7 ms·
Open IP over VHF/UHF
- drmpeg 6y agoHow about 30 Mbps with OFDM. http://www.w6rz.net/ofdm3.png http://www.w6rz.net/ofdm3.png
- superkuh 6y agoLooks like you spent about 1000x more $ on SDR, RF bits, and computer hardware for that setup than the rpi/rtlsdr options explored in the main article. Still, very cool.
- th0ma5 6y agoAmateur radio, at least in the US, has a ban on encryption, so while we also have signal speed limits that may prevent it, secure sockets are forbidden. I'm not sure how some of the proprietary digital modes get away with it, but I guess money talks.
- nucleardog 6y agoMy guess is that they're not, strictly speaking, "encrypted" any more than the first guys to use FM were "encrypting" their transmissions. They are receivable and decodable, you just need the right equipment. I agree that these things should be kept off the air, but I don't think it's a "money talks" situation.
- UI_at_80x24 6y agoThis is it exactly. You may not try to hide the information that you transmit, but you sure as hell can make it obscure as fuck. Just imagine the fictional conversation: FCC/CRTC: On July the 1st at 14:00 you transmitted an undecipherable message on 28MHz. Amateur Radio operator: I used y-modem protocol to transmit an image using 7P1 (7bits Parity 1 Stop bit). FCC/CRTC: but's that's stupid! Nobody has used that in 40 years! AMO: But it wasn't encrypted. Good bye.
- kawfey 6y agoThis video (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oIyckKhZrpA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oIyckKhZrpA) has a few good points on having private conversations via that don't "obscure the message" via ham radio, namely: - Use rare/odd frequencies that are hard to access with commercial off the shelf gear - use esoteric modes and modulations (like you mention)
- siberianbear 6y agoIs this a thought experiment, or does the FCC really do this? It's hard for me to imagine that they have an army of radio engineers to go looking at all signals, figuring out which ones are "undecipherable", physically identifying the transmit locations and then determining who did it.
- jki275 6y agohams do it. The entire culture works hard to weed out anybody that doesn't follow the rules. If you do something you're not supposed to, there's a good chance someone will figure it out and report you. Foxhunting is a sport for them.
- kayfox 6y agoUndecipherable signals in strange places present an interesting challenge that the ham radio community does rise to explore. During the cold war ham radio operators spent years analyzing and characterizing over the horizon radar systems (The Woodpecker) and other strange signals like numbers stations. Its especially common these days with the advent of software defined radio, spectral displays and large amounts of storage for operators to come across a strange transmission and record it for further analysis, often posting in forums and sending the recordings to other people for them to try and analyze it. And some times those recordings are sent to the FCC and the FCC sends out strongly worded letters. If it really gets bad, the FCC will act and IIRC they average about 20~50 or so fines a year.
- numpad0 6y agoI think what GP is saying is TCP/IP is fine but TLS is not.
- paulgerhardt 6y agoTons of amateur radio links in the US are encrypted. Just look at literally any repeater. The myth that there is no encryption on ham channels is as wide spread as it is misunderstood.
- ta17711771 6y ago"...You may stop me, but you can't stop us all."
- adamtj 6y agoIt is allowed to used an encrypted connection to administer a remote repeater, like for amateur satellites. Only the control link may be encrypted. The repeated signals may not, just like any other amateur transmissions.
- kawfey 6y agoI look at lots of repeaters. I'm a repeater engineer for our city radio club. Not one has any encrypted links, unless you're talking about echolink/allstar/D-Star/YSF, in which the audio is transmitted via the internet through various protocols to other gateways, repeaters, reflectors, conferences, and end users. Even the DTMF tones to control repeaters aren't encrypted. Some repeaters do obscure the re-transmission of the DTMF codes by muting the output, but this is legal.
- paulgerhardt 6y agoInteresting. I’ll have to revisit this topic. My understanding was that the use of encryption was restricted while the parent was saying it is illegal. To clarify what percentage of your clubs repeaters are reachable through one or more encrypted connections?
- gh02t 6y agoEncryption is optional (or not available) in all of the proprietary digital modes used by amateurs, so amateurs simply don't use it even when the radio allows. As a practical matter enforcement can actually be quite difficult and I'm sure there are some folks doing it, but people on the amateur bands generally obey the rule in my experience.
