3 ms·
The public has a short memory and also has authoritarian tendencies of its own. Which is why huge country estates and other trophy homes are considered the ulti
by TheOtherHobbes 6y ago
The public has a short memory and also has authoritarian tendencies of its own. Which is why huge country estates and other trophy homes are considered the ultimate architectural ideal, even though they're insanely inefficient and you have to be a multi-millionaire to afford one.
Popular architecture is about land and status, not sculpted living space, and the populist solution is to give people an experience of land ownership - even if it's vicarious. The Garden City movement attempted this with some success, but the political problem is that land is an expensive commodity, and there was no way that kind of low density housing was ever going to be available on a mass scale.
And consider that before modernism, most housing was appalling. No one loves the flats built in the UK during the 60s, but they replaced slums which were cold, damp, smoky, and very cheaply built, and often lacked even the most basic plumbing.
There's a lot to hate about modernism (and its descendants) - not least that bare concrete looks absolutely fucking awful in a rainy and cloudy climate. But it makes no sense to compare hyper-expensive hand-crafted Victorian homes of rich elites and high-status civic projects with modern worker housing or utilitarian office spaces.
The fact that high-status civic projects - libraries, transport hubs, town halls - are (mostly) not being built any more, but trophy skyscrapers are, is a political issue, not an architectural one.