particularly for Nature. As far as I can tell the supposed disparities are explained by the amount of violent crime the race and ethnicity commits (leading to more police interactions), but it's impolite to bring that up.
- rickhanlonii 6y ago"Widely documented" means that it's trivial for you to look up the data yourself.
- waffle_ss 6y agoI obviously have, primarily the FBI's Uniform Crime Reporting (UCR), the Bureau of Justice's National Crime Victimization Survey (NCVS), and the Washington Post's police shootings database. If you compare the police-citizen homicide rate of the latter to the violent crime rate by race/ethnicity of the former, it's quite proportional. If you're basing your opinion off of highly publicized gruesome videos, I can show you less publicized videos of other races being killed by police too.
- psychometry 6y agoWould you also like a citation for the statement "racism exists"? There are some truths that are so plainly obvious and supported by mountains of data that it's absurd to demand a citation for them.
- bitcurious 6y agoIf someone made the claim that X people are the genetically less intelligent than Y people, I could point to a dozen times and places in history where that would be considered “plainly obvious,” amongst them America itself a mere century ago. The only reason it’s not today is because we have data to the contrary.
- x86_64Ubuntu 6y agoPart of maintaining these systems of white supremacy involves firstly disbelieving that such paradigms exist, and then secondly putting the labor of "proof" on the marginalized communities and their allies.
- pizza 6y agoThe last 40 years of austerity politics in the US have starved the beast [0] so greatly that the only remaining public infrastructure that functions as it's intended to is policing. For example, in the city of LA, 53% of the city's unrestricted general fund budget went to the LAPD. For everything else, there are parallel infrastructures for the haves - private education, private healthcare, privatized transit, etc. It's something I've thought about a lot in the last few weeks. On top of that, there is some research that suggests communities rate smaller police forces better than larger ones [1]. > To test this, Ostrom worked with the Indianapolis government and her students to measure the quality of policing. Surprisingly, against common assumptions, they found that the smaller the police force, the more positively residents evaluated the police services they got. > "Increasing the size of [the police force] consistently had a negative impact on the level of output generated as well as on efficiency of service provision… smaller police departments … consistently outperformed their better trained and better financed larger neighbors.” > But why did this happen? To explain this, Elinor Ostrom argued that in small communities with small police forces, citizens are more active in community safety. Officers in smaller police forces also have more knowledge of the local area & more trust from people. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Starve_the_beast https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Starve_the_beast [1] https://twitter.com/a_vansi/status/1270406823158468614 https://twitter.com/a_vansi/status/1270406823158468614
- munk-a 6y agoAnd this is exactly where the "Defund the Police" movement comes from and seems like an extremely good movement to pursue - shift that budget balance back in favor of specialized agencies that can better support social needs rather than forcing it all onto the police force. I really just wish it had gotten a better name since that title for the idea really divides people before they even open their minds.
- austincheney 6y agoDefunding the police is generally unpopular where I live. My big city is growing at about 22% decade over decade and will likely surpass San Jose in population over the next 10 years. It is also the lowest density big city in the US. In order to support the growing population the police force must continue to grow as well. The fastest growing area of the city is also the least policed. This not result of negligence from the city but just the geographic direction the city is growing towards and the funding limitations to meet the growing needs of the community. There are plans to put a precinct in my area of the city, which is strongly wanted, but it won’t happen if the police are defunded.
- mikaeluman 6y agoI don’t understand this. Usually the answer to bad algorithms is to produce better ones, through research. What is the alternative? To give up and stay out? Ethical considerations are great. Define fairness and set a valid goal for the algorithm that takes fairness into account. Do the signatories presume a non-quant approach would be less biased towards this supposed “systemic racism”?
- trhway 6y agoi think that it shouldn't be boycotted, instead all such work should be done in public. And not just through the crutches of FOIA. It should be in the open to start with. There should be no NDA (except naturally for whatever PII is protected by law). Police should publish all the data. Any contracts on working with that data, any resulting models and their application should be in the open.
