8 ms·
Nextdoor ends its program for forwarding suspicions to police
- throwawaysea 6y ago> Civil rights and privacy advocates have raised concerns about how the feature streamlined the reporting of suspicions about minor offenses, encouraging police to follow up on what would have otherwise been casual observations on social media. Why is this a problem? Minor offenses are still offenses and they can often be very frustrating and problematic. They still deserve police attention where they constitute a violation of the law. Streamlining the process is a positive not negative, and the framing here just seems like these activist groups don’t want people to be held accountable.
- PeterisP 6y agoI believe that this results in this being used as a tool of harassment against people who are less popular in the neighbourhood for arbitrary - sometimes discriminatory - reasons.
- soulofmischief 6y agoIn my experience, my local Nextdoor is filled with racist Karens who think every black person walking the street at night is casing a joint, and every homeless guy is intoxicated. This system feeds the neurosis of so many stay-at-home parents and upper-middle-class professionals and is overall a net negative. Too many false positives make the system useless and actually harmful.
- madengr 6y agoI found it was the opposite. White Karen soccer moms virtue signaling with BLM drivel about systematic racism, etc.
- jquery 6y agoKaren is a racial slur, or at least fits the definition of one. I suggest wrestling with the irony of what you just typed.
- damnyou 6y agoWhat history of oppression does the term "Karen" have associated with it? The N word and "faggot" both have centuries of violence behind them.
- ALittleLight 6y agoI'm not aware of a time requirement for a term to qualify as a slur. It seems pretty straightforward that "Karen" does qualify though. You generalize the behavior of a group (women, housewives, etc) and describe them with a pejorative. Adult women have a right to complain about things and report things if they think they are illegal. That some number of women may have filed false or exaggerated reports doesn't give you or others license to dismiss everyone of a similar demographic.
- damnyou 6y agoIn my part of the world, the term "slur" necessarily denotes a history of oppression. Yours might be different.
- ALittleLight 6y agoThe defense that "this slur was recently coined" doesn't strike me as that compelling. "Karen" plays on long standing stereotypes of women as hysterical or nagging. The name-as-insult is new, but the stereotypes are not.
- soulofmischief 6y agoI use the term Chad just as often. We're talking about common societal stereotypes and not slurs at all. When you have 8 billion people, you start to see patterns in personalities. Karen is one such observed pattern in modern society. You don't want to die on this hill, bud.
- alistairSH 6y agoBecause on Nextdoor, walking down the street while black in the wrong neighborhood is a minor offense. That site is a complete cesspool.
- samatman 6y agoYou are of course correct about minor offenses. I suggest you show the courage of your convictions, and do a few hour's research on exactly how much is illegal at present. Then, turn yourself in for only the Federal crimes you've committed in the past year. We'll never see you again, of course, but it's a small price to pay.
- TheSpiceIsLife 6y agoThis would be a fun way to antagonise the police. Flash mob style, waiting in line, no! camping out for days waiting in line, not to buy tickets to the next reiteration of $sameoldstorybutwithmorelensflare, but to turn yourself in with video evidence of jaywalking or cycling without a helmet.
- serf 6y agothere is a bit by the comedian Doug Stanhope about how the time of the 'occupy wallstreet' group of people would have been better spent by sitting within the lobbies of large banking institutions and applying for superfluous loans that would be known to be denied before hand, taking advantage of the laws in place that disallow discrimination with regards to loan applications. His example is something like 'Yes, I came here to apply for a loan of a billion dollars for an ant farm, yes I would like a complimentary coffee.' It's an entertaining idea.
- jacquesm 6y agoThat's actually an excellent idea and fairly easy to put into practice. Most of those processes don't scale at all and rely on self pre-selection and evaluation. The fact that NINJA applicants ever stood a chance was a good indication that something was terribly wrong.
