4 ms·
> The problem with long lasting alien civilisations is that if they do exist, why aren't they here already? Colonizing the galaxy only takes a few millions year
by tzs 6y ago
> The problem with long lasting alien civilisations is that if they do exist, why aren't they here already? Colonizing the galaxy only takes a few millions years even with 0.1c.
Suppose it turns out that there is nothing faster for interstellar travel than rockets or light sails. No wormholes stabilized with exotic matter. No warp drives. No other tricks.
I'm not sure in that case that those long lasting civilizations would bother trying interstellar colonization. The round trip transport time between the home world and colonies would be so long that it is hard to come up with any economic benefit establishing such colonies provides to the home worlds.
- est31 6y ago> it is hard to come up with any economic benefit establishing such colonies provides to the home worlds. If medium human life were only 4 weeks, nobody would find funding for a 1 year colonization trip across a different continent. You wouldn't find a crew when it'd take one generation just to cross the atlantic once. I think it's similar here. With future (bio-)technological improvements, we might live for hundreds or thousands of years. Suddenly individuals would start thinking really long term... At one point every niche of the solar system will either be declared a national park/treasure, or mined, filled with real estate developments, etc. We'd run out of space and some rich folks would meet on one of the private moons of Jupiter (like how there are private islands today) to discuss a venture towards another star.
- zamfi 6y ago> The round trip transport time between the home world and colonies would be so long that it is hard to come up with any economic benefit establishing such colonies provides to the home worlds. Let’s just hope, for the sake of any beings already on other planets, that you are right. History here on Earth suggests that long journeys are not a sufficient obstacle for exploitation.
- TheOtherHobbes 6y agoThe problem with these discussions is everyone seems to assume colonising a galaxy is just like colonising a planet - so you have an Age of Exploration, and then you set up colonies, and stuff happens, and you have an Empire or a Federation, or something. This is really, really unlikely to be true, for all kinds of reasons. There's a huge difference between colonising a galaxy - which assumes some kind of uniform culture, and common strategic goals - and simply throwing more or less living/sentient stuff around a galaxy and hoping some of it sticks. We've gone from barely being noticeable on Earth to being in danger of being responsible for a planetary extinction event in around 12,000 years. We know nothing about building a stable culture that can last for millions of years. It's unlikely any sentient species will be able to learn that skill without making a lot of mistakes - some of which will be terminal. So galactic colonisation requires a lot more than solving the mechanics of transportation. And the "few million years at 0.1c" estimate is going to be Not Even Wrong.
- bhaak 6y agoYou don't need to build a stable culture for a galaxy wide colonisation. We colonized the whole planet without that. Likewise a locust-like swarm of colonizing ships without any central control or common culture would also be a possibility.