3 ms·
The article does mention about some integration with nature, and from some Google pictures it seems that Barbican State has at least some greenery. > Brutalism
by rglullis 6y ago
The article does mention about some integration with nature, and from some Google pictures it seems that Barbican State has at least some greenery.
> Brutalism has become popular with many people of my age.
Has it really? Have you lived in any of the places you mentioned and consider nice? That has always been a better test than going by people's expressed opinions.
In Brazil it is quite easy to find people that praise Oscar Niemeyer's work, but none of them actually live in Brasilia - and I am yet to see a catholic that has any good thing to say about Rio de Janeiro's Cathedral.
- cannam 6y ago> > Brutalism has become popular with many people of my age. > Has it really? Have you lived in any of the places you mentioned and consider nice? I can't afford to. I do know people who live in the Barbican estate, at least, and who love it. But it's a good question and I think quite right. My remark does sort of exhibit the same mistake that Brutalism was supposed to avoid - using public appreciation of aesthetic quality as a proxy for lived quality. And I also see that I'm praising the expensive, ambitious, now-unaffordable projects, not the ones that were "problematic" and then blown up, like Red Roads (in Glasgow) or Heygate (in London).