- thrwaway_3212 6y agoYou can both disagree with petty laws for minor violations and still want prohibitions against theft or public disturbances enforced in your neighborhood.
- pooper 6y ago>Why is this a problem? Minor offenses are still offenses and they can often be very frustrating and problematic. They still deserve police attention where they constitute a violation of the law. Streamlining the process is a positive not negative, and the framing here just seems like these activist groups don’t want people to be held accountable. Be careful of what you wish for. You might wish to look at your local municipal/county/parish/state laws. I likely break dozens of laws/ordinances every day and I'm very positive you do as well, without even knowing it. I am very saddened that I have to spell this out. I don't know whether you use NextDoor, throwawaysea. Would you be willing to post this under your real name in NextDoor and share the link here?
- SilasX 6y ago>I likely break dozens of laws/ordinances every day and I'm very positive you do as well, without even knowing it. Okay but then isn't that the real problem? Of not regularly weeding out laws against things that people don't really feel need to be banned? It's kind of clumsy to take the approach of, "We're going to keep dubious laws on the books, and also have ultra-random, haphazard enforcement of all laws regardless of how merited."
- arrrg 6y agoBoth are problems. People who abuse that situation and useless laws on the books.
- notatoad 6y agoyes, that is a real problem and it should be solved. but in the absence of a solution to that problem, shutting down tools that make it easy to take advantage of that problem to be racist and/or annoying is a decent starting point.
- baddox 6y agoThe problem is that when everyone is guilty of something, the government can pick and choose who it punishes, through prosecutorial discretion, selective policing, and other means.
- newacct583 6y ago> Minor offenses are still offenses The problem, as is always the case, is that "minor offenses" are not equitably enforced. So if the local white kids are hanging out at the corner of the park smoking weed, no one cares. No one posts to Nextdoor. The police don't show up. But four young hispanic men walking through the same white neighborhood (to get to a job, say) will freak someone out and a busybody post to nextdoor will end up getting them stopped. Oh, and it turns out that one of them has weed in his pocket. There's your "minor offense". It's still an offense, right? It deserves police attention? You're looking at this with a microscope. No one is saying don't enforce boring laws. People are saying do it fairly. Nattering busybodies on Nextdoor are the opposite of fair.
- jquery 6y ago> Nattering busybodies on Nextdoor What is more fair than locals choosing which stuff is bothering them?
- newacct583 6y agoBecause left to their own devices, some locals decide that stuff like "black kids in the neighborhood" are what bother them. We had this argument already, like sixty years ago. Your side lost.
- pnako 6y agoIt does look like separation is back on the menu in America, so I would not be too quick to claim victory. Look around the world and you will mostly see ethnically homogeneous neighborhoods. It's not by random occurrence.
- joshuamorton 6y agoWhen the things bothering them are "having black neighbors", I'd say most other systems are more fair.
- jquery 6y ago
- ponker 6y agoBecause what is an “offense” is designed to capture a certain kind of person who harms the public but leaves the other, much more harmful kind, untouched. What is the harm caused by stealing a package off a doorstep compared to creating a Facebook ad for oversexualized garments targeting young girls? Compared to marketing addictive pharmaceuticals to people who do not need them? Compared to issuing a fraudulent AAA rating on a mortgage backed security and selling it to a pension fund? Which gets the police involved?
- TheSpiceIsLife 6y agoThe problem isn’t minor offences as such. It’s the reporting of the suspicion. I don’t need my neighbour calling the police on the suspicious of $minor_offence.
- mindslight 6y agoPolice departments are failing to arrest murderers even when there is ample evidence. Let's focus on the felonies until they can get those right.
- madengr 6y agoNextdoor actual does the opposite, censoring conversations that do not meet their political beliefs (which you can guess lean left). I recently deleted my account for the worthless service, as they were deleting responses to those pushing BLM propaganda.
