3 ms·
I really don't understand how it helps against racism to purge language from certain words in contexts where they're not even applied to humans.
by adrianN 6y ago
I really don't understand how it helps against racism to purge language from certain words in contexts where they're not even applied to humans.
- toomuchtodo 6y agoFeels good without effort. Meaningful progress takes enormous amounts of time and tireless efforts, comparatively speaking. A pull request, many even, isn’t going to fix systemic injustices and inequalities at societal levels. Slavery continues to exist today in the 21st century [1]. I’m unsure how some feel this is the case, but the bluntness seems necessary. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Slavery_in_the_21st_century https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Slavery_in_the_21st_century (The International Labour Organization estimates that, by their definitions, over 40 million people are in some form of slavery today.)
- downerending 6y agoPretty much. Tutoring a minority kid would actually make a difference, but oh so much work. Much easier to change my FB background image to something trendy and downvote the "racists" who don't instead.
- toomuchtodo 6y agoNot just tutoring minority kids. Advocating for efforts against police brutality. Advocating for prison reform, drug decriminalization, ending cash bail, free school meals (breakfast and lunch) for all children K-12 as well as improvements to educational infrastructure in disadvantaged communities. Structural changes, pulling strings that control the system. Alas, these are not commits you can make and then move on. These must become your hobbies if you intend to see meaningful change in our lifetimes. Some of these listed above are my hobbies, and I hope they become yours if these causes matter to you.
- downerending 6y agoIMO, only real actions, like tutoring minority kids, matters. You can "advocate" up, down, left, and sideways, and it will make not one whit of difference. Want to change the world? Do the work.
- toomuchtodo 6y agoI have had moderate success speaking with political representatives at local, state, and federal levels on these issues. Beyond that, campaign contributions to those who support these efforts (maxing out FEC contribution limits). Public policy changes are operating at scale (for example, over a million felons who have served their time in Florida have had their right to vote restored, which matters quite a bit). Advocacy is work, and costly.
- BolexNOLA 6y agoSo you’re saying the only way for stuff to get done is for everyone to be “boots on the ground” and to never fund or work for advocacy organizations?
- ryan29 6y agoIt doesn't fix anything directly, but it's an easy, effective way to show support for people who have been disenfranchised. And it's the sum total that counts, so every little thing makes a difference. One project making changes doesn't have much of an impact, but if every project on GitHub did the same that would be a very clear message the tech industry isn't satisfied with the status quo. Sometimes all it takes to stop a bully is for one person to speak up because then others that might have been keeping silent will feel more comfortable speaking up as well.
- justicezyx 6y agoOne can actually support oppressed people around them. Why does someone want to show support to people who do not need that support after all?
- dwd 6y agoVirtue signalling, plain and simple. Makes you look good to your peers without doing anything of substance. I don't get why there isn't a sustained campaign to reach out for commitments from elected representative while they are largely working from home and more immune from the political pressures that keep them in lockstep maintaining the status quo. Now is the time to push for change from those who hold the power of the purse and frame laws.
- apatters 6y agoThis realization is what motivated me to start participating in charity over the past few years. There has never been as much empty virtue signalling by privileged people as there is today. They declare the deck chairs on the Titanic to be offensive, remove a few of them, congratulate themselves and call it a day like their responsibility is absolved. Maybe they go the extra mile and try to get somebody fired for not speaking the same doublespeak as them. But fixating on their theater achieves nothing. It just gives them more of the attention they crave. So I decided instead to donate my time and my money to good causes and actually help make things better, because this is in short supply. The virtue signallers may or may not take note, but it doesn't matter. What matters is that if they're going to absolve themselves of doing the real work, someone else has to step up.
- dwd 6y agoI avoid simply giving money to a lot of large charities. Fancy offices with executive level pay while they largely rely on donations and volunteers to do the real work for free. Kind of a corporation version of virtue signalling. I'd rather donate food to the local animal refuge than give to them.
- toomuchtodo 6y agoSome large charities are very effectively run. Charity water comes to mind. I think it’s important to not throw out the baby with the bathwater, and that donating to large nonprofits can be an effective use of resources if you’ve done your homework.
- BolexNOLA 6y agoWhy is the assumption that if people want to remove symbols/language that it means they aren’t also doing “real” work too? We can walk and chew bubblegum at the same time. We also should be able to acknowledge that terminology/symbols/language reinforce issues. If they weren’t significant, then we wouldn’t have so many people defending them.
- userbinator 6y agoIt's the rise of "radical political correctness". IMHO things like this should be treated like the trolls they are; and not fed, lest important projects get overrun by this BS.
- vore 6y agoBecause ultimately code is read by humans and some of them don't enjoy having to be reminded about slavery when reading code, and we can do without these inconsiderate metaphors. I think at large, while some changes might be more performative than others, removing master/slave terminology seems pretty clear cut.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- ScottFree 6y agoIt doesn't. That's not the point. It never was. "A society of emasculated liars is easy to control. I think if you examine political correctness, it has the same effect and is intended to." -Anthony Daniels
- adrianN 6y agoI don't believe political correctness is a hidden agenda to control the populace. It's much easier to explain by well meaning people trying to help.
