6 ms·
It seems like a simple law could fix this: Phone device makers that provide an application store must also allow the user to load non-approved applications wit
by jedberg 6y ago
It seems like a simple law could fix this:
Phone device makers that provide an application store must also allow the user to load non-approved applications with equivalent API access to approved applications, and must make it possible for the user to load a third-party application store with equivalent access to the first-party application store.
- anchpop 6y agoI would like this to be extended to game consoles and any other kind of personal computing device, too! Although phones are clearly the most egregious example, game console manufacturers create a weird two-party market where they subsidize the purchase of the console so they can rent-seek off the larger playerbase by taking a cut of game sales.
- jedberg 6y agoExcellent point. It should probably apply to any hardware where you can load applications. There should always be a way for a user to load their own applications.
- threeseed 6y agoThat would completely destroy the gaming console market. Nintendo would largely be fine. Sony and Microsoft however would be forced into anti-consumer practices like putting advertising everywhere and selling your data. Not to mention a complete consolidation of the studios where most games would be made by Sony Studios and only sold on the Sony app store.
- WrtCdEvrydy 6y ago> like putting advertising everywhere and selling your data Ever used Xbox Live on the Xbox you paid for and seen ads? We're already there.
- 013a 6y agoGame consoles don't have the kind of monopoly market that smartphone makers have. Firstly, because smartphones have evolved to become a generally indispensable item for most people, whereas game consoles don't have the same broad appeal and necessity. But also, secondly, game developers don't feel the same impetus to release on any individual platform, including the most popular closed-down platform, PS4. On the contrary, most games are released as exclusives, or otherwise intentionally limit their release platforms to ease engineering burden (example: Hollow Knight Silksong, an upcoming indie game from the very small Team Cherry (3 people last I checked), is intentionally only releasing on Steam and Switch at launch because supporting PS and Xbox is too difficult). Valorant will do fine despite not being on PS4 or Xbox. Halo Infinite will do fine despite not being on PS4. The Last of Us II will do fine despite not being on Xbox or PC. This is the story for practically every game; net revenue from a specific title rarely increases enough to compensate for the additional effort of supporting a new platform, especially when platform exclusivity checks come in to play. Speaking on platform exclusivity checks: They're an indispensable part of the industry and the production process for new games. Naughty Dog starts working on TLOU2 six years ago; they don't start seeing revenue from it until yesterday, after multiple delays and setbacks. Where does the money come from to pay developers until then? The publisher, which most commonly nowadays, is also a platform holder. Where does their money come from? The most sustainable, long-term revenue source is a storefront cut for already released games; Sony's 30% on every game funds Naughty Dog's development team. What about the 70% from, say, the first Last of Us? Sure, that forms a critical component, but unless you're a studio that can consistently release mega-hit after mega-hit, that money will dry up. There are maybe 10 studios out there who can do this (Naughty Dog is one of them, so imagine we're instead talking about, lets say, Remedy with their recent game Control). In other words, this is investing in individual stocks versus market indices; the 30% cut from every game is more sustainable than the 70% cut from individual games, because not every game releases to massive success. Think Mass Effect Andromeda, No Mans Sky, Fallout 76, etc. Take Fortnite; it funded Epic's ability to launch the Epic Games Store, and write exclusivity checks to companies like Remedy to secure Control. While I do believe Epic is being honest when they push their 12/88% revenue split and shit on Steam for their 30/70, lets be realistic: Fortnite enables them to do it, not morality. Epic paid $10M for Control [1]. Sony also paid some undisclosed amount for PS4-exclusive content, though the game also released on Xbox. Would Control exist, at least in its current awesome form, without those massive checks? Absolutely not. At best, development would have had to been rushed, or specific nice-to-haves would have been cut. At worst, who knows. But Remedy's previous release, Quantum Break (2016), was a keystone exclusive release for Xbox One, for which they likely also paid millions upfront, and it did not perform well. Now, what you may be thinking is, what about companies like EA, Ubisoft, Rockstar, the "AAA third party studios". Yet, even these companies get huge checks from Sony and Microsoft. Sony paid Activision what was likely several million dollars for 1 year PS4 exclusivity on a multiplayer mode for Modern Warfare. Red Dead 2 had exclusive PS4 content at launch. When Destiny 2 releases a new map, it at least used to come to PS4 before anyone else. Xbox likely cut a special deal with EA for Access exclusivity on Xbox for years. Every company out there gets checks from these platforms at some point. When Apple takes its 30%, app developers see none of it. But, with game consoles, to some significant degree that 30% is paying into a a bank account that you may, at some point in the future, be able to withdraw from if you promise a platform holder a bit (or a lot) of exclusive content. The hardware is a loss-leader. The subscription services (XBLG, PSN+, Game Pass) contribute some, but a lot of that money is already earmarked. That 30% cut is critical. The games industry is far more of a cycle than the App Store, and hurting the platform holders' ability to push this cycle along would have huge, unpredictable ramifications for the industry. Its not all good, but its far more necessary than Apple's 30% cut. [1] https://www.pcgamer.com/epic-paid-dollar1045-million-for-controls-exclusivity/ https://www.pcgamer.com/epic-paid-dollar1045-million-for-con...