- wespiser_2018 6y agoI live in an immediate suburb of Boston, and joined Nextdoor and joined to see what features were attracting so many folks to a new social media platform. Wow! Anyone with a tattoo, going to your door for any reason was considered "suspicious" and reported. One alarming thing, is that NextDoor is feeding on our fears about outsiders who look different, and creating a loop out of this for higher engagement when people post pictures and engage their camera feed. It's too bad, I think idea of organizing a social network based on proximity and centered around community information is a viable idea, It's just that NextDoor is doing that with our worst instincts.
- heavyset_go 6y agoThis has been my experience, as well. Take this type of echo chamber to its extreme, and you get this[1] kind of reaction from an entire community, where they end up chasing a Hispanic family out of town because someone said they were antifa on Facebook[2]. [1] https://www.oregonlive.com/pacific-northwest-news/2020/06/family-harassed-accused-of-being-political-activists-before-being-trapped-at-washington-campsite-authorities-say.html https://www.oregonlive.com/pacific-northwest-news/2020/06/fa... [2] https://twitter.com/RandazzoTweets/status/1268608526491910145 https://twitter.com/RandazzoTweets/status/126860852649191014...
- TheSpiceIsLife 6y agoOk, I read both the links you provided, and it would appear your words: > reaction from an entire community, where they end up chasing a Hispanic family out of town Is a drastic overstatement of what happened. Or did I miss something? Are there really only four vehicles in the entire community of Forks?
- heavyset_go 6y agoYou missed something, because it was more than 4 cars. Members of the community followed them in, then others approached them at a store and several hours later a larger group chased them out. Among the people involved are city councilmen, the mayor and his son, and several local business owners. Dozens of people were involved in person, and dozens more online. Armed people were mobilized in not only Forks, WA, but Olympia and Port Townsend based on rumors about the Hispanic family. For example, when they were stopped at the store, the family is quoted as saying[1]: > The family had shopped for camping supplies at Forks Outfitters and were confronted “by seven or eight carloads of people in the grocery store parking lot,” Anderson said they reported to deputies. No one in the community is willing to come forward with the names of the guilty parties, however many of them were okay with spreading violent rumors about out-of-towners, both of which are levels of complicity in my book. [1] https://www.peninsuladailynews.com/crime/family-harassed-in-forks-after-being-accused-of-being-members-of-antifa/ https://www.peninsuladailynews.com/crime/family-harassed-in-...
- rubyn00bie 6y agoFuck you, Nextdoor. Not. Enough. Nextdoor is known to be platform that enables bigotry and perpetuates racial stereotypes. Nextdoor, not forwarding bullshit suspicions to the police, is the least they could do since they created the fucking problem to begin with. It encourages one to view everyone who you don't immediately recognize as an outsider, causing you to fear them, and then share that fear with others so they too can be afraid. It's absolute madness, and I haven't ever heard a good thing in the real world about Nextdoor. I have had people assume my race incorrectly though, and gleefully admit their racist usage of it not knowing what they were about to say would be considered so fucking awful...
- spydum 6y agoI suspect you are projecting too much on their motives. It seemed to me to be a great place to establish neighborhood communities they could advertise to, with the side benefit of opening up communication inside the neighborhood as well. What's unfortunate is how some people choose to communicate and fear monger. I've seen it used both positively and negatively- really depends on the neighbors. Depending on the privacy agreement, would be very intriguing to see neighborhood sentiment analysis... Maybe pick out those racist neighborhoods to avoid (or join? Maybe you are into homogeneity).
- chillacy 6y agoI don't use nextdoor so I don't know, but how much is caused by the platform's design and how much of that is just "these suburbanites are racist"?
- Spooky23 6y agoRacism is only one annoying persona. The big advertisers have been Ring and security companies, so they tend to attract people worried about other people. They suppress things like political posts, so there really isn’t anything to do but worry about lost cats or busybody crap.
