3 ms·
> On Earth, Life has embarrassed us by being found in the most inhospitable, acidic, saltiest, hottest places. And then embarrassed us again, by turning up in t
by tsimionescu 6y ago
> On Earth, Life has embarrassed us by being found in the most inhospitable, acidic, saltiest, hottest places. And then embarrassed us again, by turning up in the cold black energy-poor ocean depths, sipping sulfur from vents.
And yet, all life on Earth has the same basic structure. The most likely reason for this is that life only originated once, and in one "place". This observation significantly reduces the probability we should ascribe for life to appear, and/or the specificity of the conditions required. For example, we know for sure that a planet like the Earth today is completely inhospitable to the emergence of life (there has not been an abiogenesis event for billions of years).
The other option is that life has emerged in many places/times on Earth, but with the exact same structure. While unlikely, this would suggest that life must have a very specific structure, that at least on Earth-like planets we should also expect RNA and DNA based life at least. This would also suggest that the likelihood of other kinds of life existing is smaller than initially could have been conceived. And even with this assumption, it would still not be clear that life is appearing on Earth today anymore, as the life forms we've looked at seem to have a phylogenetic link with other life (though our methods may be weak if the possibility of abiogenesis were correct). And even if abiogenesis was still occurring on Earth, it would have to be in some remote place in extreme conditions, as we have tried in all regular places with no success.
Overall, my belief is that the emergence of life is likely a vastly improbable event, and that we shouldn't expect to "see" a living (or formerly living) being that is not related to life on Earth in the lifetime of the Earth.
> And Intelligence is surely bigger than Life.
This seems a mystical belief, given all we know of the world.
- baq 6y ago> > And Intelligence is surely bigger than Life. > This seems a mystical belief, given all we know of the world. if you assume that intelligence comes from the brain and if you assume that the brain is just a very highly optimized computer, there's no need for an intelligent entity to be alive. it just needs an adequate computer to exist.
- TheOtherHobbes 6y agoThat's a lot of interesting assumptions.
- tsimionescu 6y agoSure, but the computer must have been built by some form of life ultimately (possibly through a long line of other computers). If your point was only that artificial life created by a form of life could vastly outlast that form of life, then I agree that that is a very good point.