- Sargos 6y agoIt seems very common sense. I don't even know what the argument would be against this measure as it's completely optional for users and neutralizes censorship and anti-trust concerns. Seems like a win-win for both consumers and the platforms.
- JoshTriplett 6y ago> I don't even know what the argument would be against this measure While I do absolutely agree that sideloading should be possible, I do know that many phishing/security scams involve (or used to involve) installing a sideloaded application. It should be easy to install a sideloaded application if you understand the implications (and maintain the same protection that ensures you know what permissions you're granting the application), but it should not be easy to accidentally or unknowingly install a sideloaded application. Maintaining that distinction is a challenge; it's important enough to be worth doing, though.
- grishka 6y agoAndroid shows some scary-ish warnings the first time you try to install an apk, and has you go into system settings and allow yourself sideloading apps from that particular source (browser, self-updating beta of something and so on). With this and all the permissions and sandboxing, it would take some serious dedication to scam yourself this way.
- threeseed 6y ago> it would take some serious dedication to scam yourself this way Consumers every day go to extreme lengths to satisfy the wishes of scammers. They will physically drive to the store, buy iTunes Gift Cards and hand over the codes to them. They will take photos of passports, credit cards etc for identify theft. They will install whatever software they are asked to. The idea that they won't go into some setting and enable "Sideloading Apps" which sounds completely harmless is a bit ridiculous.
- 6y ago
- graeme 6y agoWouldn’t this lead to intense efforts to install malware and scams?
- jedberg 6y agoProbably. Just like on your PC. But I'm not sure that is a good reason not to have it. We've put mitigations in place on the PC.
- threeseed 6y agoThis reality you want to impose on the world is hilarious. Just picturing wanting to sit down and play on my PS4 and having to first run virus and malware checkers.
- oauea 6y agoThis reality you want to impose on the world is hilarious. Just picturing buying a computing device, then not being able to install the software I want on it.
- threeseed 6y agoI am not imposing any reality. The status quo is then when you buy console devices e.g. gaming, cars, TVs etc you can only install apps that are approved by the manufacturer. People think of phones as console devices not computers.
- Nextgrid 6y ago> Just picturing wanting to sit down and play on my PS4 and having to first run virus and malware checkers. Why would a reputable game developer ever release malware? You can still go to a reputable developer's website or even Sony's website and obtain the game from their store and be guaranteed that it's free from malware. Of course, if you're obtaining your games from Torrent-Warez-1337.net then you need to be more careful but then it's your fault, it's not like you didn't know what you were in for when you went to a shady website.
- rajlego 6y agoI thought you could already do this on iOS? I can’t remember where I saw it but I could’ve sworn you can without jailbreak
- jedberg 6y agoYou cannot. You can kind of do it if you pay for a developer account and can get the source code and compile it yourself and sign it yourself. You can also install Testflight which allows someone (with a developer account) to distribute a limited number of copies. But you can't just go online and download an app.
- eqtn 6y agoYou can kinda do it using altstore.