- alexilliamson 6y agoPeople are boiling this down to "less crime = good". Like if a mathematician can design a deployment system such that the percentage of crimes where an arrest is made increases from 15% to 20%, how can that be a bad thing? What if every single one of those additional arrests is a Black person? Well that might require an additional look. It's possible that it's all Black people doing those crimes. It's also possible that the mathematician built an algorithm anchored on years of arrest data from racist cops doing racial profiling. Will the mathematician be able to say, "hey cops can we take a second look?". No. Can the police be trusted to dig into the nuance themselves? Also no. Is racism active and documented in police departments across the country? Yes. Should everyone who has any ability to do so stand up and say, we won't support this shit, which is what these mathematicians are doing? I think yes, but that's obviously my opinion.
- lazyjones 6y ago> It's also possible that the mathematician built an algorithm anchored on years of arrest data from racist cops doing racial profiling. That possibility is explicitly excluded since the data comes from crimes reported by victims, not investigations initiated by police officers.
- alexilliamson 6y agoArrest data includes both.
- BGthaOG 6y agoMinorities are less comfortable calling the police in the first place.
- lazyjones 6y agoDo you have any data to back up that claim, other than anecdotal "evidence"? Here's some real data: https://www.bjs.gov/content/pub/pdf/rpa11.pdf https://www.bjs.gov/content/pub/pdf/rpa11.pdf Across all races and Hispanic origin, American Indians and Alaska Natives (15%) and persons of two or more races (15%) had the highest rates of reporting crime or neighborhood disturbances to the police. No statistical difference was observed between the percentage of white (9%) and black (7%) persons reporting a crime or neighborhood disturbance to police in 2011. Also, perhaps I'm reading it wrong, but Appendix Table 4 suggests that minorities are much more satisfied with police response than the average.
- young_unixer 6y agoThe deeper question: should heuristic methods be used at all by police? I mean not only artificial heuristics like machine learning, but the ones people have always used, e.g.: "acting really weird means the person is probably on drugs/commiting a crime". All prejudices we use are heuristic techniques. Some are badly calibrated and give bad results (e.g. racism) but some may give accurate results (e.g. "poor neighborhoods have a higher crime rate"). Should these techniques be used when they're accurate?
- huntertwo 6y agoCops shouldn’t be put in a spot to make decisions. Otherwise societal biases seep into those decisions. Our policing systems should be resilient against biases in the individuals policing.
- mesozoic 6y agoAnd identity politics breached into the final bastions of logic completing the spread of corruption and signalling the completion of the ritual to summon the lord of chaos.
- retox 6y agoYou'd think mathematicians of all people would be able to look at the numbers of 'killings' and see through the propaganda.
- jxramos 6y agoI've always wondered if there's a probabilistic argument to show just how biased of policing there is by quantitating somehow the arrests made on a given subpopulation and somehow show how improbable it would be to randomly achieve a given arrest disparity to another subpopulation under the presumption of equal offending by those subpopulations. Is there any math to explore such a thing, sort of like flipping a quarter and hitting heads 5x in a row, that sort of thing. To use a less charged example say I have three populations of fish, and all swallow coins in the same proportion as each other. In this universe sharks make up 10% of the fish population, sea-bass 30% and rockfish 60%. Exactly 5% of each fish type has a coin in their belly at any given time. So if we have a world of 1000 fish, then we're talking 100 sharks, 300 sea-bass, and 600 rockfish. Of those 5 sharks, 15 sea-bass, and 30 rockfish have coins in their belly. To measure anything other than those counts of 5% per subpopulation, is there a way to measure how improbable that would be with random selection and subsampling and what not? Does this question even make sense and is well defined enough? My stats strengths aren't the keenest.
- RickJWagner 6y agoReally, nature.com? Is noplace safe from politics?
- s4n1ty 6y agoEveryone agrees that the police should be held to a high standard, but I'm getting tired of people preaching this thinly-veiled anti-police bigotry.