4 ms·
I don't get the hate for email. Like at all. I'd rather have people send me one well phrased coherent email than: - 3-5 fragmented chat messages where I have t
by atoav 6y ago
I don't get the hate for email. Like at all. I'd rather have people send me one well phrased coherent email than:
- 3-5 fragmented chat messages where I have to search for meaning
- one infinitly long speech message where someone else basically forces you to witness their attempts of focusing their thoughts
- a @-mention in a group timeline where you have to Ctrl+f a smalltalk-filled timeline to figure out what they actually want from you
What I like about email (and letters) is that people have to formulate coherent thoughts if they want something from you. They have to write a subject and that alone pauses them to think about what they want.
Every form of communication that moves the burden of decyphering meaning to the receiver should be avoided IMO.
- adonese 6y agoI was reluctant to use whatsapp and other chatting apps up until two years ago. voice notes have been really annoying for me, and for so long i have been literally ignoring them! Now with this corona i started to use chatting apps more regularly and at times i get really lazy to write so i will just voice note. i still struggle with them though
- atoav 6y agoAs someone who grew up with things like ICQ, MSN or Skype Chat I think chats jave their place. For chitchat or conversation with friends it is very nice. For work not so much. The only time a group chat worked was on a low budget film set where I worked as a camera operator, because people only wrote something there when they needed sth.
- kilroy123 6y agoI _love_ voice messages on WhatsApp. I use them all the time. It's way better than writing out a novel to someone. Just send a quick two minute audio. Done.
- Sodman 6y agoThe problem is that it now takes the recipient 2 minutes to listen to your message, and can't search for it when they need to reference it again in the future. If you literally just typed out the same words you spoke, the recipient can 1) interpret your message faster and 2) search for it and find it in the future. Removing those two features for marginally faster message composing just seems selfish and a waste of the recipient's time.
- atoav 6y agoFast for you, slow for everybody else. You are putting the burden of making sense of what you say onto the other side. If your speech messages are concise and follow a bottom line first approach, this could be okay. After a certain length and complexity the other side will have to take notes. If you are not a clear speaker they will have to relisten and take notes. Additionally speech is usearchable which could be very bad for the other side as well — imagine someone who has to listen through 10 speech messages to figure out what you said. My girlfriend once had a manager who loved speech messages as well (I heard some of them). These messages were 15 minutes long, full of chitchat about her live and the workplace and somewhere around minute 9 the three sentences that should have been communicated to my girlfriend appeared. My girlfriend told me that she wasn't the only person who would just completely ignore these messages with the sentence if it would be important, she would send us an email. So if one is in a position where one can offload the burden of decyphering and searching for meaning in the words to others, speech messages are certainly comfortable for the sender. Sometimes they are also totally fine (e.g. to loved ones, friends, people where you know they hate reading). But in most cases you are creating work for others — work multiplied by the number of receivers and number of times they have to listen through your stuff. Imagine e.g. if you work in IT support and all you get is speech messages. That would be hell.
- hombre_fatal 6y agoSomething I don't like about email is that often has this "always online" assumption about it. At some times in my 20s I was taken advantage by this. Get a 9am email on a Saturday to fix something even though I was never on call, it would encroach like that. There definitely was a turning point of sorts in my career when things like Slack became common place. I just cmd-q the app when work is over. The green light is off next to my name. The default assumption of boundaries seems slightly healthier. Send a PM to my username without the green light next to it at 9am on Saturday and you aren't asking me how I didn't see it Monday morning. As for longer form work discussion, I prefer Github issues or an internal forum. I don't like the privacy of email with work discussion. That's for friends and family. I want all work matters to have an audience in the open. As for friends and family, there's a place for both email and chat.
- andrewflnr 6y agoThis is quite interesting. Email is much more strongly async for me than chat. I only check work email a couple times a day, and ignore it over the weekend. But people's main complaint about slack is that it is always online. FWIW, I only use Slack per se for fun social groups.
- atoav 6y agoWeird for me it is the other way around. Answering a email after one to two days is totally acceptable, in a chat not so much.
- lazyjones 6y agoSame. After 30 years of continuous e-mail use, it's finally working. Spam is down to 0-1 message per day (pobox.com and fastmail spam filters). Most businesses now respond to e-mails. Large e-mails (large attachments) finally work. No more character set problems. No more broken / unsafe e-mail clients (most people use webmail). No real delays, no full mailboxes, no bounces for stupid reasons anymore. It's not time to abandon e-mail, it's finally fixed and here to stay.