3 ms·
Signatures are not really anti-forgery proof as most people expect... Instead they are protected by law. If you sign something claiming to be someone else, y
by londons_explore 6y ago
Signatures are not really anti-forgery proof as most people expect...
Instead they are protected by law. If you sign something claiming to be someone else, you have broken the law.
That's why credit cards required a signature for a long time, yet nobody ever checked the signatures on the receipt vs the card. It isn't hard to fake someone else's signature, but doing so is a crime. Using someone else's card without a signature would just be a breach of the T&C's, but not a crime.
- blattimwind 6y ago> Using someone else's card without a signature would just be a breach of the T&C's, but not a crime. Even without forging a signature, it would still constitute theft or fraud, no?
- londons_explore 6y agoWith the other persons permission, I wouldn't think it would be theft or fraud.
- blattimwind 6y agoOkay, but in that case you're not breaking the law if you sign in their name -- at least in some countries. So it'd be probably back to "just a ToS violation".
- voxic11 6y agoIf you had their permission then no it wouldn't be a crime.
- kevincox 6y agoBut if someone had signed the card and you signed your own name on the receipt then you didn't commit fraud right? It is this system assuming that the receipt signature was checked against the card?
- baddox 6y agoYou’d think the law could just say that you can’t pretend (via any mechanism, a signature or otherwise) to be someone else in order to receive some material gain.
- tialaramex 6y agoIn the UK at least that is indeed a crime and I assume it's in one of the model criminal codes in the US. "Theft by deception" - basically you need to show intent to deceive and thereby permanently deprive someone of something of value. So "Lied about going to the same high school, she gave me her number" doesn't cut it, but "Showed my brother's ID to the dealer, drove away with a car" is definitely a crime.
- thaumasiotes 6y agoIt does already say that; that would come under the heading of "fraud".
- pessimizer 6y agoYou can do that passively by just not correcting people who assume you're authorized. If you require a clear cut act of deception in order to complete a fraud, such as signing someone else's name, it becomes very easy to prosecute.