- mmaunder 6y agoExcept when they don’t. The PACTOR debate continues to rage. Sailmail is super valuable for its users, but is breaking the rules in various ways. I’ve been a user and am also a ham. https://www.rrmediagroup.com/News/NewsDetails/NewsID/17804 https://www.rrmediagroup.com/News/NewsDetails/NewsID/17804
- toomuchtodo 6y agoDepending on latitude and the sailor’s pocket, I could see Sailmail users being driven to StarLink if the FCC doesn’t allow Sailmail’s continues operation in its current form.
- gh02t 6y agoWe're talking about encryption, though. Isn't the core of the PACTOR debate related to it being proprietary, not that it's encrypted? Transmitting in a format that is not readily decoded is also problematic legally, but to me there's a major difference between using a proprietary format and using actual cryptography to encipher a message. The latter is uncommon in amateur use in my experience, but I'm only an occasional ham so maybe I'm just not aware.
- userbinator 6y agoArbitrary restrictions like that just make me want to get around them... and reminds me of this phrase I heard many years ago (in the era when encryption laws were far stricter): "What's the difference between encryption and steganography? You don't know."
- squarefoot 6y ago"What's the difference between encryption and steganography? You don't know." Plausible deniability.
- arghwhat 6y agoDon't. Follow the rules, and get them changed if you disagree with them. Amateur radio enjoys the privilege of pretty lax regulation, largely due to the players not making any trouble. Speaking as a fellow radio amateur, we don't want our hobby ruined just because someone wants to be a troublemaker.
- teddyh 6y ago> Amateur radio enjoys the privilege of pretty lax regulation What. You literally have to have a license issued to you personally (no anonymity) by the government to even be allowed to do it. And the rules of what can and can’t be sent are, to my Internet-accustomed mind, excruciatingly onerous. No encryption? No foul language?
- adamtj 6y agoRadio spectrum is a limited and shared resource. It makes sense that it's licensed and regulated. But compared to other parts of the spectrum, the license is cheap and easy to get and the regulations are minimal. It's a public space for experimentation. If you don't want to be seen in public, go to some other area of the spectrum.
- arghwhat 6y agoThe rules are extremely loose. 1. You need a personal license to identify you, as an operator of a radio station. This is similar to how radios on ships and airplanes work - you need to be able to identify every transmission (even cellphones are uniquely identifiable). This is not only part of the entire sport (we're trying to contact and identify each other), but is also used to identify problems. 2. Just like for airplanes and ships, there are some rules to what you can transmit, as your transmissions can be heard (and cause troubles) for tens, hundreds and even thousands of kilometers away. 3. You have countless frequency allocations available, all over the spectrum, despite the scarcity. 4. Unlike everyone else, holding that license permits you to build your own equipment and transmit with kilowatts with no certification needed. It's extremely easy to cause massive issues with this, such as interrupting cellular communication/gps/wifi an a large area, blowing up your neighbors stereos, and fun things like that. There's a reason that everything else needs to be tested, certified, and require dedicated band allocations - we avoid it by showing that we have the sufficient skills to practice our hobby and not cause trouble. Unlike everyone else, we can do pretty much whatever we want as long as we keep it around a kilowatt and talk nice. I consider that to be extremely relaxed rules.
- mikece 6y agoThis is an awesome idea. I’ve questioned why the Amateur TV “channels” in the 430MHz range can’t be re-purposed for digital TV or just 6MHz wide pure data channels (over which digital TV could be sent). Much of the resistance is from old HAMs who don’t want anything to change. Hopefully TAPR can get behind something like this as well as lobbying for updates to encryption where TLS over IP over amateur radio is happening.
- drmpeg 6y ago70 cm is a bit of a problem. 97.307(f)(6) limits data transmissions to 56 kbaud and 100 kHz bandwidth. However, digital TV is allowed. Some folks have circumvented the rule by sending a low bitrate video stream as a small part of their overall data. https://www.law.cornell.edu/cfr/text/47/97.307 https://www.law.cornell.edu/cfr/text/47/97.307
- aidenn0 6y agoWhat sort of effective bit-rate can you get at 56kbaud and 100kHz bandwidth with the allowed powers? If you can net 4 symbols after any error correction, that would yield the 100kbit TFA wants
- drmpeg 6y agoDVB-S2 With 8PSK and 2/3 code rate would give 111 kbps at 56 kbaud. With 0.2 rolloff, the signal would be 67.2 kHz wide. The article is using FSK with a bandwidth of at least 300 kHz, so it's not legal in the US (for data only).
- jlgaddis 6y agoSome of us were doing ATV on the 70cm band 25 years ago.
