4 ms·
> it seriously shows you the image at the new point, but time-shifts it backwards so that it seems like you were seeing it the whole time your eyes were moving.
by crazygringo 6y ago
> it seriously shows you the image at the new point, but time-shifts it backwards so that it seems like you were seeing it the whole time your eyes were moving... you can see this effect happen if you watch an analog clock with a second hand. Look away (with just your eyes, not your head), then look back to the second hand. It'll seem like it takes longer than a second to move, then resumes moving as normal.
Is there a citation for this? I can't find any paper on it, the Wikipedia articles on "sacaddic masking" and "transsaccadic memory" don't mention the phenomenon at all, and I've been trying it with my own clock (where the second hand moves in second increments, not continuously) and it simply doesn't happen for me at all.
I can't figure out why your brain would "rewrite past memory" instead of simply persisting the old image either.
If anyone could point me to an actual name for this phenomenon, or a paper proving it, I'd super appreciate it, because it seems so implausible that I'd love to understand it more.
EDIT: found the actual term for it -- "chronostasis" -- and the memory phenomenon is "neural antedating" or "neural backdating". [1] And while it appears to be a reported phenomenon, it appears to be understandably difficult to verify experimentally, since it is an inherently subjective phenomenon and experiments involve potential sources of bias that could alternately explain it.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chronostasis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chronostasis
- jstanley 6y ago> it simply doesn't happen for me at all. FWIW, I have noticed the effect many times, in particular with the second hand of analogue clocks.
- karmakaze 6y agoYes, but never while you're listening--it's not a hack by your vision system, it's your perception system. You're basically hallucinating all the time, mostly to synthesize what's 'out there'.
- kqr 6y agoEven before I knew this was a thing, I know I've looked at my watch and for a second being confused about why it seemed broken when it was working just minutes ago, simply because the second hand didn't appear to move in time.
- proactivesvcs 6y agoI had assumed that this was part of my watches' mechanisms that self-calibrated but it never occurred to me that I just happened to notice this self-calibration so often! It's interesting that I casually came up with a complex explanation and didn't even try to critically examine whether it was plausible or not.
- mcguire 6y ago"I can't figure out why your brain would "rewrite past memory" instead of simply persisting the old image either." There isn't an image to persist. The "image" you see is an active construction of your brain working on incomplete and inaccurate sensory data. As a hypothesis, your visual system doesn't have the memory to "persist" the sensory data, the data during the saccade is not meaningful, and your brain, while constructing your own personal chronological sequence after the fact simply uses what it has on hand.
- boomboomsubban 6y ago>And while it appears to be a reported phenomenon, I believe you're misreading that Wikipedia section. The phenomena exists, and the mentioned aspects all play a role in causing it. It is difficult to explain which part of the process causes the time distortion, and the measurements of how distorted things can be are influenced by the testing.