4 ms·
You make it sound like it's normal that people would expect that they can drive into a bridge without checking the height first - as if it's the bridge's fault
by chrisseaton 6y ago
You make it sound like it's normal that people would expect that they can drive into a bridge without checking the height first - as if it's the bridge's fault for being too low. Why don't the drivers check?
- sixothree 6y agoBecause people are human. They are passing a 4-way intersection. Their wife is angry at them. Their boss is giving them a hard time. Who knows. People are human and they make mistakes all the time. That's why simple, clear signage helps. Why wayfaring is a science. Why packaging is difficult.
- chrisseaton 6y ago> That's why simple, clear signage helps. But the bridge is signed, isn't it?
- sixothree 6y agoIf it were done well, would there have been 100+ accidents?
- chrisseaton 6y agoI guess I don't understand why tall vehicles are approaching a bridge at such speed that they don't have time to react. It doesn't seem an abnormally low bridge in the first place.
- compiler-guy 6y agoIt is about two feet or so below modern standard for bridge clearance. But it was within spec when it was built.
- necovek 6y agoI am pretty confident an abnormally low bridge would have fewer accidents — the fact that it looks like it's just high enough doesn't help matters. Perhaps the simplest solution is to introduce a light hanging (eg rubber) plate to make the underpass appear even shorter so people do stop and look at the signs.
- compiler-guy 6y agoI used to drive under this bridge almost every day. It is remarkably well signed. But some people just can’t be reached. I’m reminded of the elective attention test. http://www.theinvisiblegorilla.com/gorilla_experiment.html http://www.theinvisiblegorilla.com/gorilla_experiment.html
- sebastien_b 6y ago>> That's why simple, clear signage helps. > But the bridge is signed, isn't it? But is it done clearly?
- chrisseaton 6y agoIt's a huge bridge, right in your way. What more do you really think they should do? Why is anyone driving underneath a bridge without carefully checking the height. If the height isn't clear, why don't people stop rather than just ploughing into it.
- sebastien_b 6y agoEver missed a single down-step and fell down/got tripped up? How could you possibly miss it??? I mean, it was right there in front of you! I mean, it doesn’t matter that it “blended in” and wasn’t easily visible, and has no handrail, it was still right there.
- chrisseaton 6y ago> it doesn’t matter that it “blended in” and wasn’t easily visible It's a MASSIVE bridge, right in front of your face, and bright yellow warning bar.
- sebastien_b 6y agoTHE POINT IS that the height difference isn’t that “massive” as you describe it - LOOK AT ALL THE VIDEOS (that’s right: plural) - it’s clear that the lack of clearance is not so obvious.
- chrisseaton 6y agoBut if there’s any bridge coming at you, don’t you stop and think ‘will I fit under this?’
- jacquesm 6y agoBecause they're not used to driving trucks. Modern light weight cargo vehicles accelerate and brake as though they are personal cars. Spend an hour or two behind the wheel of one and you're liable to forget that you have this huge box behind you that extends well over the height of the cab, the part that is in your immediate field of view. It takes some serious situational awareness to keep that at the front of your thoughts when driving an unfamiliar vehicle on unfamiliar roads. The basic assumption people make is that the roads they know or that are indicated by their navigator are the roads that they can drive on. I don't recall even if my navigator has a way of setting the vehicle height, I should check that.
- chrisseaton 6y agoIsn't the first and last thing anyone driving a tall vehicle is told that they should check the height of bridges before going under them?
- jacquesm 6y agoAbsolutely. And then you do it for a couple of hours concentrating on the road and driving the car between the lines nicely widthwise and you'll forget it when you need it most. I've done a lot of driving, some of it boxtrucks and larger and when you switch vehicles it is a thing that you need to remind yourself of constantly. The easiest solution would be to dig that road out to standard depth, the next best would be to drop it from all navigation systems so that at least people that do not know about it won't try to use it.
- chrisseaton 6y ago> And then you do it for a couple of hours concentrating on the road and driving the car between the lines nicely widthwise and you'll forget it when you need it most. Must be different locations being different. But where I'm from you couldn't remotely just drive regardless of your vehicle height. You'd smash into something within minutes.
- 6y ago
- sebastien_bois 6y ago> You make it sound like it's normal that people would expect that they can drive into a bridge without checking the height first 1. Most people would correctly expect that road-approved vehicles would clear all bridges. 2. This one is literally a couple of inches out for clearance; it looks like the truck is 12ft (or whatever the current bridge height is), which is probably what the truck's height indication is. It's not unreasonable for the driver to expect to clear the bridge even knowing the height of both, especially if they match closely. 3. The bridge was recently lifted to its current height - if this is a 'local' driver, they probably expect all vehicles to clear it now, knowing it got lifted.
- chrisseaton 6y ago> Most people would correctly expect that road-approved vehicles would clear all bridges. Oh right ok that's it - in my country you absolutely can't assume this so everyone is careful at all low-looking bridges.
- necovek 6y agoBut I would wager that this is not a "low-looking bridge" — and I am confident making it look like an even lower bridge would help matters.