- js2 6y agoThe vast majority of nextdoor posts in my area are people asking whether a snake is a copperhead or not and then arguing over whether or not to kill it. Followed by people complaining about X (speeders, dog poop, roaming cats, etc). Also a lot of folks looking for miss-delivered packages. It's useful for borrowing a car seat, getting recommendations for plumbers, electricians, etc, advertising extra garden produce we wish to give away, and so forth. Otherwise, I stay off of it. Also from a technical and UI perspective, the web site is atrocious. It loads terribly slowly on a current generation iPad, constantly tries to route you to its app, makes it way too easy to accidentally interact with a post or comment, defaults to "top posts" instead of "recent activity" and on and on. It's barely any better visiting on a desktop. I much prefer the sub-reddits, city-data forums, and even FB groups for my area for keeping in touch with what's going around me.
- downerending 6y agoSame here, although within the last 24 hours, my neighborhood's chat is starting to look like a Twitter-ish hate-fest. If they don't stop, I'm going to chuck it in the same dumpster as Twitter.
- supernova87a 6y agoI think the problem with such tools is that the technology disconnected our societal checks to make sure that such tools are used correctly. Or didn't consider the need for that function at all as this new online capability was created. It was just some developer+PM saying, "what if we offered this?" And it just appeared, a new feature in the world. Now, maybe I will be downvoted for saying (in this climate), but the ability for people to see something suspicious and do something about it is important. You would have the pendulum swing the other way and have people actively tell themselves to ignore potential crime / bad actors, or be unable to report something legitimate? But the point is that up to recent years, your interactions with police were not anonymous, and you had to (generally) put your name and reputation (or phone number and your voice) behind things that you asserted were true. There was an element of credibility verification in the reporting. Today, anonymity on the internet, and the ease of creating false (or biased) reports has unleashed a tidal wave of noise and bad information, with no repercussions (reputation-wise, or cost) to the persons creating it. And the effects are all externalized to those who wrongly come under suspicion. There are some things that need to have a barrier to being done, and taking it online lowers that barrier. Until we figure out what that caused, and how it's to be handled correctly, it's right that these portals disable the features that are causing us these kinds of societal mistakes -- and we actively should choose to slow down our adoption of things that we don't yet understand the full implications of.
- ikeyany 6y agoThe ability to report dangerous things to the proper authorities is one of the ways you know you live in a functional society. That said, this whole topic brings up the question of "At what cost?" We won't see the macroeffects these have on our communities for quite a while. Our base insticts when it comes to how we should react when we see something off, are slowly changing.
- jacquesm 6y agoHah. East Germans know exactly what this sort of thing will lead to: selective enforcement against those that the police wish to target anyway. Nothing like a bit of good old snitching to the authorities. Too bad if you're not lily white and walking around in a posh - or not so posh - neighborhood past what others think should be your curfew. Of course, if you are witness to a serious crime you should report it. But if someone waters their lawn, sleeps in their car, or pees in their garden then that's their business and usually not yours so as long as you are not inconvenienced you should mind your own business lest one day the tables are turned and you forget to bring in your garbage container. And that's before we get into reporting people 'walking while black', those things might actually be against a law. If you're breaking N laws per day think about what the effect would be if those were all enforced. Do not do unto others... And don't give racists even more tools for harassment.
- smcl 6y agoOne thing I’ve learned over the years is that many people perceive: - themselves as perfect but making the odd honest mistake every now and then - others as fundamentally flawed, persistent rule-breakers who Need To Be Punished Even if they’re broadly the same or worse. This is true on the road, in college or writing code. A lot of people will be unable to look at their own tiny little infractions and see them as equivalent to the flagrant disregard for the rules that they observe in others.
- neeeeees 6y agoThis sounds like Fundamental Attribution Error: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fundamental_attribution_error https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fundamental_attribution_erro...
