4 ms·
What does it mean to 'overproduce' something? Are you saying it's too polished and well done?
by chrisseaton 6y ago
What does it mean to 'overproduce' something? Are you saying it's too polished and well done?
- ProZsolt 6y agoToo many visual effects and the whole thing feels sterile.
- franciscop 6y agoIt means it seems too artificial and unnatural, so it feels like an ad.
- Aqua_Geek 6y agoI mean, this IS an ad.
- sneak 6y agoIt's so well-rehearsed and body language coached that it feels like watching an infomercial. I mean, it is an infomercial, but it's still annoying and distracting. It's so high-stakes and painstakingly precise that it reminds me of watching the mass games in Pyongyang.
- chrisseaton 6y agoWell-rehearsed, coached, precise, all sound like good things.
- xnyan 6y agoI can't speak for anyone else by myself but for the last several years most of the presenters sounded like they were well dosed with beta blockers before presenting. Not at all natural, or at ease, or relaxing to watch.
- rimliu 6y agoAnd if it were not polished people would complain about how apple lowered the bar, how nothing is the same since Jobs has died, etc. etc.
- eyerony 6y agoThey've been trending that way even at the live events. Last few years the obviousness of all the coaching and rehearsal has been extremely distracting. I mean it was there before but not quite so intensely. They all come off as robotic or like someone's holding a gun on them.
- addicted44 6y agoIn all likelihood, insufficient coaching and rehearsal is why it feels coached and rehearsed. A perfect presentation, which has been extremely well practiced and rehearsed, comes off as natural. Because they havent practiced it enough (and probably because many of them are simply not very good presenters, unlike say Jobs) it falls into the uncanny valley and appears unnatural.
- alexashka 6y agoAn actor can only do so much with a terrible script.
- eyerony 6y agoYeah, you're on to something. I'd guess it's intense and precise coaching paired with people who don't do this sort of thing very often. It seemed to get a lot worse soon after they started trying to get a bunch more presenters involved, some years back. My guess is they didn't think the first couple of those were polished enough, so cranked up the prep, which, when applied to people who haven't developed outstanding presenter-talent, gives you a really fake and awkward effect. I think the somewhat rougher early ones were nicer, personally. To their credit, I guess, most other events I've seen like this since everyone started trying to ape Apple's announcement style have the same problem, and usually worse.