- jsjohnst 6y agoDespite sibling comment implying otherwise incorrectly, there are multiple ways to install non-app store approved apps. 1) you can sign an app for your device and run it without paying Apple anything for 7 days. After 7 days you have to do it again. Not convenient in the slightest, but still possible for free. 2) you can pay Apple $99/year for a paid dev account and the 7 day window extends to 365 days. Neither of those above options require source code, somebody else could’ve compiled the app, you just need to sign it. 3) TestFlight allows installation without full App Store review and builds expire after 60 days (or is it 90, I forget?). I believe the cap of “limited people” sibling referred to is 10,000 these days, but I could be wrong. iSH is an example of a popular app using this route. 4) Corporations can sign up for an enterprise account for $299/year. This allows signing apps similarish to option 2 above, but for a virtually unlimited number of devices. The apps are required by policy to not be distributed to the general public though.
- jedberg 6y agoI'm not exactly sure how I was incorrect. I said exactly the same thing you did, just with fewer numbers. At the end of the day, you can't just download an app and install it. You have to go through hoops, all of which involve money, expirations, or limits.
- michaelt 6y agoThat would be better than nothing, but wouldn't the alternative app stores end up being vimeo to Apple's youtube? With every developer needing to obey Apple's policies and get into their store if they want to make a living from their work?
- jedberg 6y agoMy assumption is that it would force apple to have better and more transparent policies. For example, if every app that didn't like the 30% cut rule went to another app store that didn't have that rule, that other app store would either get really popular or Apple would be forced to change their fee structure.
- michaelt 6y agoSo long as keeping 70% of 100 sales is better than keeping 100% of 50 sales, I just can't see competing app stores getting big.
- jedberg 6y agoI don't assume it would fix all problems. I just assume it would force Apple to move to a slightly more developer/consumer friendly model. Also, in a lot of cases, the choice is 100% of 0 sales because Apple just won't let you in their store. For an example of what a third party app store would look like, check out Cydia app store (the main way to get apps on your jailbroken phone). There are a ton of useful apps in there.
- glogla 6y agoMight be, but it might be Epic and Humble Stores to Apple's Steam.
- ntsplnkv2 6y agoIn general I am against legislation like this. There are plenty of areas for remediation for a rejected app. You can offer on competing platforms (Android), or offer a web-app which is usable on an iPhone. Or you can follow the rules of the app store. Those are 3 perfectly viable options. We have a tendency to view anything that goes against "us" as unfair. I don't see anything that Apple is doing that is anti-competitive, and don't see why legislation is necessary.
- jedberg 6y agoA standard legal test is: "are the alternatives equivalent". The three options you provide are not at all equivalent. That makes it anti-competitive. Android isn't the same as Apple. They also have their own rules. A web app doesn't have the same level of access as a native app. The rules of the app store are unfair and aren't applied equally to everyone.
- ntsplnkv2 6y ago> A standard legal test is: "are the alternatives equivalent". The three options you provide are not at all equivalent. That makes it anti-competitive. The test is rather, are the alternatives viable. And that they are. You also have to prove that Apple is being anti-competitive - which is not true. Apple is applying their rules as equally as possible - just because it's imperfect enforcement, doesn't make it anti-competitive - it's unfair to punish when the scope of the problem means there will be apps that slip through wrongly. Example: There are multiple email apps on the app store, and Apple isn't removing Hey because they also have a $99 email app. That would be anti-competitive. That's not what's happening here. > Android isn't the same as Apple. They also have their own rules. Android you can use third party app stores and sideload without any rules at all, and it's a bigger market. Sounds like a viable alternative. > A web app doesn't have the same level of access as a native app. Gmail has a website and an app. Both do the same thing - email. It's a viable alternative. > The rules of the app store are unfair and aren't applied equally to everyone. Imperfect enforcement is not the same as they aren't applied equally. It seems to me that they are - Apple is looking for offenders, finding them, and removing them. Seems pretty equal to me.
- scarface74 6y agoApple ‘s APIs also require access to Apple’s infrastructure - like CloudKit and notifications that go through their infrastructure.