3 ms·
The article is a great example of gross innumeracy. The author confuses linear distributions with exponential ones, comparing them as stacked bar graphs without
by ctdonath 16y ago
The article is a great example of gross innumeracy. The author confuses linear distributions with exponential ones, comparing them as stacked bar graphs without suitable differentiation of axis.
Doesn't take much of a consistent percentage increase in income from one person to the next, spread across a large population, to result in that top 20% indeed dominating most wealth.
ETA (after playing with Excel for a few minutes): If each person in the USA makes just 0.000003% more than the next, the resulting "20%s" wealth distribution graph looks exactly like the "Actual" part of the Percent Wealth Owned graph.
I'd say a wealth inequality of three millionths of one percent between one person and the next is about as fair a wealth distribution as you could ask for. The author needs to educate himself about statistics before self-righteously educating others about the virtues of communism.
ETA2: reduce the differential to 0.000002% and the graph approximates the "Estimated" part of the graph in question. To achieve the alleged "Ideal" distribution, further reduce the differential to 0.000001%. Innumeracy indeed.
- ckuehne 16y ago"The author confuses linear distributions with exponential ones, comparing them as stacked bar graphs without suitable differentiation of axis." Could you elaborate? By the way, the graph is taken from the original paper (click the details link below the graph).
- ctdonath 16y agoThe graph (and the article's conclusion) would be more sensible if the bottom bar were on a linear axis while the top was on a suitably scaled logarithmic axis. The author does not comprehend the consequential differences between percentages and absolute values.
- ctdonath 16y agoAddressing my own innumeracy, reworking the numbers I find that all three bars are indeed exponential, expressing percentage increases of different orders of magnitude (the top is increasing wealth accumulation at 10x the percentage rate of the bottom). Mea culpa aside, the author is using a linear X axis instead of a far more suitable logarithmic scale, thus skewing the reader's perception of the graph (as exemplified by the fact that all the HN comments failed to notice this).
- rwl 16y ago> ETA (after playing with Excel for a few minutes): If each person in the USA makes just 0.000003% more than the next, the resulting "20%s" wealth distribution graph looks exactly like the "Actual" part of the Percent Wealth Owned graph. Not sure what you're saying here. Do you mean that, in an imaginary country where everyone but the top earner makes exactly 0.000003% less than the person above him, income will be distributed in that way? I see how this would tell against the author's particular choice of representation, but I'm not sure that it tells us much about how income is actually distributed in the U.S., much less how it should be distributed. Just because the same distribution can be realized in a country where income seems to slide much more "fairly" (i.e., gradually) from the richest to the poorest doesn't mean that distribution can't be realized in a much less fair way here. (Moreover, I suspect that if you put it in absolute dollars, rather than percentage points, the incomes in your imaginary country would strike most people as decidedly less fair.)
- ctdonath 16y agoYes, I do mean that. I ran the numbers & graphs in a few minutes on Excel and came up with results that matched the article's graphs (right down to the automatic color choices - heh). I also mean that the real-world actual, estimated, and (alleged) ideal distributions are a near-perfect match for the mathematical theory. Ergo, it gives lie the selfish "should" part: we are living the reality of statistics, to wit a near-zero differential of income between one person and the next necessitates a huge fluctuation between the bottom & top wealth holdings. The "innumeracy" comment comes from the fact that those decrying "unfair!" do not realize that a miniscule (two millionths of one percent is nigh unto zero) linear adjustment of percentages translates to exponential variations when applied across hundreds of millions of people. They're performing an equal linear division of the population (20% increments) and somehow expecting the wealth numbers to come out with a similar "fair" equal division of holdings; realizing that the rich should indeed have more than the poor (hence the semantic difference in terms), they resolve this cognitive dissonance by "allowing" the rich to hold some 3x the wealth of the poor - oblivious to the statistical fact that variations in wealth are a matter of exponential-accumulation percentages, not linear accumulations multipliers. I don't see how income can slide much more "fairly" (i.e., gradually) from the richest to the poorest than a differential of a vanishingly small three millionths of one percent. To say that somehow it "should" (obvious moral arguments of "it's not yours to distribute" aside) be _one_ millionth of one percent instead is to wage class warfare, a very real and bloody process as history shows, because the dividing lines for the 20% groupings mean the guy at the bottom of the highest bracket is making $0.10 more than the guy at the top of the second-highest bracket, and the guy at the bottom of the second-lowest bracket is making $0.0003 more than the top person in the lowest bracket. Comparing between adjacent individuals, and even across entire brackets, with real numbers should strike most as decidedly fair. Is the 80% division hundreds of times wealthier than the 20% division? and the very top unto billions more than the very bottom? sure - and that's reality, folks: the wealth distribution curve is a natural consequence of miniscule percentages aggregated over hundreds of millions of people, and no amount of "should" and social-reengineering (to wit: "comply or die") can render viable change to a natural, social, statistical phenomenon. But since many people cannot cope with exponential consequences of uniform miniscule percentages applied across a population of hundreds of millions, we will always be faced with those who cry "unfair!" and insist on forcing their notion of "fair" upon the population. The 20th Century suffered some 100,000,000 dead as a consequence, and the authors of TFA (and, it seems, you (rwl)) want to repeat that toll for want of the 0.000003% more their neighbor makes, when 0.000001% would somehow be OK.