2 ms·
Your comment reminds me of the recent Dilbert strips where everyone is acting like the main character doesn't care about safety because he didn't state the impl
by throwaway0a5e 6y ago
Your comment reminds me of the recent Dilbert strips where everyone is acting like the main character doesn't care about safety because he didn't state the implicit assumption that safety matters and someone looking for cheap virtue points noticed and said "you didn't mention safety, why don't you care about safety" even though he obviously cares as much as anyone else.
Nobody in this entire comment section that I have seen so far is advocating for harming more people more frequently in the name of progress. Just because people are asking "are there any other ways of testing drugs" and the current testing system cares about safety does not mean that these people want to abandon safety in order to more cheaply test drugs. Maybe we can find some other way to test drugs that is cheaper per useful drug than the current system and equivalent or better in terms of safety to humans.
- ethbro 6y agoI didn't say that anyone wanted to abandon safety. I said that they wanted to deprioritize safety, presumably to increase successful drug development. > Maybe we can find some other way to test drugs that is cheaper per useful drug than the current system and equivalent or better in terms of safety to humans. Maybe. But we should start at a place of shared understanding. HN is notorious for "if they just"isms with regards to other fields. Consequently, I think it's fair to point out that the thing that most people are lamenting (strict adherence to standards, extremely conservative trial progression) are attached to a value (avoiding harm to humans). If people are advocating to upend the apple cart, then they don't just get to say "We want to continue to prioritize safety and also not do some things that increase safety." Personally? I'd be fine with an informed consent alternative that helped speed through population-targeted or riskier drugs. Better to have options. But implementing that system would have costs.