- dbcurtis 6y agoDATV is a thing on 430. The problem is equipment. MDARC runs DVB-S, I believe. For DVB-S, you can re-purpose satellite equipment. KH6ATV is a proponent of DVB-T (which in theory should be better than DVB-S for terrestrial paths). There is one company in Taiwan that makes DVB-T transmitters and receivers that are usable in the ham bands (available in their E-Bay store), and people have done DVB-T in the ham bands with LimeSDR. BATC has done a lot of work with DVB also. Sorry to be vague, I haven't been keeping up on my reading... about 1.5 years ago I was going to try setting up for DVB-T on 430MHz and 1.2GHz, but life got in the way. In theory, you should be able to run 780p in a 6 MHz wide channel in the 430Hz band, or even squeeze 480i down to fit a 2MHz wide channel. (The max bandwidth allowed for amateur video in the USA on 430 is 6MHz, DVB-T does have 8MHz wide formats used in some countries for broadcast.) Contact KH6ATV if you are interested in doing some experiments. I recommend reading his notes first: https://kh6htv.com/application-notes/ https://kh6htv.com/application-notes/ For those that haven't stopped reading already: DVB-C -- optimized for cable. DVB-S -- optimized for satellite path loss and fading, but not for multi-path. DVB-T -- optimized for terrestrial paths which may suffer from significant multi-path propagation. ATSC -- The US standard, which unfortunately was standardized earlier than the rest and is expensive to generate and has outrageously poor weak-signal performance, both of which make it a ridiculously bad choice for amateur radio.
- non-entity 6y agoSo this might he a little off topic, but I picked up an SDR with some cool projects in mind. And when I opened SDR programs I quickly realized I had no idea what I was doing. Much of the terminology seemed foreign, etc. What kind of background knowledge do I need to get up to speed with this stuff? Would a few signals/ DSP course suffice to start out?
- unoti 6y agoI recommend getting all 3 ham radio licenses: technician, General, and extra class. In the process you’ll learn all kinds of things and have a lot of the concepts down. You’ll learn about many different aspects of electronics, antenna design, RF propagation, and fun ways to use radios along the way. And you’ll be ready to put it to use right away with your first license. So if you research learning materials for those licenses you’ll be off to an awesome start. There’s excellent free and paid books available.
- mmaunder 6y agoI have all three (WT1J) and I found them to be thin on digital signaling, SDRs, and understanding real world signals. I’d suggest getting a cheap SDR and starting here: https://greatscottgadgets.com/sdr/ https://greatscottgadgets.com/sdr/ You’ll learn how to build a basic fm radio using gnuradio along with other cool stuff, like a simple explanation of decibels among other things.
- ghostpepper 6y agoIt depends on what your background is already and what you want to do. I took some signals courses in school and we used the Oppenheimer textbook, but that's a lot of math if all you want to do is receive some ADSB signals. Lots more recommendations here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14584377 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14584377
- mhh__ 6y agoIf you know a bit of mathematics the book "SDR for Engineers" is exactly what you're looking for - it covers the right DSP material that you'll need. For starters, it actually covers the sampling techniques SDR actually uses and (it's published by Analog Devices) covers some of the fancy RF-to-Digital System on Chips available today. Some DSP books (Like Proakis's) are incredibly long-winded and totally detached from the real world (and I say that as a theoretical physics student) and don't cover the sampling topologies that many SDR's use. Interestingly, I have some very old communication theory books from the 50s and 60s - they are still useful for Software Defined radio stuff today. The only thing they didn't foresee is the throughput of a modern digital filter being as high as it is.
- monkeycantype 6y agoOh this is awesome. In ancient times I set up email over uhf in a remote village in bougainville (the only link I can find is a paywalled pdf https://shop.ata.org.au/shop/renew-issue-84 https://shop.ata.org.au/shop/renew-issue-84) We had to pretend to be a ship the mv sunrise to access a system that ran out of san diego that was only licensed to provide service to ships in international waters. There was an internet provider in the solomon islands that did something similar, but for political reasons they were not allowed to help.
- thatlongthrow1 6y agoThere is a one page preview here: https://www.jstor.org/stable/renetechsustfutu.84.16?seq=1 https://www.jstor.org/stable/renetechsustfutu.84.16?seq=1 Fascinating stuff.
- monkeycantype 6y agoThanks for finding that, I haven't seen that photo for a long time, I remember the feeling of exhausted relief that it was finally working.
- holidayacct 6y agoIgnore open IP over VHF/UHF if anyone wants a challenge I found out recently that... People have been able to eavesdrop on homes by targeting pretty much anything containing metal coils (including appliances) with advanced HAM radio equipment since the early 1970s.