4 ms·
It's weird that we've set up a stock market for machines rather than humans, where ever-faster bots interpose themselves between slightly slower bots, all the w
by musicale 6y ago
It's weird that we've set up a stock market for machines rather than humans, where ever-faster bots interpose themselves between slightly slower bots, all the way up to the original buyer and seller, who are probably bots as well.
- missedthecue 6y agoThe machines help humans. The bid/ask spread on a $100 share in 1970 as $5. Now it's $0.003 cents and it will continue to narrow, saving you and I money.
- adrianN 6y agoHow big would it be if we limited machine trading such that milliseconds don't matter? Say run everything with 1Hz frequency instead?
- logicchains 6y agoIt would be much wider, because the dumber your pricing, the less certain you can be about how the price may move, so you have to be more cautious and quote wider.
- arnoooooo 6y agoThis sounds like circular logic to me. It really saves money to people who want to buy and sell often, which has no social value. I think having a penalty for buying and selling too often is a feature, not a bug : we want investors that think long term.
- logicchains 6y ago>which has no social value Who made you the global arbiter of social value? Clearly the people participating in the transaction see some value in it.
- icelancer 6y ago>> I think having a penalty for buying and selling too often is a feature, not a bug : we want investors that think long term. This already exists. It's the long-term capital gains tax reduction compared to short-term cap gains tax, and very high corporate taxes (relative to the rest of the world).
- ChrisLomont 6y agoIt benefits the majority of adults in the US and the vast majority of retirees who have exposure to stock vis retirement accounts. It has benefits to every pension fund, including teachers and public sector unions. I could continue, but don’t poo poo things of which you don’t understand the components or utility.
- rvense 6y agoThis all sounds so perverse to me. There are so many obviously brilliant people working on these things. Why aren't they doing something productive with their time? Fighting climate change, educating uneducated, feeding the unfed. All the energy and rare and bloody minerals that are being put into these radios, all the drinking water that will be forever tainted after having been used to produce the semiconductors needed for all this... was it really the best place to use it? To make the roulette wheel run a little faster? I don't understand it.
- Erlich_Bachman 6y agoYou won't like it, but the there is a sensible answer for this. Despite you not liking the stock (and other financial) markets, they do perform a useful and needed task (price discovery, reallocation of resources, reallocation and focusing of human brainpower, reallocation of capital, allowing for investment (allocation of collected capital and resources in the present for future projects, so that they can be achieved faster, and thus provide overall better output of the system)), and even speculation is also an important part of that task. It is not needless greed (as popularized by some movies and pop culture), it is an engine of the capitalist civilisation, which has so far produced far more results (even in less obvious terms like allowing for least poverty in the world than any other time in history, because the benefits of a well-functiouning society do evidently trickle down to the the little guy, even if the most of it is collected at the top) than any other. There is indeed some meaningless speculation in it, just like how there is corruption in all of human systems, and just how in every ecosystem there are a number of parasites, but they are there because the underlying system (capitalism) is meaningful and produces value for society. > feeding the unfed They do feed the unfed. The capitalist system has been able to reduce world poverty by far far more than any other system in history. Look at the stats. And well-functioning capital, labor, idea and resource circulation markets are at the very heart of that system.
- rvense 6y ago> And well-functioning capital, labor, idea and resource circulation markets are at the very heart of that system. Sure. But I'd question whether high-frequency trading is a necessary component of that, as opposed to regular-frequency trading. Same as I'd question whether things like collateralized debt obligations and interest-free loans were good for the housing market. "Capitalist civilization" has changed in a number of ways since Reagan and Thatcher, just in its legal framework, compared to the thirty years before and I don't think it's obvious at all that we are better off in the developed world than we were in the fifties and sixties when things were more regulated. When I look at stats for things like wage disparities, and the amount of money poured into marketing (demand generation), and the amount of frivolous products that the capitalist economy produces because it must by its nature constantly expand production, I quite honestly don't see efficiency and I certainly don't see reason.
- logicchains 6y agoThe bots don't take profit, the humans do. They just use bots because bots can help them better achive what they need, much like we may prefer to use a browser to fetch information from the internet rather than physically going down to a library.