4 ms·
I think the article is right. Vaclav Smil has pointed out that today the share of fossil fuels, at about 90% of global energy consumed[1] is actually higher tha
by Barrin92 6y ago
I think the article is right. Vaclav Smil has pointed out that today the share of fossil fuels, at about 90% of global energy consumed[1] is actually higher than in 2000, and falling at a snails pace.
There is a worrying trend emerging, fuelled by the tech industry of performative environmentalism that seeks to promise absolution like the church did by buying Tesla's and biodegradable cups while the real-world impact is marginal while leaving the fundamental flaws of the system untouched. We won't consume ourselves out of the doghouse.
Russ Ackoff in a great talk about systems thinking[2] once pointed out a few salient things
1. Counter to intuition one does not improve a system by merely removing deficiencies. Doing away with what you don't want doesn't get you what you want.
2. Incrementalism doesn't solve fundamentally new problems, rearranging deck chairs on the titanic is pointless, and people confuse efficiency with effectiveness. Doing the wrong thing right is worse than doing the right thing wrong.
3. One must recognise that like an architect, a designer does not design rooms independently of the house. One starts with the house, and only changes parts as to improve the overall functioning of the system, never the parts alone.
This is what needs to be applied to modern environmentalism. Woke green consumerism and tech worship is useless. The entire global system needs to be redesigned, instead of trying to fix individual parts. We need to think in holistic terms rather than trying to remove individual problems.
[1]https://www.sciencemag.org/news/2018/03/meet-vaclav-smil-man-who-has-quietly-shaped-how-world-thinks-about-energy https://www.sciencemag.org/news/2018/03/meet-vaclav-smil-man...
[2]https://youtu.be/OqEeIG8aPPk https://youtu.be/OqEeIG8aPPk
- CuriousSkeptic 6y agoIs was just wondering the other day: do we have something like the IPCC currently charged with doing exactly that?
- fulafel 6y agoBuying a Tesla is certainly not marginal - it's lifetime carbon footprint incl manufacturing is still huge, it's wastefully big, and the owners previous car will in 90% of cases just continue life with the next owner, ending up with one more car in the world. The alternative co2 reducing uses of 1 Tesla worth of money would be very significant in the $2 earnings/day part of the world, so the opportunity cost is enormous.
- chiph 6y agoI grew up in the 1970's when environmentalism was just getting started (I can recall the 4th or 5th Earth Day[0] being celebrated). Back then the concern was population growth[1] and the consumption of resources. Fossil fuels were a major concern then as well, mostly because of automobile exhaust. During the current pandemic, people have posted before/after photos of their cities. But places like Los Angeles had smog so thick that the skyline was hidden[2]. Since then, better engine controls and catalytic converters have reduced emissions to amazingly low levels. If you're behind an older car that has a carburetor some time, you'll definitely notice the smell of raw gasoline. Imagine millions of cars emitting that! There's no question that the more people, the more resources get consumed. However what is an important question is: Is world population growth exceeding our ability to engineer lower per-person resource usage? Right now, that curve has positive slope, and we need to get it to a slight negative slope, without losing the advantages of a technological civilization. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Earth_Day https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Earth_Day [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Population_growth https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Population_growth [2] https://timeline.com/la-smog-pollution-4ca4bc0cc95d https://timeline.com/la-smog-pollution-4ca4bc0cc95d
- TomSwirly 6y ago> However what is an important question is: Is world population growth exceeding our ability to engineer lower per-person resource usage? That's a trick question. The answer is that human population increases by about 1.1% a year; and independently, individual human consumption increases exponentially as well. The exact rate depends on the specific resource or commodity being consumed of course. Now, you're right that technology allows individual things to be manufactured more effectively, with less waste. What you miss is that this causes people to buy a lot more things, so it more than cancels out. I spent some time looking at this, and I found a few resources that had decreased consumption. Freon is the most obvious one, but it's important to notice that it was replaced by another safer but rather similar gas - raw material consumption did not decrease. Even things like biofuels - wood, dung, or other biological products that are burned for heat. They used to be nearly all the world's energy production - now they're a tiny part but on their own, their growth is now and has always been exponential. It's just that fossil fuels grew much faster - we never cut down on anything. We need to use less of absolutely everything. For us not to such the world dry, we individually and as a species need to decrease our consumption by as much an order of magnitude. If we are not to decimate our biosphere, we need both far more efficient manufacturing, but also a lot less manufacturing.