- downerending 6y agoSomeone (maybe the Russians?) had a folk saying: May the gods please save us from those who are only trying to help.
- wayneftw 6y agoIt can be both. During Operation Mockingbird [0] the CIA found that they only had to infiltrate a relatively small nimber of the news outlets in order to sway public opinion. They placed stories with both cooperating and unwitting journalists. Useful idiots can be very useful. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Mockingbird https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Mockingbird
- 082349872349872 6y agoIt's not as if the vocabulary in tech doesn't change* every few decades anyway. In this case the vocabulary change is intentional, but even if one believes it misguided, it's hard to argue it's harmful. * Myer and Sutherlands "On the Design of Display Processors" gives some sense of how we go around in circles (or, hopefully, spirals), but I'm unaware of any reference for how vocabulary changes while the concepts remain unaltered. An example might be "prefix sum" calculations (or whatever they're called on GPUs nowadays), as these have appeared under different names back to before computers. (when hand calculating, in the days when "computer" was a job description, not a machine, and US Navy calculations took weeks to run, shallow parallel algorithms could save substantial sums)
- dx87 6y agoIt seems easy to argue that it's harmful. They're actively wasting people's time, and making it seem like civil rights activists don't have any legitimate complaints if this is the kind of stuff they spend their energy on.
- downerending 6y agoThis is an important point. Pushing trivia like this uses up the attention and good will that people have to spend on the larger issues. If you want to change the world, lead with what actually matters.
- zzo38computer 6y ago> In this case the vocabulary change is intentional, but even if one believes it misguided, it's hard to argue it's harmful. Often it isn't harmful, but sometimes it can be, so that is why to be careful of it, I think. Altering comments (and documentation) is probably not harmful (as long as it remains clear, or in some cases, becomes even more clearly meaning), but altering names of commands and other stuff (especially if it is an exposed API) is more problematic, I think. (Changing them to same words as other things to be confusing, or breaking URLs, or whatever, is also harmful, though.) I think that it is best to change the vocabulary when the concepts are altered, and to leave it the same when the concepts remain unaltered, although I am not trying to stop you or anyone from writing what they want to write; if they don't like these words, change them, especially if the new words are a better description of it anyways. (But I believe in freedom of speech: If someone else doesn't want to change their program or document, don't force them to do so. But I also dislike copyright: I believe that if you don't like their program or document or whatever, you should be allowed to make (and use, and distribute) a modified copy.)
- sbarre 6y agoHumans have to use and read the code. The word "slave" obviously doesn't mean anything to you, but is it not within your comprehension to see how it could be a painful word to encounter, in any context, for some of our fellow humans?
- adrianN 6y agoI believe that almost everybody who is able to read code is also able to understand that words have different meanings in different contexts and a RNG really doesn't suffer if it's a slave to another RNG.
- BolexNOLA 6y agoIf you can’t see why the term “slave” might cause issues I don’t know what to tell you.
- adrianN 6y agoI really don't see it. For example the term pet is perfectly fine when applied to a dog, but very questionable when applied to a human. Should we rename pets to something else?
- sbarre 6y agoI don't know how else to put this but you really seem to lack empathy for your fellow human beings. You are turning people's real pain into a pedantic discussion about language and context, and ignoring the real-world context of this specific scenario. The tone deafness is astounding.
- distantaidenn 6y agoIf I am incorrect, I do apologize, but I assume you are not a person of color, or perhaps you come from a country in which you are the majority. I am a P.O.C, and these small things do set a bit of a tingle in my mind when I hear them. As a software developer, I cringe a bit to myself when I have to say terms like "whitelist" and "blacklist" or "master/slave" Obviously to you they may just be innocuous words, but think about what they represent: good vs. not good. Growing up in America, these terms hold a rather disgusting history -- and upon hearing them, I find it difficult to remove that context. I don't think this has any racist connotations, but it can and does make some people feel needlessly uncomfortable. It's a small change, and I applaud their efforts.
- ARandomerDude 6y agoWhite/black for good/evil predate American slavery by a few millennia. They aren't racial terms, they relate to light and darkness (as in EM radiation).
- distantaidenn 6y agoConsider this thought experiment: if you were a P.O.C., say black for example -- how would you feel growing up seeing that all things bad or ill are associated with the term that your people have been called. Blacklist, blackball, black magic, blackmail, and the list goes on. You might have never thought of these things, simply because it may not a part of your daily life. If we can fix this in even a small way: then why not?
- ARandomerDude 6y agoI hope I would have the clarity of mind to realize that just because I have taken offense doesn't mean anyone has given offense.
- wayneftw 6y agoI don’t think I’ve seen very many people that are purely black. Most of them look like they are shades of brown to me.
- tekproxy 6y agoIt clears the mind of problematic thoughts. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Newspeak#Vocabulary https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Newspeak#Vocabulary