3 ms·
> students are taught that mindfulness creates space in which we can ‘choose our response’ as opposed to reacting or lashing out. [...] These might sound like r
by naasking 6y ago
> students are taught that mindfulness creates space in which we can ‘choose our response’ as opposed to reacting or lashing out. [...] These might sound like reasonable claims, but they imply a dichotomy between emotions and reason, and the superiority of ‘rational’ responses to distress. [...] Historically, these ideals have served to undermine oppressed groups, as anger and resistance is perceived as irrational.
Sometimes anger and resistance is rational, sometimes it's not. If mindfulness gives you the "mental space" to decide whether you are right to be angry, that's a good thing, and it absolutely is superior to purely acting emotionally.
I'm frankly struggling to see how anyone could think that modulating your emotions with reason is a bad idea.
- silveroriole 6y agoPossibly because constantly thinking “am I right to feel this way? How should I respond?” also describes the thinking patterns of anxious/autistic people. ‘Normal’ people generally just feel and act. They aren’t constantly modulating themselves. Maybe that means they make some suboptimal choices, but they also aren’t wasting time and making themselves feel bad by internally interrogating themselves non-stop.
- naasking 6y agoAnxious people can't help negative thought patterns. They happen despite their desires. That's the complete opposite of this case, so I'm not sure that's it.