3 ms·
I stayed away from PE, for a couple of reasons: 1) The teachers were invariably bullies. They would belittle students that they did not feel “performed well.”
by ChrisMarshallNY 6y ago
I stayed away from PE, for a couple of reasons:
1) The teachers were invariably bullies. They would belittle students that they did not feel “performed well.” Also, because of the nature of the class, this bullying could manifest in physical (not just verbal) form. PE was my “horror” class. I was terrified of it.
2) In the US, there is tremendous pressure to compete. Scoring is everywhere. I have never been a competitive person; always preferring consensus and cooperation. This attitude was highly discouraged in PE (often by nasty remarks from the teacher, and their “pets”).
3) I’m “on the spectrum,” and one of the manifestations of that, is rather poor coordination. I have never been able to perform well in any sport; no matter how hard I tried. I could get fit, but not good.
Sour grapes? Maybe.
But I do feel that bullying is a big problem in every society, and it is often done by the “winners,” so there’s no will to address it. No one wants to “hobble” their “stars.”
I don’t see how deep breathing exercises will address that.
- lemonberry 6y agoI believe that at some point in our nation's history PE lost it's bearing and no longer became about "physical education" per se and became more about sports and game type classes. Games like dodgeball allowed the bullies – teachers included – to flourish. Physical education should be just that, an education on the body. How it moves, how to retain mobility, how to get stronger, etc. There are books on this, I don't have any references at the moment sorry. I used to be a personal trainer. I stopped being amazed at how little people knew about their bodies and how to move them pretty quickly. It's a sad state of affairs. While I don't think physical fitness will "cure" people with clinical depression and anxiety I believe it's an important tool in the toolkit.
- ChrisMarshallNY 6y ago> While I don't think physical fitness will "cure" people with clinical depression and anxiety I believe it's an important tool in the toolkit. I completely agree. Physical fitness, when taught without a focus on competition, is extremely valuable. I'm sure that a big reason for my non-competitive stance, is because I learned, quite early on, that I would never be able to do particularly well in any physically competitive arena, and it wasn't even worth trying. I am also of Irish/Scottish/English heritage. Pretty much the Platonic Ideal of "white." I live in NY, with a significant percentage of folks of Mediterranean descent. I don't tan. I stroke. I get sick of people telling "You can tan, just take sun in fifteen minute increments." For me, it is: Fifteen minutes -Ghost white Fifteen minutes -Ghost white Fifteen minutes -Ghost white Fifteen minutes -Bright red, peeling, and screaming No in-between. The same goes for my friends (and not-friends) that have normal coordination. I took six years of tennis lessons, and never got beyond "suck." I took a year of Kung-Fu, and never got beyond white belt. "Quitters never win, winners never quit, but those who never win, and never quit are idiots." -From a Despair, Inc. Demotivator https://despair.com/collections/retired/products/stupidity https://despair.com/collections/retired/products/stupidity (That's me, at tennis)