- Analemma_ 6y agoClose, but it’s more like “people perceive themselves and their ingroup as perfect but making occasional honest mistakes” and perceive their outgroup as flawed, persistent rule-breakers. And guess who the outgroup tends to be in racially homogeneous neighborhoods.
- jackcosgrove 6y agoI just logged into NextDoor today after years of inactivity because I wanted to see if there were resources about how to dispose of bulky trash items. Wow, what a mess! Standard lost dog fare, but also a lot of busybodies nitpicking about neighbors' municipal code violations, suspicions of people who don't look like they "fit" the neighborhood, and general bickering in every comment thread. NextDoor seems like a good idea, until you execute and it turns out the power users are busybodies holed up at home who have way too much time to micromanage the goings-on in their neighborhoods.
- Spooky23 6y agoMy neighborhood in Nextdoor was actually pretty non-toxic until recently. It has become overrun with lost/found/who owns this cat posts and people complaining about fireworks and dog trauma. (Since we had riots fireworks have been a constant presence)
- neonate 6y agohttps://archive.vn/hFSCI https://archive.vn/hFSCI
- chasd00 6y agoheh yeah i get lots of "beware of this suspicious person" messages that turn out to be hte mail man on Next Door. However, it is very useful for lost pets. IMO they need to expand on that utility, i routinely see lost/found pet posts were the owner and pet are eventually re-united via Next Door.
- Grimm1 6y agoNextdoor just seems like another 1984 esq system especially because of their ties to the state through the Police. This will never be making its way into my home. It honestly astounds me that people buy into these things especially with potentially petty neighbors you're one bad day away from being the person who "doesn't belong" in the neighborhood.
- mrfusion 6y agoWhen will Ring step up?
- int_19h 6y agoSome of the things on Nextdoor remind me of "Snow Crash" sometimes. "Fairlanes, Inc. is laying new ones all the time. Have to bulldoze lots of neighborhoods to do it, but those seventies and eighties developments exist to be bulldozed, right? No sidewalks, no schools, no nothing. Don’t have their own police force — no immigration control — undesirables can walk right in without being frisked or even harassed. Now a Burbclave, that’s the place to live. A city-state with its own constitution, a border, laws, cops, everything." "MetaCops Unlimited is the official peacekeeping force of White Columns, and also of The Mews at Windsor Heights, The Heights at Bear Run, Cinnamon Grove, and The Farms of Cloverdelle. They also enforce traffic regulations on all highways and byways operated by Fairlanes, Inc. ... MetaCops’ main competitor, WorldBeat Security, handles all roads belonging to Cruiseways, plus has worldwide contracts with Dixie Traditionals, Pickett’s Plantation, Rainbow Heights (check it out — two apartheid Burbclaves and one for black suits), Meadowvale on the [insert name of river] and Brickyard Station. WorldBeat is smaller than MetaCops, handles more upscale contracts, supposedly has a bigger espionage arm — though if that’s what people want, they just talk to an account rep at the Central Intelligence Corporation. And then there’s The Enforcers — but they cost a lot and don’t take well to supervision. It is rumored that, under their uniforms, they wear T-shirts bearing the unofficial Enforcer coat of arms: a fist holding a nightstick, emblazoned with the words SUE ME. ... These Burbclaves! These city-states! So small, so insecure, that just about everything, like not mowing your lawn, or playing your stereo too loud, becomes a national security issue."
- alance 6y agoAs someone who is trying to run a vaguely similar service (streetmates.net) I'm wondering how communities can be guided to be constructive and pleasant. Or maybe people are just people, pleasant and unpleasant and everything else, and it can't really be helped? It seems like putting something on the front page like "hey don't be a racist busy-body" isn't really enough. And at the other end of the extreme you've got Facebook employing organisations that filter sensitive content - with fairly horrific outcomes for the individuals who do the monitoring. HackerNews is a pretty good example of getting a certain standard of behaviour out of people en masse. I wonder what the secret sauce was?
- pcvarmint 6y agoSee something, say something