2 ms·
qualified immunity should not happen regardless - the modern incarnation is far removed from the original law, which was intended to mean judges couldn't be sue
by olliej 6y ago
qualified immunity should not happen regardless - the modern incarnation is far removed from the original law, which was intended to mean judges couldn't be sued if their rulings were later found to be incorrect (e.g. the Supreme Court disagreed with them).
As far as I can make out the modern version is police officers say that they believe they were acting appropriately, and that is sufficient to remove liability.
- mcv 6y agoQualified immunity is fine for things done in good faith, to the best of your ability, etc. It's unavoidable that you get things wrong, and people do need some leeway in their execution of their job. But people shouldn't have immunity when they act in bad faith, or when they should have known that an action is illegal or counter to the purpose of their job. Good/bad faith are hard to test objectively of course, but in some cases they are obvious, like when you're strangling or beating an unarmed person to death. But police officers should also know they're not supposed to shoot or taser someone who is not a direct threat, or pepperspray peaceful protesters in their face. Every officer should know that's not acceptable, and officers should therefore not be immune to prosecution if they do it anyway. But that also means having clear standards about police work, and officers being trained in those standards.