3 ms·
I assume people think the answer to private corporations “framing the debate” is for government to pass laws. The same government that is trying to enforce bac
by scarface74 6y ago
I assume people think the answer to private corporations “framing the debate” is for government to pass laws. The same government that is trying to enforce backdoors to encryption and is already using facial recognition to harass people who “fit the description”.
- chiefalchemist 6y agoThat gov is also buying the data. Snowden swept under the rug. The so-called Patriot Act up for renewal. The gov is going to take the position that best preserves its own interests. This is the pattern some of us keep seeing; the rest simply can't be bothered.
- zeroonetwothree 6y agoExactly. The worst privacy transgressions historically have always come from governments. Corporations aren’t the ones we should be afraid of. You want the people that brought you the Patriot Act in charge of privacy?
- mindslight 6y agoYour argument carries an assumption that all possible government action is hopelessly broken. I'm generally libertarian myself, but this viewpoint is ultimately a coping mechanism for a societal death spiral. Why bother working for results, when the results are always bad? But even accepting the assumption that the government has become a malevolent attacker, then there is still an argument for goading it into hampering data collection - every bit of data collected by private companies is also available to the government to abuse and oppress us! Government power and corporate power are not in opposition, but rather two sides of the same coin of disempowering individuals.
- scarface74 6y agoIt’s not just broken - it’s discriminatory.
- clairity 6y agoto repeat my mantra, it's not either-or, it's all of the above. corporations, governments, and institutions of all kinds are especially designed to consolidate power. but society is better when power is dispersed widely, so that it's difficult (ideally impossible) to infringe individual liberties and civil rights without recourse. we the polity need to continually pit institutions against each other to maintain our freedoms. there's no "done, now let's move on" in that.
- scarface74 6y agoThe difference is that any power you give the government is automatically amplified. The government has the power of the state, to wield power. Private corporations have only one goal - to make money. Government is controlled by ideologues. Also because of the nature of both the Senate with two senators per state and the electoral college, the less populous states have far more voting power than their population demands. Their belief system and worldview is completely different than mine - yes I live in one of those states. It’s not just about the difference on policy issues. It’s about fundamental human rights issues like police power and treatment of minorities, and how many of them believe fundamentally that none straight/non Christian people are an abomination and laws should be passed that discriminate against them.
- clairity 6y ago> "The difference is that any power you give the government is automatically amplified." that's not immediately obvious. power is divided in government, and ultimately rests collectively in the people. you'd expect the power expressed is exactly the accumulation of the tiny amounts each of us delegate to government. it's not perfect, but all the little divisions and mechanisms of check and balance are there specifically to prevent undue amplification. certainly the government has coercive power and we must be vigilant, but make no mistake, corporations are power structures that collaborate with and coerce the government into offense against the less powerful (minorities, women, etc.). who but the moneyed owners do you think try to distort and amplify their voice through government? it's not the average person that citizen's united benefits. the indirection of the corporate form is designed specifically to make it difficult to parse out their influence (and mistakenly place trust in them). they're designed specifically to insulate owners, to the benefit of no one else (governments be damned where they can get away with it). that there are assholes everywhere, including every corporation, who would discriminate against trivial shit is exactly why you want dispersed power across any structure or institution.