10 ms·
> Barring some global unavoidable catastrophe, there is no reason to think we are going anywhere very soon. If only we didn't live during a huge ecological dis
by tsimionescu 6y ago
> Barring some global unavoidable catastrophe, there is no reason to think we are going anywhere very soon.
If only we didn't live during a huge ecological disaster that is threatening to destroy the livelihoods of hundreds of millions of people directly, with unforeseeable consequences for the rest of the world; which the major powers of the world are unwilling to act in any significant way to curtail; and which seems to require a re-structuring of the entire world's economy to actually solve...
Looking at the world right now, we know one thing for sure: none of the trends we see today will be relevant in 100 years. One way or another, the world will go through massive changes whose scope can't be predicted.
One possibility is global warming will continue unabated until we have hundreds of millions of people migrating from rapidly submerging areas (Bangladesh being one of the largest concentrations of population in the world living a few meters above sea levels), most likely followed by some kind of global war to prevent or redirect the massive migrations.
Another is that the global economy will be completely re-created to stop the production of greenhouse gases dead in its tracks, almost certainly in a non-capitalist system, since capitalism simply can't deal with externalities. The required political and economic shifts are hard to imagine, and the resulting world is equally hard to predict.
And of course, we are still always a few madmen away from nuclear war, with many of the world's most tense regions having nuclear weapons aimed at their enemies. Could global warming start a resource war between India and Pakistan that would lead to them using their arsenals? Could Israel decide to use its illegal nuclear weapons to attack Iran in a "defensive first strike"? Could the US decide that its interests are important enough that, as its soft power wanes, it could launch a bomb at some country to remind everyone of its hard power? Could the Europeans spark a new war, either among themselves or against some common threat, and feel the need to use their nuclear arsenal? Could the Chinese? As long as nuclear weapons exist, they are an ever growing threat.
Remember that just in the last few years, the long standing US-Russian non-proliferation treaty was unilaterally ended by the US, signalling a vast increase in the risk of nuclear weapons actually seeing use again.
- tuatoru 6y agoWell and eloquently put.
- Kathula 6y agoFirst of all, there's no need for 7 billion people to exist to fulfill being a civilization. Surely our civilization could exist of just 1 million people if it comes to that. Secondly, the climate change "catastrophe" isn't what we need to be worried about. Rather one of those events that has occurred before on earth, wiping out almost all existing life. But considering some non-intelligent life forms, or at least life forms without our superior intelligence, survived those events I'd bet that we would survive them too. Considering we can detect them, and (somewhat) protect against them. Nuclear War is unlikely to happen since any instigator know it would come at tremendous cost. Also, the more countries that have nukes the better, since it levels the playground. Even if nuklear war happens, it wont wipe out all people, all communities.
- cthalupa 6y agoIf in a group of a million people you had enough people interested in and capable of doing the science necessary for making progress interstellar communication or travel, we would have many many many times more people working in those fields today. A civilization with only a million people in it would have priorities vastly different than our own.
- tsimionescu 6y agoThe human species doesn't need to be wiped out for civilization to end,at least at the level of being interested in interstellar communication. It's true tho that civilization may spring up again after some time, so perhaps that should be factored into the equation. And nuclear war had been only narrowly avoided on around 13 documented occasions in the last 70 years [0]. Some of these events were avoided by happenstance, not any kind of systematic protection. This kind of luck will not continue forever. And if it does break out, right now we don't really understand what may happen to the planet if the US or Russia unleash their full nuclear arsenal, rather than just bombing one or two cities. [0] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_nuclear_close_calls https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_nuclear_close_calls
- demosito666 6y ago> right now we don't really understand what may happen to the planet if the US or Russia unleash their full nuclear arsenal Nothing will happen. Planetary nuclear arsenal yield is dwarfed by a single large vulcanic eruption, and those happen regularly. In fact, modern nuclear arsenal is barely enough to destroy military targets and major cities of both parties. Direct casualties will be in millions, but probably in single digits of them. In other words, it will be a major humanitarian catastrophe, but nothing humanity (or even a major world power like US) can't survive. Probably the biggest change would be due to large areas rendered uninhabitable for decades, but then again, plenty will be left and "uninhabitability" is a matter of life quality standards. People live in Hiroshima and Chernobyl just fine.